Life on Earth 3 - Urbilateria Notes

Urbilateria

  • Common ancestor of all bilaterally-symmetrical Bilaterian animals.

  • 'Ur' = ancient.

  • Protostomes and Deuterostomes are assumed to be sister groups.

  • Understanding Urbilateria involves extrapolating information from Protostomes and Deuterostomes.

Homologous Characters

  • Similarities due to common descent.

  • Characteristics inherited from a common ancestor and shared by two species.

  • Determining when a character evolved is based on the principle of parsimony.

  • Identified through extensive similarities, implying common ancestry rather than convergent evolution.

  • Example: Pentadactyl limb.

  • The probability of two genes being homologous can be statistically calculated, ruling out identical amino acid sequences by chance.

  • Example: Mouse HOX4 gene and its Drosophila homolog, Deformed.

Analogous Characters

  • Evolved independently via convergent evolution.

HOX Genes

  • Highly conserved.

  • Show a close correspondence across the animal kingdom.

  • Specify position in the body along the anterior/posterior (A-P) axis.

  • Gene expression allows cells to determine their location along the A-P axis and what structures should form.

  • Same HOX genes are present in fruit flies and mouse embryos.

  • Homologous genes are expressed in similar locations relative to each other.

Development of Eyes in Vertebrates and Fruit Flies

  • Mutations in the same homologous Pax 6 gene result in Eyeless (fruit flies), Aniridia (humans), and Smalleye (mice).

  • Switching on the Pax 6 gene from a vertebrate (mice) in a fruit fly, or vice versa, has the same effect.

  • Results in extra eyes forming in the wrong places.

Dorso-Ventral Axis (D-V axis) in Fruit Fly and Frog

  • BMP 4 is expressed in the belly of a frog/vertebrate.

  • Vertebrates originated from an inverted invertebrate.

  • Gene expression in chordates is upside down compared to all invertebrates.

  • Conserved gene expression suggests a CNS was present in Urbilateria, common in both protostomes and deuterostomes.

  • The dorso-ventral axis CNS was patterned by SOG/Chordin in Urbilateria.

  • Identifying other examples of homologous concepts between protostomes and deuterostomes helps characterize/extrapolate Urbilateria.

Evo-Devo: Variations on Ancestral Themes

  • Most animals evolved from a common ancestor, Urbilateria.

  • Urbilateria had developmental genetic networks for shaping body plans.

  • Comparative genomics show that many genes present in bilaterian animal ancestors have been lost by individual phyla during evolution.

  • Reconstruction of the archetypal developmental genomic tool-kit present in Urbilateria helps explain the contribution of gene loss and developmental constraints to the evolution of animal body plans.

Introduction

  • Urbilateria: the last common ancestor shared by all bilaterian animals.

  • Must have been a complex creature, possessing most of the developmental gene pathways from which animals are built (Robertis and Sasai, 1996).

  • Urbilateria depicted as a segmented bottom-dwelling (benthic) animal with eyes, CNS, small appendage, open slit-like blastopore.

  • Endoderm shown in red, CNS in dark blue, surface ectoderm in light blue.

The Genetic Tool-kit

  • Sequencing of complete genomes allows powerful inferences to be made.

  • If a gene found in humans/chordates is also found in either an Ecdysozoan or Lophotrochozoan animal, then the gene was present in Urbilateria as well.

  • If a gene is found in cnidarians/chordates, it must also have been present in Urbilateria.

  • Until recently, it was believed that chordates had evolved new classes of genes serving as extracellular antagonists of growth factor signaling (since C. elegans and D. melanogaster lacked (Dkk) and secreted (sFRPs) and Noggin).

  • However, a BLAST search of the mollusc genome reveals it contains several Dkks, sFRPs, and Noggin.

  • These Lophotrochozoan and chordate genes were present in the Urbilateria genome but were secondarily lost in C. elegans and Drosophila (fruit fly).

  • The prominent role of gene loss constitutes a powerful agent of rapid evolutionary change.

Hox Complexes and the A-P Axis

  • E.B. Lewis' discovery that genes controlling the identity of abdominal segments (by repressing the formation of legs and wings) of the fly were clustered in the genome and occupied the same order along the DNA as they were expressed along the A-P body axis.

  • Cloning of vertebrate gene Hox-C6 (Carrasco et al., 1984).

  • The frog gene cloned turns out to have functions similar to fruit fly genes.

  • The first development-controlling gene was identified in vertebrates.

Mechanisms of Segmentation

  • Body plans of vertebrates and invertebrates are metameric, comprised of repeated segments.

  • Arthropod segments and mammalian vertebrae are examples of a unity of plan in animal design (Appel, 1987).

  • Insect and vertebrate metamerism share striking similarities in mode of development.

  • Drosophila first forms parasegments, which are subsequently subdivided so each one forms the posterior and anterior half of the adjoining definitive segments (Carroll et al., 2001).

  • In mammals, vertebrae develop from a portion of the somite - sclerotome.

  • The sclerotome undergoes resegmentation so that the posterior half of one sclerotome and the anterior half of the next one fuse to form the vertebral bodies (Bagnall et al., 1988).

  • Ensures that muscles and tendons generated by each somite span adjoining vertebrae, facilitating movement coordination.

  • Deep homology may exist in the mechanisms of animal segmentation (De Robertis, 1997).

  • Despite profound anatomical differences in resegmentation.

  • Vertebrate segmentation clock driven by Notch signaling (Dale et al., 2003).

  • Notch does not appear to play a main role in Drosophila segmentation.

  • However, Drosophila represents a minority of insects in which the embryo develops rapidly, with all segments developing simultaneously (long germ-band development).

  • Most insects/arthropods form segments by short germ-band development (Damen, 2007).

  • Although it is still premature to conclude that Urbilateria was segmented, the plot has thickened over the past decade (De Robertis, 1997).

  • Search literature on Urbilateria segmentation.

The Chordin-BMP Pathway and the D-V Axis

  • A gradient of D-V positional information regulates the subdivision of the embryo into tissue types.

  • Chordate body plan: ectoderm is subdivided into CNS, neural crest, and epidermis; mesoderm into notochord, somite, intermediate (kidney) and lateral (body wall) mesoderm.

  • In Xenopus and zebrafish, cell differentiation decisions are mediated by a conserved extracellular pathway involving ventral BMPs (bone morphogenetic proteins) and their antagonist Chordin expressed in the dorsal organizer region.

  • The same molecular machinery is utilized, except the homologs are Dpp (Decapentaplegic) and Sog (Short gastrulation); inversion of axis takes place (O'Connor et al., 2006).

  • The Chordin-BMP developmental gene network controls D-V pattern in spiders (Akiyama-Oda & Oda, 2006), hemichordates (Lowe et al., 2006), and amphioxus (Yu et al., 2007).

  • Ancestral to bilateral animals.

The Ancestry of the Bilaterian CNS

  • The CNS forms dorsally in chordates and ventrally in protostomes in regions in which the BMP gradient is low.

  • Suggests that Urbilateria had a differentiated CNS that was inverted during evolution (De Robertis & Sasai, 1996).

  • Questions whether the bilaterian ancestor had a centralized CNS separate from the epidermis or a diffuse one (Lowe et al., 2006).

  • The Arendt group subsequently revealed that annelids share deep homologies with vertebrates.

  • Entire molecular fingerprints have been conserved in D-V CNS neuronal cell-type patterning (Denes et al., 2007).

  • Annelids have neurosecretory cells that secrete Vasopressin, Oxytocin, and Neurophysin prohormone - homologous to cells in the zebrafish hypothalamus.

  • The overall D-V arrangement of neuronal cell types in the CNS is regulated by the BMP gradient in Drosophila (Mizutani et al., 2006) and zebrafish (Little & Mullins, 2006).

  • The Pax6 gene is an upstream regulator of eye development (Gehring, 1998; Arendt & Wittbrodt, 2001).

  • These results support the view that hemichordates lost neural centralization secondarily, and that Urbilateria had an organized CNS with elaborate neuronal cell types inherited by its descendants.

The Genetics of Evolutionary Adaptation

  • Identifying actual mutations that provided variation; selective pressure acted upon in natural animal populations.

cis-Regulatory Mutations

  • Provide the variation for most of the novelties in body form in animal species (Carroll et al., 2001; Davidson, 2006).

  • Achieved by bringing together combinations of transcription factors on DNA regulatory regions - enhancers; control spatial and temporal expression of genes.

  • Tissue-specific enhancer modules can be added/deleted, avoiding pleiotropic effects on other regions.

Historical Constraints

  • Dilemma between homology and convergence in evolution.

  • Homology: two structures arising from an ancestral structure by the action of natural selection/common ancestors.

  • Convergence: driven by functional needs.

  • Example: pentadactyl limb evolved at different times, similar adaptations.

  • Constraints in evolutionary biology should also be considered a positive influence, facilitating effective adaptive responses to the strictures of natural selections.

  • Designated parallelism (Gould, 2002).

Reflections on How Urbilateria Was Constructed

  • Did it contain the complete genetic tool-kit animals now use?

  • Was it segmented?

  • Were the D-V and A-P axes patterned by BMP/Chordin, Wnt, and Hox genes?

  • Did the gene machinery that generates work into similar morphological solutions?