Chapter 9: Organizational Behavior - Foundations of Group Behavior
Foundational Concepts and Classifications of Groups
Core Definition of a Group:
- A group is defined as two or more individuals, interacting and interdependent, who have come together to achieve particular objectives.
- Interaction and interdependence distinguish a functional group from a mere aggregate of unrelated persons.
Formal versus Informal Groups:
- Formal Groups: Work units defined by an organization’s formal structure, featuring designated work assignments, established tasks, and defined hierarchies of authority.
- Informal Groups: Natural social alliances that are neither formally structured nor organizationally determined, emerging spontaneously in the work environment in response to the need for social contact.
Social Identity Theory:
- Examines the conditions under which and reasons why individuals define and perceive themselves as members of specific groups.
- Self-Esteem Linkage: Individuals experience emotional reactions to the successes or failures of their group because personal self-esteem becomes intrinsically bound to group performance.
- Relational Identification: Identity defined through personal connections, mutual relationships, and interpersonal bonds formed with specific group members.
- Collective Identification: Identity derived from direct attachment to the overarching characteristics, values, and status of the collective entity as a whole.
Ingroups and Outgroups:
- Ingroup Dynamics: Members view those who share their social identity as part of the ingroup, cultivating mutual favoritism, trust, and alignment.
- Outgroup Dynamics: Individuals possessing distinct or contrasting social identities are categorized into outgroups, which can become targets of stereotyping, bias, or social competition.
- Social Categorization Process: The psychological mechanism wherein individuals categorize themselves and others into distinct social classifications, generating ingroup favoritism and intergroup dividing lines.
The Punctuated-Equilibrium Model of Group Development
- Applicability and Framework:
- Applies specifically to temporary groups operating with finite deadlines.
- Replaces linear stage models by demonstrating that groups experience long periods of inertia punctuated by brief, revolutionary transitions.

- Chronological Sequence of the Model:
- First Meeting (Point ): The group establishes its fundamental direction, sets behavioral norms, and forms assumptions about the project. This initial framework creates behavioral inertia that persists throughout the early life of the group.
- Phase 1: Characterized by early inertia and low progress. The group stays locked into the original assumptions and patterns set during the initial meeting, operating on autopilot.
- The Midpoint Transition (Point ): Occurs precisely midway between the initial meeting () and the project deadline (). Group members experience a collective realization that half their allocated time is spent. This transition acts as an alarm clock, dropping previous inertia and driving major revisions, new perspectives, and adopted plans.
- Phase 2: A secondary period of equilibrium characterized by execution at higher performance levels, executing the new patterns, strategies, and directions adopted during the transition.
- Completion (Point ): A final burst of concentrated activity immediately preceding the deadline to finalize details and deliver final outcomes.
Group Properties: Roles and Behavioral Expectations
Conceptual Foundations of Roles:
- Role: A defined set of expected behavior patterns attributed to an individual who occupies a given position within a social unit.
- Individuals enact multiple, distinct roles simultaneously across work, family, and civic domains.
Perceptions and Expectations:
- Role Perception: An individual’s internal view and interpretation regarding how they are supposed to act in a given situation, frequently formed through external cues, observation, and personal schemas.
- Role Expectations: The shared beliefs and standards held by others concerning how a specific person ought to behave in a designated situation.
- The Psychological Contract: An unwritten agreement that defines the mutual expectations between employees and employers, specifying what management expects from staff and what workers expect in return (e.g., resources, fair pay, respect).
Role Incompatibility:
- Role Conflict: A situation in which an individual faces divergent, incompatible role expectations where fulfilling one makes fulfilling another difficult.
- Interrole Conflict: A specific manifestation where the expectations placed on an individual across distinct, separate groups or domains (such as career responsibilities versus parental duties) are mutually opposed.
Group Properties: Norms and Behavioral Influence
Nature and Scope of Group Norms:
- Norms: Acceptable standards of behavior established and shared by the members of a group, dictating what ought and ought not to be done under specific circumstances.
- Norms exert powerful informal control, guiding performance expectations, appearance standards, social arrangements, and resource allocations.
Norms and Emotional Alignment:
- Norms govern the expression and internal experience of emotions within collectives.
- Group members learn to interpret, experience, and display shared emotions uniformly, creating consistent affective climates.
- Empirical studies establish a reciprocal influence loop in task groups: individual affective states influence the collective emotional tone, and the collective group emotion shapes individual emotional reactions.
Conformity and the Asch Studies:
- Investigated by Solomon Asch to test group pressure on individual judgment using comparison line cards.

Experimental Design and Findings:
- Subjects were asked to match reference line against three comparison lines (, , and ).
- When confederates uniformly chose an obviously incorrect comparison line, naive subjects showed substantial conformity by agreeing with the incorrect consensus, demonstrating the power of normative influence over objective sensory evidence.
Normative Influence in the Hawthorne Studies:
- Conducted at the Western Electric Company's Hawthorne Works.
- Established that worker productivity is heavily driven by informal group norms rather than solely by physical working conditions or financial incentives.
- Groups established informal output quotas to prevent management from speeding up the line or lowering wage rates, actively disciplining high-producing "rate busters" and low-producing "chiseler" peers to enforce behavioral conformity.
Positive Norms and Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR):
- Organizations deploy Corporate Social Responsibility initiatives with the explicit goal of having organizational values hold normative sway over employee attitudes.
- When employees internalize positive organizational norms, the probability of constructive social impact increases exponentially across operations.
Typology of Workplace Deviance:
- Norms can institutionalize negative or destructive practices across four recognized categories:
- Production Deviance: Violating norms regarding how work is completed, including leaving early, intentionally working slowly, and wasting company resources.
- Property Deviance: Damaging or unauthorized use of tangible assets, including sabotage, lying about hours worked, and outright stealing from the organization.
- Political Deviance: Interpersonal actions that disadvantage others at a political or social level, including showing favoritism, gossiping, spreading rumors, and blaming coworkers.
- Personal Aggression: Explicitly hostile interpersonal actions, including sexual harassment, verbal abuse, and stealing from coworkers.
- Norms can institutionalize negative or destructive practices across four recognized categories:
Workplace Reporting Barriers:
- Gallup poll data shows why employees avoid reporting unethical behavior, ranked by frequency:
- Belief that no action would be taken:
- Fear of retaliation:
- Preference not to answer:
- Uncertainty whether the behavior constituted a violation:
- Negative past experience reporting a compliance or ethics issue:
- Directly addressed the offender to resolve the matter personally:
- Desire to avoid getting into trouble:
- Perception that reporting was too much hassle:
- Lack of knowledge on how to file a report:
- Gallup poll data shows why employees avoid reporting unethical behavior, ranked by frequency:
Norms Across Cultural Contexts:
- Collectivist cultures show higher levels of compliance with group norms than individualist cultures.
- Cultural normative orientations are not fixed; an individual’s behavioral tendencies can shift even after living in a different society for an extended duration.
Group Properties: Status and Size
Status Foundations:
- Status: A socially defined position, tier, or rank assigned to groups or group members by others.
- Operates as a significant motivator and shapes internal communication hierarchies.
Status Characteristics Theory:
- Status differences derive primarily from three distinct sources:
- Power over Others: Individuals who control organizational resources and command authoritative decisions carry high status.
- Ability to Contribute to Group Goals: Members whose contributions, skills, or assets are vital to collective success hold higher status.
- Personal Characteristics: Individual traits deemed valuable by the group (such as intelligence, charisma, physical appearance, or reputation) enhance status.
- Status differences derive primarily from three distinct sources:
Behavioral Consequences of Status:
- Status and Norm Deviation: High-status individuals enjoy greater psychological freedom to deviate from group norms and ignore conformity pressures than lower-status peers, provided their deviance does not harm overall progress.
- Status and Group Interaction: High-status individuals behave more assertively, speak out more frequently, direct conversations, and critique other members.
- Status Inequity: Perceived injustice in status distribution creates social disequilibrium, triggering interpersonal resentment, lower motivation, and corrective behaviors aimed at restoring balance.
Impact of Group Size:
- Large Groups: Effective for gathering broad, diverse information, generating large pools of ideas, and problem exploration.
- Small Groups: Faster, more productive, and superior for processing input and implementing specific operational tasks.
- Social Loafing: The tendency for individuals to expend less effort when working collectively on a task than when working alone.
- Caused by the dispersion of responsibility, where individual effort cannot be easily isolated or measured against collective outcomes.
Group Properties: Cohesion and Diversity
Group Cohesion:
- The degree to which group members are attracted to one another and motivated to stay united.
- Cohesion by itself does not guarantee superior organizational performance; its effects depend on prevailing performance norms.
The Cohesion-Performance Norms Matrix:
- High Cohesiveness and High Performance Norms: Results in high productivity; members hold each other accountable to rigorous goals.
- Low Cohesiveness and High Performance Norms: Results in moderate productivity; individuals work effectively, but lack collective synergy.
- High Cohesiveness and Low Performance Norms: Results in low productivity; high mutual support solidifies norms against high output.
- Low Cohesiveness and Low Performance Norms: Results in moderate to low productivity; individual drift and poor standards combine to minimize output.
Group Decision Making: Dynamics and Techniques
Strengths of Group Decision Making:
- Generates more complete information and deeper knowledge reserves.
- Brings a broader diversity of perspectives, approaches, and alternatives to bear.
- Cultivates greater acceptance and buy-in for final solutions, simplifying implementation.
Weaknesses of Group Decision Making:
- Consumes significantly more time than unilateral individual decisions.
- Creates social conformity pressures that stifle independent critique.
- Can be hijacked by the outsized dominance of a few vocal or high-status members.
- Suffers from ambiguous responsibility, diluting accountability for negative outcomes.
Decision Evaluation Criteria:
- Accuracy: Group decisions tend to be more accurate than the average member's choice, though rarely superior to the group's most capable specialist.
- Speed: Individual decision-making is consistently faster.
- Creativity: Groups regularly unlock higher creative combinations than individuals working in isolation.
- Acceptance: Solutions chosen by groups secure wider acceptance and support than autocratic decisions.
Pathologies of Group Decision Making:
- Groupthink: A deterioration of mental efficiency, reality testing, and moral judgment caused by in-group pressures to reach consensus. The drive for unanimity suppresses the critical appraisal of unusual, minority, or dissenting viewpoints.
- Groupshift (Group Polarization): A post-discussion shift in the group’s final decision toward a more extreme position than members originally favored, moving either toward cautious conservatism or high risk.
Structured Group Decision Techniques:
- Interacting Groups: Members meet face-to-face and rely on verbal and nonverbal communication. Often leads to self-censorship, conformity pressures, and early convergence.
- Brainstorming: Designed to overcome conformity constraints:
- The group leader states the core problem clearly.
- Members are instructed to freely propose as many alternatives as possible without hesitation.
- Direct criticism and immediate evaluation are strictly prohibited.
- Participants build upon each other's contributions and are encouraged to "think the unusual."
- Nominal Group Technique (NGT): Restricts verbal debate and interpersonal communication during early decision stages, ensuring members work independently while physically present:
- Step 1: Each member writes down their independent ideas concerning the problem in complete silence.
- Step 2: Each member presents one idea to the group in turn without discussion, recording it publicly until all ideas are cataloged.
- Step 3: The group discusses the cataloged ideas strictly for clarification and assessment.
- Step 4: Each member independently rank-orders the ideas using a private, silent ballot.
- Step 5: The final group decision is determined mathematically by the idea securing the highest aggregate ranking.
- Performance Note: Nominal groups systematically outperform brainstorming groups in idea quantity and quality.
Comparative Assessment Across Group Formats:
- Number and Quality of Ideas: Interacting = Low; Brainstorming = Moderate; Nominal = High.
- Social Pressure: Interacting = High; Brainstorming = Low; Nominal = Moderate.
- Money Costs: Interacting = Low; Brainstorming = Low; Nominal = Low.
- Speed: Interacting = Moderate; Brainstorming = Moderate; Nominal = Moderate.
- Task Orientation: Interacting = Low; Brainstorming = High; Nominal = High.
- Potential for Interpersonal Conflict: Interacting = High; Brainstorming = Low; Nominal = Moderate.
- Commitment to Final Solution: Interacting = High; Brainstorming = Not applicable; Nominal = Moderate.
- Development of Group Cohesiveness: Interacting = High; Brainstorming = High; Nominal = Moderate.
Managerial Implications for Group Dynamics
Managing Identity and Ingroup Dynamics:
- Nurture shared identification within functional work units.
- Actively defuse perceived identity threats.
- Prevent biased ingroup favoritism that causes interdepartmental silos or outgroup exclusion.
Navigating the Group Life Cycle:
- Expect new groups to experience periods of adjustment and shifting development phases.
- Anticipate that newly assembled teams rarely function smoothly without deliberate role assignment, onboarding, and training.
- Recognize whether a group is stalled in early Phase 1 inertia or reaching a midpoint transition, stepping in with targeted structural interventions to break deadlocks.
Role Clarity and Psychological Contracting:
- Align internal role perceptions with external expectations to avoid friction and overlap.
- Explicitly define and honor the reciprocal terms of the psychological contract, actively working to repair trust when breaches occur.
- Provide resources and flexible frameworks to resolve acute role conflicts and competing institutional demands.
Managing Norms and Status Differentials:
- Monitor informal normative trends, recognizing that unwritten codes often drive daily actions more than official company handbooks.
- Model ethical behaviors, reinforcing corporate social responsibility norms throughout operations.
- Keep high-status individuals from monopolizing conversations, bypassing corporate ethics, or intimidating colleagues.
- Foster psychological safety so lower-status personnel can challenge ideas, report infractions, and propose alternative solutions.
Optimizing Size, Cohesiveness, and Collaborative Formats:
- Size teams to fit the specific objective: lean units for fast execution, larger groups for diverse input.
- Structure clear individual deliverables within teams to reduce social loafing.
- Build group cohesiveness alongside high performance norms to prevent shared complacency.
- Select structured formats like the Nominal Group Technique when tackling complex issues to mitigate groupthink and prevent groupshift distortions.
Questions & Discussion
Discussion Question 1: Have you experienced groupthink or groupshift situations in any of the student organizations in which you participate? How has it affected the organization’s goals?
- Core Context: Evaluates how conformity pressures lead campus groups to overlook risks, suppress alternative ideas, or adopt extreme plans during projects.
Discussion Question 2: Imagine that you’ve been asked to participate in a group where you know social loafing has been a problem. How would you address the issue?
- Core Context: Explores tactics for improving personal accountability, including setting visible individual metrics, breaking deliverables into tracked sub-tasks, peer reviews, and tying rewards to individual contributions.
Discussion Question 3: Discuss interrole conflict as it applies to student athletes. How do their demands for practice and competition conflict with demands from professors and other academic entities?
- Core Context: Analyzes the tension between competing roles, contrasting athletic schedules (mandatory practices, travel, games) with academic expectations (classes, exams, team projects), highlighting how time constraints and opposing authority figures create systemic role stress.