Islam

Common Law:

  • England gave us a tradition in which courts and earlier judicial decisions became especially important

    • Our question was: “What have courts already said?”


Civil Law:

  • Rome and continental Europe gave us a tradition emphasizing organized written codes

    • Our question was: “What does the code say?”


Mecca: a city in the Arabian Peninsula, in what is now Saudi Arabia

The Quraysh held enormous influence in the city and were closely connected to the Kaaba, the sacred sanctuary at the center of Mecca

The Kaaba attracted pilgrims from across Arabia


  • As Muhammad gained followers, opposition from powerful members of the Quraysh intensified

  • His message challenged traditional religious practices, but it also challenged parts of the existing social order

Muhammad had eventually lost important family protection

The protection came from his uncle.

Muhammad belonged to the Banu Hashim clan of the Quraysh. His uncle, Abu Talib, was not a follower of his practice

  • After wife, Khadijah passes, Islamic tradition remembers it as the year of sorrow.

Around 620 CE, Muhammad travels to Ta’if, a city southeast of Mecca. They rejected him.

The Invitation Comes from Yathrib

About 280 miles from Mecca was an oasis settlement call Yathrib.

  • Muhammad was used as a mediator between the tribes Aws and Khazraj

  • Quraysh plotted to killed Muhammad

  • The migration to Yathrib in 622 CE is known as the Hijrah

  • Yathrib soon becomes known as Medina


Muhammad confronts the real problems of Medina

The Qur’an is not a modern law

It is not organized like

Chapter 1: Murder

Chapter 2: Theft

Chapter 3: Assault

And it does not contain an explicit rule for every situation a society may encounter

9/14/26

Sunnah: The normative example associated with the Prophet Muhammad

  • His teachings, actions, and approvals became important for understanding how Islamic principles should be applied

Haddith: Reports transmitting statements, actions, or approvals attributed to Muhammad

  • Scholars developed methods for evaluating the reliability and transmission of these reports

Dispose of in accordance with all local, state and federal regulations or contract with a licensed chemical disposal agency.

Question: What happens when the Qur’an doesn’t directly answer the question AND isn’t a clear example from Muhammad?

Answer: IJMA: Consensus

The basic idea”

  • Qualified Islamic legal scholars examine the sources

  • They interpret and apply those sources

  • Over time, scholarly consensus can carry leal authority

Qiyas: reasoning by anology

 “ Is there a situation in the Qur’an close enough to an established rule or principle that we can apply the same reasoning?”

Qur’an: Revelation

Sunna: Muhammad’s example

Ijma: Consensus

Qiyas: Analogy


Qisas/Diya:

Qiya: Eye for an eye

Diya: Financial compensation

Hudud: A limited category of offenses traditionally associated with prescribed punishments and demanding legal/evidentiary

Fiqh: Human understanding


/