Study Notes on the Whitewashing of Social Work History
The Whitewashing of Social Work History
Abstract
Severe Racial Inequity: Characterizes contributions of ethnic minorities to U.S. history, connected to White Supremacist ideologies and practices.
Higher Education Impact: These disparities perpetuated through textbooks and pedagogy.
Historical Narrative: Social work literature predominantly showcases a whitewashed history, lacking contributions from BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and other People of Color).
Implications: Educators need to include a racially diverse history in social work to prevent reinforcing White Supremacy among predominantly White students.
Attention Needed: Social work education must recognize the contributions of BIPOC individuals to improve self-efficacy and representation.
Aim: This study reviews the historical narratives and recommends strategies for integrating diverse contributions into social work education.
Keywords
Dismantling racism
Social work history
BIPOC contributions
Introduction to Issues of White Supremacy
Symbols of White Supremacy: Not limited to physical emblems (e.g., confederate flag); also includes narratives that position Whites as innovators and BIPOC as receivers.
Historical Perspective: Academic and vocational institutions attribute roots and innovations primarily to White individuals.
Social Work's Inception: The narrative is framed by the same dominant ideologies, which undermines the roles of BIPOC in the social welfare field.
Educational Impact: Failure to acknowledge BIPOC contributions discourages diversity in the profession.
Institutionalized Racism in Documenting History
Importance of Accurate History: Distorted historical accounts influence the trajectory of social work, informed by inherent biases in narratives about past contributions.
Impact of White Narratives: The predominance of white authors and educators in social work literature perpetuates stereotypes about BIPOC communities.
Statistics:
According to the CSWE's 2019 report, 61.1% of full-time faculty and 58.3% of part-time faculty identify as White, also showing a majority of White students in social work programs.
Consequences: Reinforcement of the notion of BIPOC inferiority leads to negative impacts on BIPOC students' aspirations in social work.
Historical Context of Social Work and Racism
Social Work's Inception: Dates back to mid to late 1800s; traditionally seen as originating from frameworks in Europe and the United States.
Debatable Origins: Difficulty in defining early social work practices; often tied to religious principles in charitable initiatives (e.g., orphanages, hospitals).
Omission of Indigenous Practices: Indigenous cultures historically utilizing communal care structures often excluded from formal recognition in social work histories.
Racial Science Impact: Racial theories used in the 1800s supported oppression and maintained racial hierarchies, sidelining BIPOC contributions.
Founding Figures of Social Work
Jane Addams (1860-1935): Recognized for her role in social reform, often heralded as a central figure in social work’s history.
Mary Ellen Richmond (1861-1928): Noted for contributions to casework and social service fields, yet also whitewashed in historical records.
John Augustus: Another early influencer in the criminal justice aspect of social work; recognized for substantial contributions yet often excluded from broader discussions.
Bias in Historical Recognition
Frederick Douglass: Noted for his civil rights activism; his contributions are frequently overlooked in social work narratives despite their relevance.
Intersection of Activism and Recognition: White women like Addams and Richmond received accolades while BIPOC leaders faced societal backlash.
Impact of Public Recognition: BIPOC activists (e.g., Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.) often oppressed, contrasting the recognition awarded to white activists.
BIPOC Social Work Forerunners
W.E.B. Du Bois: Critically important in advocating for racial equality and social reform yet rarely acknowledged in social work history.
Eugene Kinckle Jones (1885-1954): A leader in community advocacy through the National Urban League, significant yet not widely recognized in curricula.
Modern Day Efforts to Uncover BIPOC Contributions
Dr. Crystal Coles: Uses prosopography to explore African American women's contributions in southern U.S. social work history.
Collective Contributions: Highlighting how historical collaboration among BIPOC women established social systems against oppression.
Significance of Oral Tradition: Emphasis on listening to marginalized histories can yield more inclusive narratives.
Examples of Contributions:
Lucy Goode Brooks: Founder of Friends Asylum for Colored Children.
Grace Evelyn Arents: Established housing associations for workers.
Integrating and Honoring BIPOC Contributions
National Association of Black Social Workers (NABSW): Advocates for recognizing and integrating BIPOC contributions into social work education.
Need for Curriculum Revision: Emphasis on the importance of a curriculum that reflects the contributions of BIPOC and challenges existing misconceptions.
Examples of often overlooked foundational practices in social work that originated in BIPOC communities.
Recommendations for Future Research and Education
Interrogating Historical Narratives: A critical lens is needed to assess how educational materials uphold White Supremacy.
Questioning Recognized Founders: Scrutinizing why certain individuals are celebrated while others, notably BIPOC, are omitted.
Emphasizing Collective Contributions: Recognizing the collaborative efforts of marginalized groups in crafting social welfare practices.
Conclusion
Need for History to Reflect Reality: The need for inclusive narratives that champion the contributions of all social work founders.
Future of Social Work: Rethinking the designation of historical figures as icons must occur to allow for recognition that supports current social justice initiatives.