Communism Notes

Communism

Communism vs. Fascism

Here's a comparison of Communism and Fascism, outlining their key differences:

Feature

Communism

Fascism

Method of Gaining Power

Violent revolution

Abuse of the electoral system and terror

Method of Rule

Single-party Dictatorship

Single-party Dictatorship

Source of Beliefs

Writings of Marx, Lenin, Mao

Writings of Mussolini, Rocco, Sorel

Goals

Triumph of the working classes, world revolution, the overthrow of capitalism

National greatness, constant expansion

Economy

State controlled, no private property, favors proletariat, emphasis on equality

State regulation of private enterprise, favors capitalists, natural inequalities

Appeal

Working class, peasants, intelligentsia

Lower middle class, some upper class and clergy

Scope

A worldwide movement, opposed to nationalism

A series of national movements, stresses nationalism

Belief in Reason

Humans are basically rational

Humans are basically irrational

Political Characteristics of Communism

Communism is both an economic theory and a political system with the following characteristics:

  • Government actions for the benefit of all

  • Theoretically democratic

  • Equal rights – Bill of Rights (many freedoms and rights guaranteed but not enforced)

  • Periodic elections (high turnout, but often only 1 candidate – one party state)

  • Control of media and education

  • Need to educate (indoctrinate) the youth



Justification of Communism

  • Based on established theories of Marx – communist system creates a society that encourages creativity and self-awareness (because you are not worried about mundane things).

  • Democracy is based on the idea that all people are equal, not freedom.

  • Rapid industrialization proved the superiority of the system

  • Avoidance of Great Depression

  • Ability to defeat the Nazis

Conditions in Russia Leading to the Bolshevik Revolution

  • Part of Europe but not industrializing at same pace

  • Awareness of Enlightenment ideals

  • Dissatisfaction with limited reforms made by Tzar (economic reforms outpaced the political reforms)

    • Civil rights, universal suffrage, and elected Duma were introduced in 1905 but suppressed.

  • Losing the battles of World War One

Bolshevik Rise to Power

  • Two revolutions – one to overthrow the Tzar, the next to establish Bolshevik rule.

  • Bolsheviks gained support of peasants and soldiers through Lenin – “peace, land, bread.”

  • 5-year civil war

  • War Communism: swift transfer to communist system (to support civil war efforts).

  • NEP – Lenin sees the dramatic transformation is not working, returns to minor forms of capitalism (e.g., farmers selling extra produce).

Stalin’s USSR

  • Vision: Rejected the NEP (need to devote to the communist ideology)

  • Point to the strength of communism during the Great Depression

  • Indoctrination/propaganda:

    • Used to promote the cult of personality (Stalin as a strong man, yet father-figure).

    • Also used to denounce opponents.

  • Direction of Popular Discontent:

    • Collectivize farms to support rapid industrialization.

    • Kulak revolts, reduced output, Ukrainian famine

    • During the Cold War – blamed the US for problems.

Controlled Participation in Stalin's USSR

  • Only one party – CPSU

  • Voters handed ballot with approved candidates name on it

  • If you wanted to vote for someone else, you had to scratch out the name and write another: with everyone watching you.

  • 6% of the population were members of CPSU (starting at a young age).

  • Perks: bigger apartment, better food, special medical services, nice vacation, better education for children (approximately 1% also had rights to overseas travel, foreign currency, and personal servants).

  • Force:

    • Elimination of opposition (early removal of opposition will allow the socialist society to become truly communist).

    • Great Purge

    • KGB, gulags

Rejection of Liberalism

  • Avoided the Great Depression

  • Greater equality - didn’t have the race riots or protests like the US Civil Rights Movement. Their women gained equality long before women were treated equally here in Canada.

  • Literacy and health care were superior to many liberal nations.

  • The rejection of liberalism made sense when Stalin was ruling the country.

The Fall of Communism

  • The collapse of the communist political system will be studied during the Cold War.

Stalin Video

  • Pros of Stalin's rule

  • Cons of Stalin's rule

  • Do the ends justify the means?