Extinction and Recovery Notes

Extinction and Differential Reinforcement

  • This week's topics: extinction and differential reinforcement.
  • These are often combined in clinical settings.
  • Rationale: stop reinforcing undesired behavior and teach an alternative behavior to access reinforcers.

Reinforcement and Punishment

  • Reinforcement and punishment are consequences that influence the future selection of responses.
  • Basic principle of operant learning: learning from consequences.
    • Repeat behaviors with desirable outcomes.
    • Avoid behaviors with undesirable outcomes.

Extinction

  • What happens when an organism associates a response with a consequence, but the consequence is no longer available?
  • Example: a child screams, and the parent usually comforts them, but suddenly that stops.

Today's Lecture Objectives

  • Explain what extinction is.
  • Considerations when implementing extinction.
  • Expected changes with extinction implementation.

Definition of Extinction

  • Not species extinction.
  • Behavior analytic definition: no longer delivering a reinforcer for a previously reinforced behavior, leading to a decreased frequency of the behavior.

Examples of Extinction

  • Job stops paying you: you eventually stop going.
  • Empty beverage: you eventually stop trying to drink from it.
  • Dog barks, and you pet it to calm it down. If you stop petting the dog when it barks, it will probably bark more for a while, but eventually stop.
  • Driving to a coffee hut for a latte that is now closed: you might try a few times, but eventually, you'll stop.

Effects of Implementing Extinction

  • Novel behaviors may arise as the organism tries something else to get the reinforcer.
  • Extinction burst: a sharp increase in the frequency of the behavior after extinction is applied.
    • The organism tries the response more frequently.
    • A spike in the response rate, then it drops off.
    • Important consideration in human services settings with aggressive behaviors.
  • Spontaneous recovery: recurrence of a behavior that's been placed on extinction after a pause.
  • Consider how the individual can access the reinforcer. Removing the ability to get the reinforcement at all isn't kind; offer means to access it appropriately.

Extinction vs. Punishment

  • Extinction is a nonevent: simply not providing the reinforcer.
    • Not taking anything away or adding anything.
    • Keep the environment neutral as though the behavior didn't happen.
  • Punishment is a penalty: removing something or applying an aversive stimulus.
    • Saying "no" to a dog when it barks is punishment.
    • Ignoring the dog is extinction.
  • Both result in a decrease in frequency.
  • Punishment is typically faster, but it has downfalls.

Ethical Considerations

  • Suppressing stimming: stimming is calming for autistic people, and the field is moving away from trying to make individuals behave like neurotypical peers.
    • Less common to treat stimming that doesn't interfere with the individual's life or cause harm.
    • Different story if dangerous or interferes with learning.
  • Leaving a child to cry: the principle of extinction still holds, but it's not the only way to address nighttime crying and should be age-appropriate.
  • Fastening children to chairs with seat belts: Indicates a lack of assent; not as commonly done anymore.