ART APP READING 1

Definition of Art

  • Art encompasses social, historical, institutional, or intentional characteristics.

  • A comprehensive theory of art addresses various issues, including defining art and artistic value.

Historical Background

  • The notion of defining art has roots tracing back to ancient philosophers like Plato and Aristotle.

  • Early definitions did not align with the contemporary understanding of 'fine arts', which solidified during the eighteenth century.

  • Plato and Aristotle described poetry, painting, music, and architecture without establishing a strict definition of art.

  • During the Renaissance and Enlightenment period, the concept of fine arts evolved, prompting definitions based on representation.

  • Key figures like Hutcheson, Batteux, and Kant contributed to early definitions focusing on representation.

    • Kant's Definition: Distinguished fine art as aesthetic arts focused on pleasure derived from representations.

Theory of Art vs. Definition of Art

  • A theory of art is broader and may not focus directly on defining art.

  • Theories often address:

    • Questions of value: Unique values art offers.

    • Cognitive issues: Understanding an artwork and valid interpretations.

    • Emotional responses and the cognitive development encouraged by art.

Concepts of Art

  • Collingwood’s Definition (1938): Art is an activity of clarifying emotions, escaping from general types to specific feelings.

    • This challenges the traditional mimetic ideal by focusing on artist-audience emotional communication rather than medium.

    • Issues arise from defining expressiveness too narrowly, ruling out significant works from the Western tradition.

Art as Expression

  • Traditional expression theories claim that art expresses emotions, often aligning the artist's feelings with the work.

  • Recent perspectives suggest art can express emotions perceived by audiences without reflecting the artist's intention.

    • [Danto's Contributions]: Expression theories redefined in a context moving beyond mere representation.

Formalism

  • Growing alongside expression theories, formalism focuses on the form of artworks and its significance.

  • High modernism (1880-1960) celebrated form over representational content, emphasizing the construction of works through color, line, and shapes.

  • Clive Bell’s Definition: Art is identified by 'significant form' that produces aesthetic emotions in the viewer.

    • This definition invites critiques regarding the exclusivity of beautiful versus meaningful works.

Aesthetic Definitions

  • Aesthetic definitions link art with the experience of beauty or aesthetic value.

  • Addressing movements that challenge aesthetics (e.g., Dadaism, conceptual art), defenders argue that realization of aesthetic properties remains present even in apparent non-aesthetic objects.

  • Examples include:

    • Duchamp's readymades emphasizing the questioning of aesthetic values.

Anti-Essentialism

  • Emerging in the mid-20th century, this perspective argues against defining art with necessary and sufficient conditions.

  • Notable proponent Morris Weitz suggests that concepts related to art are 'open-textured' and lack rigid boundaries.

  • Rejected definitions prioritize family resemblance and the evolving nature of art.

Historical Approaches and the Revival of Functionalism

  • Functionality in defining art surfaces in revisionist perspectives, suggesting that art may serve varying foundational roles across contexts.

  • Levinson proposes an historical view where intentions of artists and relations to prior artworks define what is art.

  • Stecker and Davies extend the functionalist definition to include the evolution of artistic roles in historical contexts.

Danto and Dickie: Institutional Definitions

  • Danto's Insights: Art cannot be strictly delineated by exhibited properties; it relies on context and interpretation from historical perspectives.

  • Dickie’s Institutional Definition: A work of art is defined by its recognition and the conferred status from the artworld, incorporating aspects like audience interpretation and historical context.

    • Both philosophers emphasize the importance of relating artworks to their historical and social settings.

Conclusion on Art's Definition

  • Overall, contemporary discussions lean towards flexible definitions rather than strict boundaries.

  • The consensus may mark a shift from the pursuit of an essential definition to a more pragmatic understanding of art, focusing on the interplay of various attributes and contexts.