ART APP READING 1
Definition of Art
Art encompasses social, historical, institutional, or intentional characteristics.
A comprehensive theory of art addresses various issues, including defining art and artistic value.
Historical Background
The notion of defining art has roots tracing back to ancient philosophers like Plato and Aristotle.
Early definitions did not align with the contemporary understanding of 'fine arts', which solidified during the eighteenth century.
Plato and Aristotle described poetry, painting, music, and architecture without establishing a strict definition of art.
During the Renaissance and Enlightenment period, the concept of fine arts evolved, prompting definitions based on representation.
Key figures like Hutcheson, Batteux, and Kant contributed to early definitions focusing on representation.
Kant's Definition: Distinguished fine art as aesthetic arts focused on pleasure derived from representations.
Theory of Art vs. Definition of Art
A theory of art is broader and may not focus directly on defining art.
Theories often address:
Questions of value: Unique values art offers.
Cognitive issues: Understanding an artwork and valid interpretations.
Emotional responses and the cognitive development encouraged by art.
Concepts of Art
Collingwood’s Definition (1938): Art is an activity of clarifying emotions, escaping from general types to specific feelings.
This challenges the traditional mimetic ideal by focusing on artist-audience emotional communication rather than medium.
Issues arise from defining expressiveness too narrowly, ruling out significant works from the Western tradition.
Art as Expression
Traditional expression theories claim that art expresses emotions, often aligning the artist's feelings with the work.
Recent perspectives suggest art can express emotions perceived by audiences without reflecting the artist's intention.
[Danto's Contributions]: Expression theories redefined in a context moving beyond mere representation.
Formalism
Growing alongside expression theories, formalism focuses on the form of artworks and its significance.
High modernism (1880-1960) celebrated form over representational content, emphasizing the construction of works through color, line, and shapes.
Clive Bell’s Definition: Art is identified by 'significant form' that produces aesthetic emotions in the viewer.
This definition invites critiques regarding the exclusivity of beautiful versus meaningful works.
Aesthetic Definitions
Aesthetic definitions link art with the experience of beauty or aesthetic value.
Addressing movements that challenge aesthetics (e.g., Dadaism, conceptual art), defenders argue that realization of aesthetic properties remains present even in apparent non-aesthetic objects.
Examples include:
Duchamp's readymades emphasizing the questioning of aesthetic values.
Anti-Essentialism
Emerging in the mid-20th century, this perspective argues against defining art with necessary and sufficient conditions.
Notable proponent Morris Weitz suggests that concepts related to art are 'open-textured' and lack rigid boundaries.
Rejected definitions prioritize family resemblance and the evolving nature of art.
Historical Approaches and the Revival of Functionalism
Functionality in defining art surfaces in revisionist perspectives, suggesting that art may serve varying foundational roles across contexts.
Levinson proposes an historical view where intentions of artists and relations to prior artworks define what is art.
Stecker and Davies extend the functionalist definition to include the evolution of artistic roles in historical contexts.
Danto and Dickie: Institutional Definitions
Danto's Insights: Art cannot be strictly delineated by exhibited properties; it relies on context and interpretation from historical perspectives.
Dickie’s Institutional Definition: A work of art is defined by its recognition and the conferred status from the artworld, incorporating aspects like audience interpretation and historical context.
Both philosophers emphasize the importance of relating artworks to their historical and social settings.
Conclusion on Art's Definition
Overall, contemporary discussions lean towards flexible definitions rather than strict boundaries.
The consensus may mark a shift from the pursuit of an essential definition to a more pragmatic understanding of art, focusing on the interplay of various attributes and contexts.