On-Site Detention Plan-Checking Training Session

Session Context & Objectives

  • Internal training session focused on checking an On-Site Detention (OSD) design that has already been lodged.
  • Only the OSD component of a broader civil plan set is reviewed; other civil aspects (earthworks, roads, etc.) are assumed complete.
  • Trainees (Patrick and colleagues) learn to:
    • Read plans, pit schedules and cross-sections.
    • Extract governing parameters supplied by council via OSD 4 software.
    • Populate Council’s in-house Excel “Detention Volume Calculation” template.
    • Confirm that the design meets both Permissible Site Discharge (PSD) and Required Storage Volume criteria.
    • Recognise how pits, pipes and tanks contribute to total storage, and why ≥ 60 % must be underground.

Key Terminology & Symbols

  • OSD (On-Site Detention) – temporary storage system that throttles storm-water runoff so post-development peak discharge ≤ pre-development target.
  • PSD (Permissible Site Discharge) – maximum flow rate council allows to leave the site.
  • Storage Volume – minimum volume that must be provided to attenuate the design storm.
  • Flow Control Pit (FCP) – chambered structure with inlet & outlet compartments; outlet has an orifice sized to limit flow.
  • Invert Level (IL) – internal base level of a pit/pipe.
  • Cover Level (CL) – finished surface level above a pit.
  • Top Water Level (TWL) – maximum water surface in detention system during the critical storm.
  • Critical Duration – storm duration that produces worst-case storage or discharge.
  • MC2 / Multicell – proprietary flow-control device; performance read from manufacturer’s chart.

Step-by-Step Plan-Checking Workflow

1. Gather Required Documents & Software

  1. Civil drawings (layout, long-sections, pit schedule, cross-sections).
  2. OSD 4 report issued by design engineer (contains PSD, storage, critical duration, etc.).
  3. Council Excel templates located via:
    Excel → Templates → “Detention Volume Calculation”.
    • Sheet 1 = calc engine (contains live formulas with cell tool-tips).
    • Sheet 2 = explanation of equations (e.g.
    Rational Method, continuity, orifice flow, Darcy-Weisbach, etc.).

2. Enter Governing Parameters From OSD 4

  • The very bottom line of the OSD 4 print-out summaries the design targets. Example site values:
    • PSDreq=8.79  Ls1PSD_{req} = 8.79\;L\,s^{-1}
    • Vreq=4.34  m3V_{req} = 4.34\;m^{3}
    • Critical duration, total hard surface area, etc. captured for reference.

3. Establish Hydraulic Levels

For every pit (starting at the outlet and working upstream):

  1. Read Cover Level & Depth from the pit schedule.
  2. Compute Invert Level via IL=CLDepthIL = CL - Depth.
  3. Record TWL (usually the top of the baffle/batter wall separating inlet & outlet chambers).

4. Quantify Storage in Each Element

4.1 Pits (Chamber Storage)
  • Typical rectangular pit volume:
    Vpit=Width×Length×(TWLIL)V_{pit} = Width \times Length \times (TWL - IL)
  • Example – Pit 7 (FCP):
    • Width = 0.6m0.6\,m
    • Length = 1.8m1.8\,m
    • TWL = 109.75\,m,
      IL = 109.01\,m\;\Rightarrow\;(TWL-IL)=0.74\,m
    • Vpit7=0.6×1.8×0.74=0.80m3  (rounded  0.74m3 in session)V_{pit7}=0.6\times1.8\times0.74=0.80\,m^{3}\;(rounded\;0.74\,m^{3}\text{ in session})
4.2 Pipes (In-Line Storage)
  1. Identify pipes whose upstream end is connected to an inlet chamber (storage-side). Pipes bypassing directly to the outlet do not count.
  2. Use the higher IL of the two connecting pits for conservatism.
  3. If multiple parallel barrels exist, multiply the length by the number of barrels.
  4. Volume per pipe:
    Vpipe=π4D2LV_{pipe}=\tfrac{\pi}{4} D^{2} L
    (ensure DD in metres, LL total length in metres).
4.3 Tanks
  • Rainwater or reuse tanks sitting above natural ground = above-ground storage and may be excluded if ≥ 60 % underground rule already satisfied.
  • Underground tanks can be included provided they drain only through the throttled outlet.

5. Validate Underground-Storage Percentage

  • Spreadsheet automatically reports % underground.
  • Requirement: Underground fraction60%\text{Underground fraction}\ge 60\%.

6. Check PSD via Orifice (or MC2) Sizing

6.1 Orifice Method (common pits)
  • Designer supplies outlet-orifice diameter (e.g. 77mm77\,mm).
  • Enter diameter in the template; embedded orifice equation: Q=CdA2ghQ = C_d A \sqrt{2g h}
    • CdC_d = discharge coefficient
    • AA = orifice area
    • hh = head on orifice
  • Spreadsheet turns the PSD cell green when Q<em>calcPSD</em>reqQ<em>{calc}\le PSD</em>{req}.
6.2 MC2 / Multicell Method
  • When an MC2 cartridge replaces a plain orifice, discharge is obtained from manufacturer’s MC2 performance chart.
  • Process:
    1. Determine inlet head hh at critical TWL.
    2. Read corresponding discharge QchartQ_{chart}.
    3. Insert QchartQ_{chart} into PSD field.

7. Pass / Fail Logic in Template

  • Cells auto-colour:
    • Green – requirement met.
    • Red – requirement not satisfied.
  • Two mandatory conditions:
    1. Q<em>calcPSD</em>reqQ<em>{calc} \le PSD</em>{req}
    2. V<em>totalV</em>reqV<em>{total} \ge V</em>{req}

8. Handling Negative Storage Contributions

  • If TWL < IL for any element, resulting Δh\Delta h becomes negative ⇒ storage contribution set to 00 (delete that row).

9. Drawing Issues & Plan Administration

  • Plans must be plotted to true A4 scale (e.g. 1 : 100) so lengths can be measured.
  • Subdivision / title plans must match the current registered title; otherwise Titles Office rejects.

Worked Example Snapshot

ParameterRequiredProvided (after data entry)Status
Storage Volume4.34m34.34\,m^{3}5.76m35.76\,m^{3}Green (OK)
PSD8.79Ls18.79\,L\,s^{-1}8.70Ls18.70\,L\,s^{-1} (with 77 mm orifice)Green (OK)

Practical Tips & Common Pitfalls

  • Always convert mm → m before area/volume calcs.
  • Start storage tally downstream and move upstream; quit once V<em>totalV</em>reqV<em>{total} \ge V</em>{req} to save time.
  • For pipes with no dimension shown, use CAD or scale-rule to measure length directly on the plan.
  • Triple-check that pits feeding the outlet chamber are excluded from storage tally.
  • Watch for designs where tanks are above ground; do not accidentally credit them as underground.
  • If PSD or volume barely fails, suggest designer either enlarge pit, extend pipe length, or shrink outlet orifice.

Tools, Equations & Reference Material

  • Excel Template: Excel → Templates → “Detention Volume Calculation”.
  • Sheet 2 of template documents every formula; hover over any cell for built-in comments.
  • OSD 4 Software: Generates PSD & storage targets per council methodology.
  • Core Equations (embedded):
    1. Orifice Flow Q=CdA2ghQ=C_d A\sqrt{2gh}
    2. Pipe Storage V=π4D2LV=\tfrac{\pi}{4}D^2L
    3. Rectangular Pit Volume V=B×L×hV= B\times L\times h

Ethical, Practical & Regulatory Considerations

  • Ensuring compliance avoids downstream flooding and liability.
  • Incorrect titles or scales delay registration; accuracy protects council reputation and project timelines.
  • ≥ 60 % underground rule limits visual impact and maximises effective attenuation.
  • MC2 sizing must respect manufacturer data; misuse voids warranties and may breach approval conditions.

Connections to Previous Lectures

  • Marianne’s earlier session on OSD parameters explained how PSD & storage are derived in OSD 4; today’s lesson shows how those numbers are applied during plan checking.
  • Flow-measurement theory (head–discharge relationships) underpins orifice and MC2 checks, reinforcing fluid-mechanics topics covered in foundational hydraulics modules.

Summary Checklist for Future Reviews

  1. Open drawings, pit schedule, OSD 4 report.
  2. Launch Excel template; copy PSD & storage targets.
  3. Populate pit dimensions, ILs, TWL.
  4. Add pipe data (diameter, length, barrel count).
  5. Enter outlet device size (or read MC2 chart).
  6. Confirm both green lights (storage & PSD).
  7. Check ≥ 60 % underground storage.
  8. Verify plan scale and title accuracy.
  9. Issue approval comments or request revisions accordingly.