Study Notes on Kerry James Marshall's "School of Beauty, School of Culture"

Overview of the Painting: School of Beauty, School of Culture

  • Artist: Kerry James Marshall

  • Description: A complex painting depicting a beauty school or salon primarily filled with Black people, notably women.

Basic Breakdown

  • Left Side:
      - Two women seen from behind.
        - One seated and one standing.
        - They are looking into a heart-shaped mirror alongside another mirror.

  • Right Side:
      - A complex cluster of people, with significant action centered around a figure in a salon chair, possibly receiving hair treatment.
      - Woman in a red coat looks out at the viewer with surprise.

  • Foreground Details:
      - Woman in striped pants and yellow shirt in a pinup pose.
        - Her body language includes bent knees, curved back, and one arm on her waist while the other is behind her head.
      - Presence of a camera flash in the mirror, indicating she is posing.
      - Another woman bends over to observe her reflection in the mirror.
      - Two toddlers in the foreground:
        - One in blue overalls and another in a pink onesie.
      - Notable inclusion of a disconnected, distorted head of a white woman.

  • Visual Elements:
      - Multiple textures and images in the background including abstract flooring patterns, varied fabrics, posters, and photographs.

Background of Kerry James Marshall

  • Education:
      - Studied in Los Angeles in the 1970s when figurative painting was considered undesirable.
      - Art world, particularly white male dominated, deemed painting effectively "dead".

  • Marshall's Work:
      - Combines elements from historical and contemporary cultural fields in a bold, monumental style.
      - Encourages comparisons with historically significant works like Raphael's The School of Athens.

Comparison with The School of Athens

  • Both Paintings:
      - Size: School of Beauty is 9 feet high and 13 feet long.
      - Both are multi-figure compositions depicting groups engaged in activities: beautification (Marshall) vs. philosophy (Raphael).
      - Combination of living figures with inanimate signifiers of cultural values (e.g., sculptures in Raphael's work vs. modern cultural references in Marshall's).

  • Differences:
      - School of Beauty features fewer figures and a shallower pictorial space.
      - Subject Composition:
        - School of Athens: exclusively male figures.
        - School of Beauty: predominantly Black women.
      - Historical context of representation is significant: Marshall focuses on underrepresented Black subjects versus the historical dominance of white subjects.

Representation of Blackness

  • Historical Context:
      - Marshall's inspiration from Ralph Ellison's The Invisible Man, which addresses the double vision regarding Blackness in America.
      - The struggle of Black individuals being rendered invisible in historical narratives and art; often portrayed only in contexts of trauma or servitude.

  • Marshall's Commitment:
      - Aim to depict Black figures as empowered and beautiful.
      - Describes his subjects as exemplars of unapologetic, non-negotiable Blackness.

  • Literal Representation of Blackness:
      - Use of three distinct black pigments (carbon black, mars black, and ivory black).
      - Challenges the norm of avoiding black paint in favor of other tones, affirming the importance of portraying Blackness authentically.

Cultural Significance of the Beauty Salon

  • The setting of the beauty salon serves to highlight the importance of this space in the everyday lives of many African Americans.

  • School of Beauty is reflective of culture, history, and beauty standards, intertwining with broader art historical narratives.

Art Historical Signifiers and Comparisons

  • Reference to Holbein's The Ambassadors (1533):
      - Depicts two young men amidst symbols of wealth and knowledge, with an anamorphic skull as a memento mori representing mortality.
      - In Marshall's painting, this skull is replaced by a white woman's head, representing prevailing beauty standards based on white supremacy rather than mortality.

  • Interaction of Figures:
      - Toddlers engaging with the distorted head in a conscious manner, examined for their reactions towards beauty standards of white womanhood.
      - Their behaviors complicate interpretations of beauty and cultural values, highlighting the lived experiences of Black women.

Form and Abstraction

  • Artistic Techniques:
      - Floor and salon chair exhibit abstraction alongside their literal representations.
      - The style resonates with American abstract painters like Frank Stella and Mark Rothko.

  • Marshall's Purpose:
      - Merges Euro-American painting traditions with African American cultural expressions and experiences to convey deeper narratives and values.

Closing Thoughts

  • Marshall's School of Beauty invites viewers to reassess traditional ideas of beauty and the significance of Black culture within art history.

  • The painting celebrates the complexity and richness of Black lives and cultural experiences, asserting their rightful place within the grand narrative of art.