Guidelines for Similarity, Difference, and Causality Analysis
Comparison Analysis: Similarities and Differences
When tasked with analyzing two subjects, the requirement is to identify and explain either a similarity or a difference.
The speaker emphasizes: "Don't overwork yourself." Students should not attempt to provide both a similarity and a difference when the prompt uses the conjunction "or."
The specific requirement for the test is to focus exclusively on one of these two comparative aspects.
Once a difference is selected for explanation, the student must explain that specific difference in detail.
It is explicitly stated that students should not transition into discussing similarities if they have already begun explaining a difference.
Case Study in Differences: Presidential Policy
A specific example is provided involving two U.S. Presidents to illustrate how to handle a difference-based prompt:
George Washington: Characterized in this context as an "isolationist."
Teddy Roosevelt: Characterized in this context as an "imperialist."
In this scenario, the student's task is solely to explain the nature of this difference (isolationism versus imperialism) in depth without mentioning any traits the two presidents might have had in common.
Analyzing Cause and Effect Relationships
In contrast to the comparative task (similarity OR difference), the requirements for analyzing cause and effect are more extensive.
For a cause and effect prompt, students must address both components of the relationship.
The student must explicitly explain the following:
How one specific factor or event serves as the "cause."
How the corresponding factor or event serves as the "effect."
Interaction and Clarification
The instruction includes a check for understanding with the audience, noted by the speaker saying "Okay?" and acknowledging an audience member's attention with "Yes, sir."
The speaker reiterates that for similarity and difference, you choose one or the other, whereas for cause and effect, you must do both.