2 - Fighting the Second World War (1939-1940)
National Socialism and the Outbreak of War (1939-1940)
- Institutional Shift at War: Upon the commencement of hostilities in 1939, the National Socialist regime largely abandoned any remaining pretenses of international civility or diplomatic norms.
- Primary War Objectives:
- Historical Revisionism: A central goal was to "reverse" the humiliation and territorial losses associated with the German defeat in 1918.
- Imperialism and Economics: The war sought the colonization of new territories and the systematic exploitation of resources to sustain the Reich.
- Domestic Mass Murder (Aktion T4): The regime initiated the systematic killing of disabled Germans under the T4 program, framed as a measure of racial hygiene.
- Racial and Ethnic Persecution: The state implemented policies to segregate, persecute, and eventually murder specific target groups including:
- Poles.
- Soviets.
- European Jews (encompassing various nationalities and ethnicities).
- The Nature of Combat Organizations: A significant historical question involves determining if there were two distinct wars occurring simultaneously:
- War A: Conducted by the conventional armed forces (Wehrmacht).
- War B: Conducted by the SS and subsidiary police organizations focused on ideological and racial goals.
- Occupation Culture: Evidence of the German presence in occupied territories is seen in facilities like the Soldatenkaffee, a dedicated German soldiers’ club located in occupied Paris, where servicemen and nurses socialized.
Analytical Framework of German Strategy
- Levels of Warfare: The conflict is analyzed through two primary lenses:
- Strategy: The overarching political and military plans for the war effort.
- Tactics: The specific combat formulas and methods used on the battlefield.
- Key Strategic Debates:
- Historians question whether Germany possessed a coherent, unified strategic vision for conducting a new world war.
- There is ongoing debate regarding whether Germany actually developed a brand-new tactical formula for warfighting or simply improved upon existing ones.
- Adolf Hitler’s Leadership Style: Hitler’s role in the military hierarchy is debated as either that of a "reckless gambler" taking massive unnecessary risks or an "omnipotent warlord" with a firm grasp on all operations.
- The Fall of Paris: In June 1940, following the victory in the West, Hitler took an impromptu tour of Paris with his high-ranking entourage to demonstrate German dominance.
The Polish Campaign (1939)
- Diplomatic Foundation: The Molotov-Ribbentrop agreement (the German-Soviet Non-Aggression Pact) was the critical precursor to the invasion, ensuring the Soviet Union would not intervene against Germany and allowing for a partitioned Poland.
- Allied Response: The campaign marked the entry of Britain and France into the war, though their initial roles were limited.
- Deconstructing ‘Blitzkrieg’: The campaign is used to examine the nature of German military success, specifically addressing the "mythology" of Blitzkrieg (lightning war) vs. the actual operational reality.
- Propaganda: German propaganda efforts were heavily utilized to disparage and misrepresent the capabilities and actions of the Polish forces.
- Joint Invasion: The campaign was characterized by a synchronized German and Soviet invasion of Poland in September 1939.
Western Campaigns (1940)
- Northern Operations (April 1940): Germany launched swift invasions of Denmark and Norway.
- Western Invasions (May 10, 1940): Germany simultaneously invaded France, Belgium, and the Netherlands.
- British Political Transition: Winston Churchill replaced Neville Chamberlain as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom on May 10, 1940.
- Operation Dynamo: This was the critical maritime evacuation of Allied troops from the beaches of Dunkirk, allowing a significant portion of the British Expeditionary Force to escape.
- Fall of France: The French government officially capitulated on June 22, 1940, leading to the German occupation of Paris and Northern France.
- Evolution of Operational Planning:
- Initial Scheme: The original plan for invading France in 1940 was a traditional maneuver that swooped around Paris to the southeast, heavily resembling the 1914 Schlieffen Plan from World War I.
- Revised Plan: At the last minute, the plan was drastically changed to a westerly swooping thrust (often represented as a blue-shaded arrow on military maps). This revision is credited with the rapid collapse of Allied defenses.
The Battle of Britain and Total War
- Operation Sea Lion: The German code name for the planned amphibious invasion of Great Britain.
- The Air War: The Luftwaffe, under the command of Hermann Göring, was tasked with achieving total air supremacy over British airspace to facilitate an invasion.
- German Strategic Defeat: The Luftwaffe failed to secure air supremacy, leading to a German defeat in the Battle of Britain and the indefinite postponement of Operation Sea Lion.
- The Blitz (1940−41): Following the failure to destroy the Royal Air Force, Germany shifted to a campaign of sustained aerial bombardment against British cities and civilian targets.
- Escalation to Total War: The survival of Britain meant that Germany was now trapped in a prolonged, multi-front, total and existential war, rather than the short conflict they had anticipated.
Hitler’s Strategic Perspective and Recommendation
- Global Intentions: Historians continue to evaluate whether Hitler genuinely intended to engage in a full-scale world war as early as 1939−40, or if the conflict escalated beyond his immediate tactical goals.
- The Aesthetic of Conquest: Hitler’s visit to Paris in 1940 included high-profile figures such as the architect Albert Speer and the sculptor Arno Breker, emphasizing the ideological and cultural dimensions of the victory.
- Professional Recommendation for Further Reading: For an exhaustive analysis of German war planning and a deep deconstruction of the 1940 campaign myths, refer to:
- Karl-Heinz Frieser, The Blitzkrieg Legend.