ICA 2 - Business Law Notes

F) FREE CONSENT

Definition of Consent

  • Section 13: "Two or more persons are said to consent when they agree upon the same thing in the same sense."

  • Known in English law as ‘consensus – ad – idem’.

  • "Same thing" includes the entire content of the agreement.

  • A contract cannot be formed without consent.

  • Consent may be free or not free; only free consent is necessary for the validity of a contract.

Effect of Absence of Consent

  • Absence of consent makes the agreement void–ab–initio (invalid from the outset).

  • Not enforceable at the option of either party.

  • Examples:

    • Case 1: X has two cars, Maruti and Honda City. Y offers Rs. 50,000 for one car, unaware of the two cars. No agreement (void).

    • Case 2: An illiterate woman signs a gift deed thinking it’s a power of attorney. Agreement is void due to lack of consent (Bala Devi V S. Manumdats).

Free Consent (Section 14)

  • Consent is free when not influenced by:

    • Coercion (Section 15)

    • Undue Influence (Section 16)

    • Fraud (Section 17)

    • Misrepresentation (Section 18)

    • Mistake (Sections 20, 21, 22).

  • Agreements caused by coercion, fraud, misrepresentation, or undue influence are voidable.

  • An agreement vitiated by mistake becomes void.

I) Coercion (Section 15)

Definition

  • Coercion involves committing, or threatening to commit, an act forbidden by IPC, or unlawful detention of property, intending to induce a person to enter an agreement.

Essential Elements of Coercion

  • Committing or threatening forbidden acts (by IPC).

  • Unlawful detention of property or threat thereof.

  • Coercion does not need to come from a contracting party or be directed against the other party.

  • Immaterial whether IPC is in force at the time or place.

Effects of Coercion

  • Contracts induced by coercion are voidable at the option of the coerced party (Section 19).

  • Party rescinding a void contract must restore benefits received.

  • Example: Husband obtains a release deed from his wife under threat of committing suicide; Transaction set aside due to coercion.

  • Example: An agent withholding accounts unless freed from liabilities constitutes coercion.

  • Note: Threats to strike do not constitute coercion under IPC.

II) Undue Influence (Section 16)

Definition

  • Induced where one party dominates the will of another to obtain an unfair advantage.

Key Elements

  1. Relationship enabling dominance.

  2. Use of that relationship to gain an unfair advantage.

  3. Examples of influence-generating relationships include:

    • Landlord and Tenant

    • Creditor and Debtor

    • Husband and Wife

    • Principal and Agent.

  4. Mental distress or illness can affect capacity, leading to undue influence.

  5. The burden of proof lies on the dominant party to show absence of unfair advantage.

Example

  • A contracts high-interest terms with B, a money-lender, while in debt, which seems unconscionable. B must prove the absence of undue influence.

III) Fraud (Section 17)

Definition

  • Includes acts committed to deceive a party to induce contract entry.

  • Examples:

    1. False representation of a fact by one who does not believe it.

    2. Active concealment of fact known to the perpetrator.

    3. Promises made without intent to perform.

    4. Any act intended to deceive.

Effect of Fraud

  • Contract voidable at the option of the defrauded party.

  • Rights include rescind, sue for damages, or insist on performance based on truthful representation.

Key Points

  • Mere silence isn’t fraud unless there’s a duty to disclose, e.g. relationships of utmost good faith (fiduciary).

Example

  • Selling pigs with fever, knowingly without disclosure, doesn't constitute fraud if sold 'as is'.

IV) Misrepresentation (Section 18)

Definition

  • Occurs when a party makes a false statement believed to be true, affecting the other party's actions.

Elements

  1. Representation of a fact made (not by strangers).

  2. Made innocently without intent to deceive.

  3. Other party acts on misrepresentation believing it to be true.

Rights Upon Misrepresentation

  • Right to rescind contract unless the misrepresentation was discovered with reasonable diligence.

  • Right to insist on performance, no claim for damages in misrepresentation scenarios.

Differences Between Fraud and Misrepresentation

  • Fraud: Intent to deceive; false belief about the truth.

  • Misrepresentation: No intent to deceive; innocent false belief.

V) Mistake

Definition

  • Erroneous belief leading to misunderstanding between parties.

Types of Mistakes

  • Bilateral Mistake: Both parties are mistaken.

  • Unilateral Mistake: One party is mistaken.

  • Mistake of Law: Does not void contracts; exceptions where induced by another.

  • Mistake of Fact: Mutual mistake voids the contract.

Module III – Sales of Goods Act

3.1 Formation of Contract of Sale

  • The act came into force on 1st July, 1930.

  • Section 4(i): Contract of sale of goods involves transfer of property for a price.

Essential Elements

  • Minimum of two parties.

  • Subject matter must be goods.

  • Price paid or promised.

  • Transfer of property must occur.

Types of Goods

  1. Existing Goods

  2. Specific/Ascertained Goods

  3. Generic/Unascertained Goods

  4. Future Goods

  5. Contingent Goods

Differences between Sale and Agreement of Sale

Sale

Agreement of Sale

Executed contract (property transferred)

Executory contract (future transfer)

Seller can’t resell after transfer

Seller can resell (property remains)

Risk with buyer (owner)

Risk with seller (remains owner)

Breach allows for price and damages

Breach allows for damages only

3.2 Conditions and Warranties

  • Condition: Essential for the contract; breach permits repudiation.

  • Warranty: Subsidiary promise; breach allows for damages but not repudiation.

Implied Conditions and Warranties

  • Conditions: Title, description, sample.

  • Warranties: Possession, freedom from encumbrances, dangerous nature, quality.

Caveat Emptor

  • The principle "let the buyer beware" emphasizes buyer caution.

  • Exceptions to this principle include fitness for purpose, seller fraud, goods under patent, etc.

3.3 Meaning and Importance of Movable Property

Passing of Property
  • Passes to the buyer under conditions; risk and ownership shift based on the contract.

  • Goods perishing before or after the contract affects obligations.

3.4 Rights and Duties of an Unpaid Seller

  • Unpaid seller has rights of lien, stoppage in transit, resale, and withholding delivery.

  • Each right is conditional, i.e., seller must be unpaid, and buyer must have acted in a way that allows these claims.

  • Seller can sue if the buyer neglects to pay after property passes or refuses payment due.