Cultural and Transnational Proximity in K-Pop
Conceptual Frameworks: Cultural vs. Transnational Proximity
The course examines the global circulation, production, and reception of Korean pop music and culture.
Cultural Proximity: A long-standing framework in media studies (specifically television studies) used to explain the preference for local or regional content.
Transnational Proximity: A newer alternative framework designed to address the rapidly changing landscape of K-pop and its identity as a transnational culture.
The central intellectual shift involves moving from the original cultural proximity thesis to a more dynamic transnational lens.
The Thesis of Cultural Proximity
Coined by Pu in , the concept suggests audiences favor media produced in their own cultural environment over foreign imports if elements are equal.
Poole () argued that local products are protected by barriers of language and culture.
Joseph Strava expanded this, stating that if local content is unavailable, audiences prefer content from nearby cultures with similar linguistic and social backgrounds.
Cultural proximity often serves as a lens for analyzing the counterculture flow from the East to the West, challenging Western cultural imperialism.
Evolution of Preference Factors
Early applications of the theory focused on national and regional levels, particularly regarding Mexican telenovelas in Spanish-speaking regions.
Despite deregulation in the late , national preferences persisted in countries like India, China, Korea, and Japan.
Beyond language, Joseph Strava identified other proximity markers: humor, gender images, fashion, body language, religious values, and lifestyles.
The theory is dynamic, evolving alongside both national and transnational developments in collective identity.
Case Study: The Cool Japan Phenomenon
Cool Japan represents a cultural slogan and government project initiated in the late (specifically mentioned as ) to commercialize Japanese appeal.
It leverages the popularity of manga, anime, and J-pop to improve foreign relations and brand value.
The project's success is rooted in "Asian modernity" and "Asian personality" shared across regions like Seoul, Hong Kong, Taipei, and Bangkok.
Koichi Wapuchi of Menasha University noted that Taiwanese audiences enjoy Japanese culture due to shared historical experiences, even without a common language.
Theoretical Limitations and Shifts
Cultural proximity has been used to explain why Hallyu (the Korean Wave) succeeded in Asia due to shared Confucianism and geographical proximity.
A shift is occurring because traditional proximity factors (like language) are being replaced by new media dynamics.
Modern scholars now use transnational proximity to explain how media players facilitate transnational consumption across changing media escapes.