Theft Lecture 1: Legal Definition, Appropriation, and Property
Legal Definition of Theft and Statutory Framework
- Under s.1 Theft Act 1968 (TA 1968), the core definition provided in s.1(1) is: “A person is guilty of theft if he dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it; and ‘thief’ and ‘steal’ shall be construed accordingly.”
- Subsections 2-6 of the TA 1968 define specific key elements of the offense.
- The legal framework identifies specific components that must be proven against the defendant:
- The defendant appropriated property.
- The subject was property.
- The property was belonging to another.
- The defendant had knowledge that it was property.
- The defendant had knowledge that it belonged to another.
- The appropriation was voluntary.
- The appropriation was dishonest.
- The defendant intended to permanently deprive (ITPD) the other party of the property.
The Actus Reus: Appropriation
- According to s.3(1) of the TA 1968, appropriation is defined as: “Any assumption by a person of the rights of an owner amounts to an appropriation… including… any later assumption of a right to it by keeping or dealing with it as owner.”
- Theft is classified as a conduct crime, meaning it requires no specific result; the criminal moment occurs precisely when the appropriation takes place.
- Assumption of the Rights of an Owner:
- In Mcpherson[1973], putting whisky into a bag was considered an appropriation.
- Owners' rights include the right to possess, use, consume, destroy, sell, give away, lend, move, and price the property.
- Appropriation essentially constitutes "doing something" to or in relation to the property.
- In PithamextandHehl[1976], D1 was guilty of handling stolen goods (extfurniturebelongingtoaprisoner) because D2 had already appropriated the property by merely offering to sell it to D1.
Evolution of One Right vs. All Rights
- Historically, some cases suggested that assuming a single right was insufficient to constitute appropriation.
- In Hircock[1978], the defendant obtained a car on hire purchase (HP) and sold it 2 weeks later. The court held that the sale was the appropriation point because that was when no more rights could be assumed.
- In DipextKaurvChiefConstableforHampshire[1981], a defendant took mislabeled shoes to a cashier. The court held appropriation occurred at the cashier, not when the shoes were first picked up.
- Current Law: The assumption of only one right of the owner is now sufficient.
- In Morris;extAndertonextvBurnside[1984], defendants switched price labels on supermarket items. The House of Lords held that the right to label goods is a right of the owner, and switching them constituted an appropriation.
Later Assumptions and Temporal Coincidence
- s.3(1) allows for a "later appropriation" to resolve issues where the Actus Reus (AR) and Mens Rea (MR) do not initially coincide:
- Situation: D gains property innocently (extARbutnoMR), later realizes they should not have it, and decides to keep it (extMRforms).
- The statute specifies that appropriation includes situations where a person has come by property without stealing it, but later assumes an owner's right by "keeping or dealing with it as owner."
- Dealing: Suggests a positive act, such as using the property.
- Keeping: Can be inaction or an omission.
- Example: In ThompsonextvNixon[1965], a defendant found rabbit food and initially intended to hand it in but later kept it. Under the current TA, this is a later assumption by keeping.
- In problem-solving, students must identify the "relevant" appropriation—the specific moment where the MR and AR align. Prior assumptions without MR are noted but dismissed as the point of theft.
Continuous and Subsequent Appropriation
- Once a defendant has already appropriated property with the required MR, there cannot be a subsequent theft of that same property by that same defendant.
- Williams (1978) noted that without this rule, a court could "convict a thief of the theft of a silver teapot every time he uses it to make tea."
- Continuing Appropriation:
- In AtakpuextandAbrahams[1994], defendants hired cars in Europe using fraud and drove them to England to sell. They were charged with conspiracy to steal.
- The Court of Appeal held the appropriation occurred abroad and did not continue when they entered the UK. Because the cars were already stolen abroad, the appeal was allowed.
Consent and Appropriation
- Historical Development:
- LawrenceextvMetropolitanextPoliceCommissioner[1971]: A taxi driver took £7 instead of the 50p fare from a foreign tourist who consented to him taking the money from a wallet. Held: This was still an appropriation despite consent.
- EddyextvNinman[1981]: Putting goods in a shop basket was not theft because the shop consented to that specific practice.
- Morris[1984]: Lord Roskill stated appropriation involves "adverse interference with, or usurpation of the rights of the owner," implying consent negates appropriation. This is no longer the law.
- Current Law on Consent:
- Gomez[1993]: A shop manager was persuaded to accept two stolen, worthless cheques for £17,000 worth of goods. The House of Lords held that an assumption of rights can occur even with the victim’s consent.
- Hinks[2000]: A woman persuaded a man of limited intelligence to give her £60,000 and a TV as gifts. Even though the transfer was technically a valid legal gift (extabsoluteindefeasibleright) under civil law, the House of Lords held (4 to 1) it was still an appropriation.
- Lord Steyn in Hinks: "It would be wrong to assume on a priori grounds that the criminal law rather than the civil law is defective."
- Lord Hobhouse (Dissenting): Argued you cannot appropriate your own property and that "there is no law against appropriating your own property."
- The Effect of Hinks: Appropriation is now a "neutral concept" with no inherent wrongdoing attached. All culpability rests within the Mens Rea (Dishonesty and Intent to Permanently Deprive).
Definition of Property (s.4 TA 1968)
- s.4(1) provides a wide definition: “Property includes money and all other property, real or personal, including things in action and other intangible property.”
- Money: Limited to coins and banknotes (even if withdrawn from a bank account).
- Real Property: Refers to land and immovable structures, as opposed to moveable personal property.
- Things in Action: This category is intangible and cannot be handled but is legally enforceable.
- Bank accounts are things in action because it is impossible to specify which physical notes belong to a customer (Davenport[1954]).
- In ChanextMan−SinvAGforHongKong[1988], a thing in action was defined as the right to sue the bank for the debt/deposited amount.
- Cheques: A cheque is property if given for consideration, as it creates a "thing in action" (the payee's right to sue the drawer for the stated sum).
- Gas: Considered property (White[1853]).
- Water: Considered property (FerensextvO’Brien[1883]).
- Electricity: Not property (LowextvBlease[1975]). However, dishonest use, wasting, or diverting of electricity is a separate offense under s.13 TA 1968.
- Confidential Information: In OxfordextvMoss[1978], a student read an exam paper and returned it. The court held that confidential information is not property; thus, the student was not guilty of theft.
Special Categories of Property
- Things Growing Wild:
- Uprooting a whole plant can be theft under s.4(2)(b).
- Under s.4(3), picking mushrooms, flowers, fruit, or foliage from a wild plant is not theft unless done for reward, sale, or other commercial purpose. This intention must exist at the time of picking.
- Domestic Pets:
- Historically, pets were treated as property (approximately 2,290 dogs and 400 cats are stolen annually).
- The PetextAbductionAct2024 now makes it a specific offense to take a dog, cat, or other animal commonly kept as a pet.
- Corpses (Bodies):
- Buried corpses are not property and cannot be stolen (FosterextvDodd; Hayne’sextCase). Body snatching was a common law crime (e.g., resurrectionists BurkeextandHare).
- A corpse can become property if someone has a right of possession (executor) or has exercised "work or skill" over the body (DoodewardextvSpence[1908]).
- In DobsonextvNorthextTynesideHA[1997], a brain kept in a jar was held not to be property.