Sentencing Options

SENTENCING OPTIONS - Chapter 11


List and define the six goals/principles of sentencing.  Use textbook Chapter 11 pages 275-277.


  1. protection of the public

    1. isolating the offender to prevent further harm to public

  2. Retribution

    1. punishment to avenge a crime, discouraging the offender from reoffending (recidivism)

  3. Restitution

    1. punishment that requires the offender to pay society back for the harm/loss suffered (e.g community service)

  4. Rehabilitation and Reintegration

    1. punishment combined with treatment and training to help offender function in society (e. psychiatric and medical treatment, prison employment program)

  5. denunciation

    1. punishment designed to show condemnation of the offenders conduct (e.g public shaming)

  6. deterrence

    1. Discouraging other from committing crimes - general deterrence

    2. Specific deterrence - discouraging criminals from reoffending 

Sentence must be “proportionate to the gravity of the offence and the degree of the responsibility of the offender” and entirely within the judges discretion

Complete the following table to compare the sentencing options available to Judges.  Use textbook Chapter 11 pages 281-301.


Sentence Option

Definition of Sentence Option

What happens to the offender under this sentence option?

Absolute Discharge


releasing convicted offender with no conditions and no record/conviction

(e.g minor offense or first time offense)

found guilty;criminal record destroyed after 1 year

Conditional Discharge


Releasing convicted offender under certain terms (e.g observing set curfews not allowed to own firearms)

Found guilty; criminal record is destroyed after 3 years

Probation


allows convicted offenders to prove that he/she is able to live in the community without committing another offence. 

A parole officer supervises an offender on probation and is responsible for monitoring the offenders behaviour, some conditions may include: 

  • reporting regularly to a probation officer;

  • not associating with known criminals;

  • staying away from particular locations;

  • attending counselling sessions;

  • paying for damages resulting from the offence; and

  • refraining from alcohol and illegal drug use.

Intermittent Sentence


<90 days

serve prison sentence on weekends and at night 

usually non violent, have steady employment

must report to jail and is subject to a probation order

Conditional Sentence


Prison term of <2 years to be served in the community with strict terms

commonly given with house arrest/electronic monitoring

Avoid prison for non dangerous offenders

Supports reintegration and considers employment and family issues

Conditional Service Order


perform certain community services in the community for a specified period

Restitution to victim/society

not given if violent offense

Peace Bond/Binding-Over


can be imposed on someone who threatens another person/that person's family or property

sentence ordering the defendant to keep the peace and demonstrate good behaviour for up to 12 months

No criminal offence occurs unless a peace bond is violated or the defendant refuses to be bound.

Fines


Monetary penalties that judges impose

Can be part of conditional sentence

In effect up to 3 years

Judge must consider ability of offender to pay

Offender who fails to pay fine may face prison time

Incarceration/Prison


Provincial Correctional System

Closed Custody

Protective Custody

Open Custody

Various levels of security is dependent on severity of crime

  • closed/max = highly secure, armed correctional officers, bars on doors/windows

  • Open/Min = no fences/walls, educational programs, prisoners not escape risks

  • Federal prison >2 years

  • provincial prison <2 years

  • detention centers - remanded in custody awaiting trial

Federal Correctional System

Max-Security

Medium-Security

Min-Security

Dangerous Offender


Someone who constitutes a dangerous offender has been convicted of a serious personal injury offence, such as a violent crime or a sexual assault, and is considered to pose a high risk of reoffending and causing harm to society.

indeterminate prison sentence

Parole


inmates conditional release into the community before the full sentence is served

Excludes 1st degree murder and inmates must meet certain conditions to qualify. Parole provides an incentive for good behaviour

parole lessens the negative effects of incarceration and gives parolee the opportunity to return to society with help and supervision

Pardon


a person's record of conviction is set aside. DOES NOT ERASE THE FACT THAT SOMEONE HAS BEEN CONVICTED OF AN OFFENCE. Pardon automatically has no effect if a person is later convicted of an indictable offence. National Parole Board can rescind a pardon for any of the following reasons: conviction for a summary offence, unacceptable conduct, false information at the time of application.

Any federal agency that has records of convictions must keep those records separate. Information may not be disclosed without permission from the Solicitor General of Canada.

Sentencing Circles

offender and family, victim and family, elders and other members of the offenders aboriginal community, police officers and a trial judge. process involves separating the person from the criminal act the person committed

Goal is to empower offender and victim

Conflict resolution and reconcilliation

Eventually a consensus is reached