st1-2-ques05
Article 1: Can a Man Acquire Beatitude?
It seems that man cannot attain beatitude due to various objections. This refers to the challenges and misunderstandings surrounding the concept of beatitude.
To the contrary: Beatitude is defined as the acquisition of perfect good; hence, a man is capable of acquiring beatitude because:
Man's intellect can understand the universal perfect good.
The will can desire this good.
Man has the capacity for seeing God's essence, integral to his perfect beatitude.
Article 2: Can One Man Be More Blessed Than Another?
It seems one man cannot be more blessed than another based on virtue. This suggests a level playing field regarding blessings and virtues among individuals.
To the contrary: One can be more blessed based on the enjoyment of the highest good, which does not vary, but individual enjoyment can differ. This means that although the highest good remains constant, personal experiences and perceptions differ.
Article 3: Can Beatitude Be Had in This Life?
It seems beatitude can be attained in this life based on various biblical references. This implies that scriptures support the notion of experiencing beatitude on Earth.
To the contrary: Some form of beatitude can be experienced imperfectly in this life, but complete beatitude, which involves seeing God's essence, is unattainable in earthly life. Thus, while moments of happiness exist, ultimate fulfillment is beyond reach here.
Article 4: Can Beatitude Be Lost?
It seems that beatitude can be lost due to man's mutable nature and decision-making. This highlights the instability and changeability of human nature affecting one's state of beatitude.
To the contrary: While imperfect beatitude can be lost, perfect beatitude possesses permanence due to the union with God ensuring no external factor can cause loss. Perfect beatitude implies a lasting connection to the divine.
Article 5: Can a Man Attain Beatitude by His Own Natural Powers?
It seems man can attain ultimate beatitude through his natural powers. Suggests that humans have the potential through their inherent capabilities.
To the contrary: While imperfect beatitude may be achieved through natural powers, perfect beatitude necessitates divine intervention, highlighting the role of God in achieving the ultimate state of fulfillment.
Article 6: Can a Man Be Made Blessed Through the Action of a Higher Creature?
It seems angels can confer beatitude to man. This posits that higher celestial beings might facilitate beatitude for humans.
To the contrary: Beatitude requires divine power; angels may assist but ultimate attainment relies solely on God, reinforcing the idea of dependence on the divine.
Article 7: Are Any Human Works Required to Obtain Beatitude?
It seems that no human works are required for beatitude. This implies a belief in grace without the need for human effort.
To the contrary: While direct human works are not essential, a rightly ordered will is necessary to align with God's plan. This indicates that there is a moral and ethical aspect to attaining beatitude.
Article 8: Does Everyone Desire Beatitude?
It seems not everyone desires beatitude as they may lack understanding. Suggests some individuals might be unaware or disinterested in the concept of beatitude.
To the contrary: All men desire beatitude as the ultimate good, though their understanding may differ, leading to varying perceptions of it. This emphasizes a fundamental human yearning for the ultimate good, regardless of their awareness.