Reform Movements and Utopian Communities

Reform Movements

  • Centered primarily in the North and were transatlantic in scope.
  • In the South, reform movements were less common due to their association with antislavery.
  • Often employed "moral suasion," using moral arguments to persuade people to their cause.
  • Almost all reform movements linked their cause to religion, especially the Second Great Awakening.
  • Some groups withdrew from mainstream society to form utopian communities.
  • These communities aimed to create "perfect" or "ideal" societies, a concept known as "perfectionism."
  • Some operated as democratic societies, while others were led by single leaders.

The Second Great Awakening

  • A religious revival movement that reinforced self-improvement, self-reliance, and self-determination, which were growing during the Market Revolution.
  • It emerged in response to declining church attendance during the Market Revolution.
  • Prominent figures included Reverend Charles Grandison Finney, who advocated for women's rights and the abolition of slavery.
  • It democratized American Christianity, making Christianity more central to the culture.
  • Tocqueville noted that Americans combined Christianity and liberty so intimately that they couldn't conceive of one without the other.

Emergence in the Market Revolution Explained

  • Revivalist ministers utilized new technologies to raise funds and travel, leading to greater mass participation.
  • The Erie Canal played an important role in this.
  • Cane Ridge Revival, 1801, was particularly significant.
  • Despite using the Market Revolution to spread their ideas, many ministers criticized its scramble for wealth.
  • The Market Revolution produced what they termed "the law of Satan's empire", due to its emphasis on "Individualism".

Utopian Communities

  • Most utopian communities operated on a cooperative basis, aiming to end the "excessive individualism" of the Market Revolution.
  • These communities represent the origins of the terms socialism and communism.
  • Some prohibited sexual relations, while others allowed "free love."
  • Key tenets included abolishing private property and challenging the idea that women were the "property" of men.

Specific Utopian Communities

Shakers

  • A community that has members to this day.
  • Believed God was both male and female.
  • Practiced virgin purity, with men and women living separately.

Mormons

  • Founded by Joseph Smith in upstate New York.
  • Smith held absolute authority.
  • Practiced polygamy, which led to persecution and eventual migration to Illinois and then Nevada.

Oneida

  • Founded by John Humphrey Noyes in upstate New York.
  • Advocated for complex marriages.
  • Society controlled behavior through public criticism.