Islamic Religious Architecture Notes
Regional Distinctions in Islamic Architecture
- Wrap up the semester by examining regional distinctions in Islamic architecture, focusing on decorative schemes in Spain and Iran, building on discussions from Monday.
- Identify familiar elements across mosques and variations based on location.
Decorative Schemas
- Revision of three ways to identify decorative schemas within Islamic religious architecture:
- Calligraphy
- Geometric
- Arabesque/Islimi
Iconoclasm Debate
- Iconoclasm: Debate over the worship of idols.
- Shift from depicting idols (e.g., Christ, Mary) to depictions of nature (gardens, flowing water) in religious architecture.
- Debate around the role of images in Christianity: symbolism vs. realistic figures.
- Danger of images leading to the worship of false idols.
- Calligraphy: Text-based art form; excessive to minimal forms; often tied to the individual (e.g., Sultan's signature).
- Example: Ottoman Tughra - signature of the Sultan used as a decorative scheme.
- Significance: Repetition signifies the Sultan's power and becomes an art form with its own decorative presence.
- Geometric Patterns: Based on mathematical studies; mathematics seen as inherent in nature; can expand infinitely.
- Mathematics connects nature, religion, and geometric logic.
- Sacred geometries: Based on mathematical relations, infinitely applicable.
- Begins from mathematical theorems rather than depictions of landscapes.
- Abstraction begins from laws of theory (order, organization, rules).
- Arabesque/Islimi: Vegetal forms of ornamentation.
- Vegetal forms (flowers, vines) are often interlaced.
- Highly abstracted ornamental style.
- Example: Lattice work with vegetal forms representing flowers.
Combination of Decorative Schemas
- Examples often combine calligraphy, geometric patterns, and arabesque.
- Interweaving of these schemas in decorative schemes.
- Seeing these interlinking forms working together in the way they're ornamented.
Architectural Terminology
- Mirab: Niches within walls marking the Qibla (direction facing Mecca).
- Development of direction of prayer towards Mecca and the Kaaba.
- Variation in shape (Byzantine-influenced archways).
- Minarets: Towers from which the call to prayer is made.
- Different expressive forms and horizontal hierarchies.
- Purpose: Site for the call to prayer; visible urban gesture; sonic aspect.
- Vertical element in the city, symbolic and visible in the landscape.
- Dome: Caps the most sacred part of the mosque.
- May be attached to the Qibla Wall or indicate a shrine.
- Sahn: Courtyard, often used for ablutions.
Orientation of Worship
- Orientation shapes the way architecture is organized across religions.
- Apse marks the altar in churches, indicating directionality.
- Stupa: Circular orientation around the finial.
- Early Christian churches: Domestic spaces with less clear orientation.
Regional Variations of Mosques
- Large, centrally organized dome spaces in Turkey.
- Hypostyle mosques in North Africa and Spain. Identification of hypostyle.
- Iwan mosques in Iran and Central Asia with courtyards and niches.
Hagia Sophia in Istanbul
- Precedes the Ottoman Empire; influenced by the Byzantine Empire.
- Symbolizes architectural transition when the Ottoman Empire conquered the city.
- Ottoman ambition to recreate the glory of a previous empire (Roman Empire).
- Large mosque compounds included religious schools, soup kitchens, and baths.
- Military involvement in construction projects signifies architecture's importance.
- Geopolitical location of Istanbul connects east and west, Europe and Asia.
Architectural Shift
- Christian basilica shifted: Nave with aisles and half-domes over the aisles.
- Structural innovations: Pendentives held the dome up.
Conversion to a Mosque
- Converted into a mosque by Mehmed the Conqueror.
- Additions: Four minarets.
- Interior: Mosaics plastered over, conversion of bells and altars.
- Retrofitting: Renovating the building for a different religious ideology.
- Removal of baptistery and depictions of Christian icons.
- Mirab inserted into eastern apse, slightly off orientation.
- Monograms of religious rulers placed on pillars.
Selimiye Mosque
- Designed by architect Sinan under Selim II of the Ottoman Empire.
- Considered a rival to Hagia Sophia.
- Aimed to surpass Hagia Sophia structurally and iconically.
- Larger dome and taller minarets.
- Complex featured prayer hall, courtyard, madrasas, and a semi-enclosed mihrab.
- Eight piers support the dome.
- Facade: Alternating rhythm of wider and narrower bays with pointed arches.
- Two-toned brickwork or stonework.
Architectural Details
- Central live dome with a ring of windows produces a floating sensation.
- Dome springs off an octagonal form with eight pylons.
- Geometry of the dome relates to the square outline of the space.
- Byzantine Christian influence in the two-toned brickwork.
- Ottoman influence in the tile work (calligraphy and geometry).
- Community spaces (shops, schools) connected to the mosque complex, fitting into the urban fabric.
Hypostyle Hall Mosques
- Characterized by a dense field of columns.
- Columns become the space itself; navigating through a forest of columns.
Great Mosque Of Samarra
- Abbasid capital moved to Samarra in 836.
- Included the caliph's residency and the mosque.
- Largest mosque in the world for a time, holding up to 80,000 worshipers.
- Rectangular brick wall and courtyard.
- Minaret built like a desert fortress with a coiled form, reaching upward with an internal staircase.
Great Mosque Of Cordoba
- Built under the Umayyad dynasty.
- One of the oldest structures from the time of Islamic rule in Southern Europe.
- Center for Arabic knowledge and a point of connection between Arabic and European cultures.
- Final exam is an at-home exam.
- Each question requires around 300-500 words.
Instructions
- Identify the week in which the case studies come from.
- Check the lectures and revise what was said about it and why it was important.
- Incorporate the essays.
- Cite all sources and include a bibliography. Every sentence has to be linked to a source.
- Make a final edit and upload the document.
Example Question
- If both case studies come from the same module, keep the responses confined to that module. Do not expand to include unrelated details.
- Refer to the essay provided in the prompt.
- Close reading of the image is important, as questions may pertain to implicit details.
Sourcing
- It is permissible to cite the lecture, but it is often more effective to verify information from a source external to the lecture when possible, in order to improve credibility.