Past Paper Questions
Which of the following was more important for the initial rise of the kingdom of kongo: the geographical location or role of kanda system [10]
Evidence for geography:
capital Mbanza Kongo was positioned on a mountain ensuring natural defence, access to Malabo pool which enabled slave trade and European connections, city became a stone city with the rising Portuguese population especially after 1568, was closer to central Africa so out of the direct power struggles in Western Africa
BUT
limited cultivable land due to the mountain range, seperated from Western African power struggles but surrounded by other violent kingdoms e.g. teke raiders, jaga group, nsundi, ndongo
Evidence for Kanda:
created a system of interlinked community, promoted self-sufficiency, separated the mwissikongo as a separate kanda family, encouraged vata system
BUT
the structure of the mwissikongo kanda specifically caused problems during succession period e.g. afonso being challenged after the death of Joao, created a power struggle, more distance kandas e.g. Soyo became seperated from ruling system of Mbanza kono
Which of the following was more important in explaining the manikongo’s adoption of Christianity in Kongo? I. Religious reasons II. Political reasons [10]
Religious reasons:
less important overall
religion became significant to the manikongos e.g. Joao changing his name from Kikongo to Portgueuse, widespread adoption throughout Kongo, 800-1000 people baptised a day by Montechristo, syncratic with African beliefs e.g. retention of Isimbi spirits, familiarity of the cross symbol
BUT
largely superficial e.g. most people were baptised because they wanted to add ‘dom’ to their names, underlying political motives, religious relationship was limited e.g. Afonso’s tensions over monogamy
Political reasons:
more important motive
centralised the King’s authority, Afonso claimed St James had helped him in the succession battle, King also became a royal authority, ‘ngolo’ (power) stemmed from a christian word, enabled the adoption of portuguese hierarchy systems
BUT
did cause issues with political power e.g. some manikongos were challenged by priests, tensions between Diogo I and Jesuits, they tried to expel him from the throne
The adoption of Catholicism was the cornerstone of the Manikongo’s power. How far do you agree?
“Kongo’s interactions with European powers were largely unsuccessful” How far do you agree?
Factors: political, economic, religious
Most contingent on economic state of relationship, biggest issues emerged here
Factor | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|
Cultural | adoption of Christianity, almost voluntary, successful syncretism with African spiritualism e.g. isimbi spirits, helped reinforce political power e.g. Afonso’s accession helped by st James | tensions with religious leaders emerged, Afonso had to appeal to the king of Portugal in 1529 and 1539 after the behaviour of priests, relationships broke down under Diogo, pope Sixtus V ignored Alvaro’s requests for religious aid |
Economic | Initially benefited from the slave trade significantly 1512 regimento established trading agreements, organised a monopoly between Kongo and Portugal slaves were seen as a distinct social group, so (initially) didn’t threat social structures in Kongo and helped the economy, making the mwissikongo no longer need to be self-sufficient | Went significantly downhill, portuguese began trading at Sao Tome with Ndongo, Kongo’s rivals, monopoly went out of the king’s hands, increase disputes over economic control, enslavement of huge amounts of the population (half by 1650s) |
Political | Portuguese helped reinforce Kongolese power, partially through religion but also administration. Afonso modelled Kongo society off of Portuguese administration, Portuguese merchants helped make it a stone city, aided with teke raiders, 600 sent to help in the jaga invasion between 1571-1573, helped centralise power and allowed mwissikongo to be self-sufficient Later relationships replaced by arrival of Dutch e.g. Dutch invasion of Luanda 1641 | Relationship deteriorated over time, Pedro II’s accession was met by a force of 20,000 Portuguese soldiers who he defeated, persuaded Diogo I to invade Ndongo in 1556 where he was defeated, wanted Kongo to be a vassal state under Alvaro |
How far do you agree that the institution of slavery benefited Kongo?
Political:
Afonso’s slave wars gave a military impetus to his kingdom, consolidated the south borders — gained 410 from the Dembos region
royal monopoly over slave trade, only King could sell slaves, established by 1512 regimento
improved relationships with the Portuguese, reinforced social hierarchy, took on new titles
BUT
political instability as groups competed over slave trade, factions emerged
trade shifted to Sao Tome which was out of the Manikongo’s control, started selling with Ngola
relationship with Portugal deteriorated
Economic:
initially greatly benefited the wealth of Kongo
Malebo pool was the site of trade, Kongo had access
traded with nzimbu shells, local currency, inflated Kongo strength
BUT
began to trade with other areas e.g. Ngolo
Took control of Luanda, led to a complete loss of treasury (Nzimbu shells)
Yaka start to sell free born Kongolese people
Social:
initially only captives from war were traded, didn’t threaten social groups
allowed for greater independence, no longer needed to be self-sufficient e.g. Mwissikongo more independent
came with christianity as well, increased social bonds
BUT
later led to the fundamental deterioration of Kongo
1656 — half of Kongo enslaved, Duartes Lopes ‘every man was enslaving his brother, son, father’
virtual abandonment of some areas, civil war and factional break down
To what extent did the manikongos of the Kongo kingdom maintain political stability
Assess the reasons for the collapse of Kongo.
succession - opposition between matrilineal and patrilineal
Alfonso I was the most successful Manikongo. How far do you agree?
Economic:
grew domestic trade through the establishments of roads, connections and commerce, facilitating internal economic prosperity
expanded to the south and the east, internal economic strength
But
under Afonso Portuguese controlled most economic decisions
Military:
ruled in relative peace and prosperity
limited military engagement which allowed for a focus on economic prosperity
maybe more successful than other later manikongos e.g.
diogo I’s defeat in Ndongo 1556 (led to Kongo losing its position as the sole portuguese trade point)
Garcia I forced to flee Soyo
But
later manikongos also achieved more military prestige
Alvaro I’s successful campaigns against the Jaga 1568
aided by the Portuguese but also shows portuguese relations
Pedro II able to defeat the Portuguese in 1623
Pedro’s actions also initiated and facilitated a relationship with the Dutch during the Luanda campaigns
Relationships with Europe
first African king recognised in Europe, very successful 1512 regimento, allowed for an exchange of european goods and taxation
But
these actions also allowed for a portuguese encroachment into Kongolese society
expelled huge amounts of Europeans in ___
Pedro more successful in dealing with the failed relationship with the portuguese
regained 1,200 kongolese slaves from brazil
aid from dutch in 1641 luanda attack
more controlled european relationships