W1, L3
The Role and Power of the Prime Minister
Constitutional Positioning: The Prime Minister (PM) is the head of government in New Zealand, not the head of state. Despite being the most powerful political figure who wields the power of the state, the role is notably absent from a single written constitutional document.
Statutory Presence: Traditionally, prime ministerial power is rarely defined in statutes. While the term "Prime Minister" appears more frequently in modern legislation than in the past, it describes the PM as a delegator of power (e.g., the power to appoint others to exercise authority) rather than establishing the PM's own inherent powers.
Specific Statutory Powers: A few narrow statutory powers exist for the PM, specifically regarding:
Official Information (as will be detailed later in the course).
Intelligence and Security Services.
Formal and Conventional Powers of the Prime Minister
Formal Authorities: The PM possesses two primary formal powers:
The power to call an election and determine its timing.
The power to appoint and dismiss ministers.
The Concept of "Advice": While ministers are technically appointed by the Governor General, this is done under the "advice" of the PM. In a constitutional context, "advice" is a binding instruction; the Governor General must act as the Prime Minister directs.
Constitutional Conventions: Julia defines a convention as "binding rules of political obligation."
These are accepted as binding right up until they are not followed.
Conventions provide the political rules and expectations that grant power to the PM, though these rules are ultimately underpinned by political realities.
Sources of Power: Party Leadership and Parliamentary Control
Parliamentary Roots: PM power is derived from their status as a parliamentary leader of a party or a coalition of parties.
The Whip System and Voting: In the New Zealand Parliament, individual MPs do not typically cast physical votes. Instead, the Party Whips present the numbers for their respective parties to the Clerk.
In the UK, MPs must physically enter a "lobby" to record their vote.
In NZ, the party-line vote is the standard, demonstrating the immense power of the party leadership.
Crossing the Floor: To rebel against the PM or party leader, an MP must physically "cross the floor" to the opposition side. This is an extreme action that effectively ends an MP's career within their party.
Patronage: The PM controls patronage, meaning they decide which MPs are promoted to ministerial roles and which remain as "backbenchers."
Under National Party rules, the PM has significant personal discretion over appointments.
Under Labour Party rules, a list is elected by MPs, though a strong leader still exercises substantial influence over the final selection.
Comparison to International Leaders: Despite the lack of formal constitutional powers, the New Zealand PM is often more powerful than foreign heads of state (like Presidents) because of the tight control they exert over the legislature through the party system.
Structure of the Executive Branch
Executive Council: This is the "dignified" element of the executive. It includes all ministers and is mentioned in the Constitution Act and various statutes.
Cabinet: The senior decision-making body, currently consisting of approximately ministers. The current (estimated) breakdown is:
National Party ministers.
ACT Party ministers.
New Zealand First ministers.
Ministers Outside Cabinet: There are currently ministers who hold warrants but do not sit in Cabinet.
Associate Ministers: Currently number . These roles function as deputies to senior ministers (e.g., an Associate Minister of Health).
Uni-nationally, in NZ, Associate Ministers are themselves often full ministers, a necessity caused by the small size of the Parliament ( members).
Lead Ministers: A new category introduced by the current government to focus on specific policy priorities.
Parliamentary Undersecretaries: Low-level deputy ministers who may not receive an additional ministerial wage. These are often appointed to satisfy coalition agreements.
Ministerial Responsibilities
Policy Portfolios: Every issue faced by the government falls under a specific portfolio (e.g., Health, Education, Defence). The PM defines these portfolios at their discretion.
Statutory Management: Ministers are responsible for managing specific Acts of Parliament and ensuring they are updated.
Legislative Stewardship: Ministers are responsible for shepherding specific bills through the House of Representatives.
Public Sector Oversight: Every government agency—including Core Departments (Public Service), Crown Entities (e.g., Universities), and State-Owned Enterprises—is linked to an individual minister. This link is the essential mechanism for democratic accountability between the executive and Parliament.
Collective Responsibility and Cabinet Dynamics
The Principle: Collective responsibility is a convention where ministers may debate issues robustly in private, but once a Cabinet decision is made, all ministers must publicly support and defend it.
Political Drivers: This convention is driven by the public's dislike of divided governments. Division often leads to suffering at the polls.
The Impact of MMP: The Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) system has "softened" collective responsibility. Coalition partners (like ACT or NZ First) often seek to differentiate themselves from the leading party (National).
"Agree to Disagree" clauses are now common in coalition agreements.
High-profile figures, such as Winston Peters, have historically challenged the boundaries of this convention due to their political importance within a coalition.
International Comparisons: Unlike New Zealand’s requirement for unity, societies like Switzerland, Belgium, and Northern Ireland accept divided executives as a norm due to their proportionately appointed or deeply divided social structures.
Cabinet Committees and Internal Decision-Making
Cabinet Committees: The actual "work" of Cabinet happens in smaller subsets or committees where specific decisions (e.g., those involving the Treasury) are finalized before being formally approved by the full Cabinet.
The Role of the PM in Decision-Making: Cabinet does not operate by a formal majority vote. The Clerk (who sits next to the PM) records the decision, but the PM is the one who ultimately states what the decision is.
Leadership Styles: Decision-making is highly dependent on the personality and "mana" of the PM.
Some PMs, like Helen Clark, were known for a very clear and forceful leadership style.
Others may prefer to build a consensus.
Questions & Discussion
Question (Julia): What is a convention?
Response: Julia defined it as "binding rules of political obligation." The lecturer noted they are accepted as binding until the moment they are not followed, noting that Winston Peters provides many examples of this.
Question (Student): How do parties vote physically?
Response: The Whips present the numbers of their parties to the Clerk (e.g., "50 National votes"). Individual voting is not standard.
Question (Alicia): What if you don't want to be part of that party vote?
Response: Alicia would have to "cross the floor," which effectively ends her career with the party.
Question (Estelle): How do you become a minister?
Response: Through ambition and by supporting the leader's agenda. The fastest way to not become a minister is to "piss off" the Prime Minister, who holds the power of patronage.
Question (Sylvia): Why are Associate Ministers also Ministers in NZ?
Response: Sylvia correctly identified the practical need for holding a warrant. The lecturer added that because the NZ Parliament is so small ( members), the talent pool is limited, and nearly a third of the governing party's MPs may already be in the executive.
Question (Anika): Why is showing unity important?
Response: Anika noted it creates faith that everything is running smoothly. The lecturer added that NZ voters culturally dislike divided governments and will punish them at the polls.
Question (Moss): How does Cabinet decide?
Response: Moss suggested everyone is responsible for the decisions collectively. The lecturer clarified that decisions are not votes but are dictated by the Prime Minister based on consensus or personal authority.