How Rolls-Royce Bribed Its Way Around the World
Rolls Royce Bribery Allegations
Introduction
Rolls Royce, a British icon, faces accusations of corruption through systematic use of agents/middlemen for bribery to secure contracts.
Brazil and Petrobras Scandal
Political Crisis in Brazil: Triggered by widespread corruption involving politicians and state officials.
Petrobras: Brazil's state oil company, a major player producing 2,000,000 barrels of oil daily, relies on equipment from foreign companies like Rolls Royce.
Rolls Royce's Involvement: One contract with Petrobras was valued at .
Pedro Burushko: A Petrobras executive, revealed companies involved in bribery. He identified Rolls Royce as one of the companies that paid bribes so he could handle deposits.
Rolls Royce Bribes: Paid via middlemen, with Burushko receiving at least USD from the contract.
Consultants: Commonly used by foreign companies to deliver bribes to directors or politicians.
Public Perception: Rolls Royce's reputation in Brazil is damaged; seen as a significant part of the corruption problem due to its global power and wealth.
Rolls Royce's Business
Current Focus: Primarily building engines for aircraft (car division sold to BMW).
UK Employment: Employs 23,000 people in the UK.
Growth: Experienced spectacular growth with sales tripling and profits increasing fivefold over fifteen years.
Investigation: The Guardian newspaper and the Serious Fraud Office (SFO) are investigating Rolls Royce's use of dubious middlemen to secure contracts in corrupt countries.
Allegations in Indonesia
SFO Investigation (2013): Investigating how Rolls Royce won jet engine contracts.
Whistleblower: A former employee alleged a bribe was paid to Tommy Suharto (former president's son) to ensure Indonesia's main airline used Rolls Royce engines.
Prima Facie Evidence: Paying bribes to people closely linked to senior politicians is considered prima facie evidence of corruption.
Allegations in China
Second Whistleblower (Soaring Dragon, 2011): Suggested Rolls Royce paid bribes to win contracts at two airlines in China.
Mechanism: Bribes paid to a Chinese airline executive through a middleman.
Chinese Authorities: Investigated, convicted, and jailed the airline executive for life, but no action against Rolls Royce.
Contracts Secured: Rolls Royce secured contracts worth from two Chinese airlines during the period the bribes were allegedly paid.
UniOil and Lindsay Mitchell
Middlemen: Rolls Royce uses middlemen to facilitate work in corrupt countries. Lindsay Mitchell worked for UniOil (Monaco based company), also under investigation by the SFO.
Confession: Mitchell admits to bribing an oil official to help a client win business, referring to it as a "facility payment" or "commission."
Rolls Royce's Knowledge: Mitchell believes UniOil paid bribes for Rolls Royce, suggesting that someone within Rolls Royce management knew about these payments.
Leaked Emails: UniOil emails suggest paying bribes was commonplace, and some involved Rolls Royce.
Examples from emails:
An email showing that UniOil put aside for middlemen on a Rolls Royce job in Iraq.
Another shows how gifts were bought for an official involved with the contract, spending more than on luxury goods.
Rationale: The emails explicitly state that spending a small amount on a key decision-maker is worth a hundred times that value.
India and Sudhir Chowdhury
Previous Issue: Rolls Royce offered to repay £ commission secretly paid to a middleman in 2014.
Defense Contracts: The most serious questions relate to defense deals where large sums of money change hands.
Hawk Jet Deal: Rolls Royce supplied engines for the Hawk jet, earning around £ from the Indian government.
Sudhir Chowdhury: A London-based billionaire and advisor on India to the Liberal Democrats who is allegedly a secretive middleman involved in Rolls Royce's defense deals.
Illegality: It is illegal to pay secret middlemen to win defense contracts in India.
Anonymous Source: Confirmed that someone from Chowdhury's team approached him for an introduction to the government regarding the Hawk deal.
Payments: Panorama understands Rolls Royce secretly paid around £ to companies owned by the Chowdhury family.
Undesirable Contact Men List: Sudhir Chowdhury is on the Indian government's blacklist of individuals suspected of corrupt practices, manipulation of defense procurement
Peter Ginger and Banu Chowdhury:
Banu Chowdhury, the son of Sudhir Chowdhury, is suspected of helping Rolls Royce win the Hawk deal.
Peter Ginger, who played a key role in selling military jets with Rolls Royce engines to the Indian government, visited Switzerland with Banu Chowdhury in 2007 and opened a Swiss bank account under the name of Portsmouth.
Ginger's account later showed a million Swiss francs.
Ginger refused to answer direct questions about whether the money was a bribe.
Legal and Financial Ramifications
SFO Investigation: Thirty investigators are working on the Rolls Royce case.
US Investigation: A separate investigation is underway in the United States.
Potential Penalties: Rolls Royce could face enormous fines, and employees could be jailed.
Ethical Implications
Reputational Damage: Rolls Royce's actions damage its brand and the UK's reputation.
Corruption and Instability: Bribing for contracts promotes corruption, making the world more unstable and less democratic.
Rolls Royce's Response
Zero Tolerance: Rolls Royce states it has zero tolerance for bribery and corruption and has intensified its focus on ethics and compliance.
Business Model Change: Bribing is no longer an option for Rolls Royce.