World War I and American Neutrality

American Neutrality and WWI

Initial Position

  • The U.S. aimed to avoid involvement in European wars, following Washington's recommendation.

  • This wasn't isolationism; the U.S. continued to engage internationally, especially economically.

  • The public was largely horrified by the barbaric nature of modern industrial warfare in the trenches and desired to stay out of it.

Washington's Directive

  • Two-pronged approach:

    • Avoid European politics and wars.

    • Trade extensively and profitably with all nations.

  • Balancing these two aspects became challenging.

International Law and Contraband

  • Late 19th and early 20th-century international agreements sought to establish rules of war.

  • Key concern: defining "contraband of war," which was crucial for trade.

  • The British heavily favored these since they had a powerful navy consisting of surface ships and dreadnoughts.

U-Boats and Unrestricted Submarine Warfare

  • Germans countered British naval superiority with U-boats (submarines).

  • U-boats were small, cheap, and posed a significant threat to enemy ships.

  • U-boats frequently had to surface to recharge batteries using diesel generators, requiring oxygen.

  • Germans adopted a policy of sinking British ships without warning.

  • This policy intended to shift the dynamics of the conflict, given Germany's limited options.

  • Germany knew this policy might provoke the U.S. to enter the war.

Eastern Front Considerations

  • By 1918, Germany was heavily involved on the Western Front.

  • They sought to focus on the Russian heartland (Poland, Ukraine, and the Baltics) because Russia was in a civil war.

  • They wanted to focus their energies on winning their civil war.

Resumption of Unrestricted Submarine Warfare

  • In early 1917, before the radical phase of the Russian Revolution, Germany planned to resume unrestricted submarine warfare.

  • This decision was recognized as potentially "stupid" due to the risk of drawing the U.S. into the war.