crim 2

CRIM2. Theories and Crime Causation

Comes from the Greek word theoria which means "viewing", "thinking" or "reflecting"

Formal statement of ideas that are suggested to explain a fact or event, or how something works

Theory

•It is a system of construction and proposition that collectively present a logical, systematic, and coherent explanation of a phenomenon of interest within some assumption and Clasundary condition are abstract concepts that systematically describe the causes or genesis of crimes. These theories often provide empirical insights to anyone who ventures unto crime analysis

Foundations of Crime Causation

Demonology Theory - earliest theory of crime causation that is grounded on the belief that criminals were possessed by evil spirit - a supernatural force beyond one's control which compel them to commit crimes.

Free will-It refers to human`s freedom or capacity to act or decide in his own.

School of Thought

Classical School- views crime as a product of free will, hedonism, and rational choice. It anchors on the argument that human beings are endowed with free will and rationality, and that human actions are results of the rational calculation of the costs and benefits.

Rationality.- means performing an act, or make a decision with sound judgment, logic, reasonableness, and often conformity with established societal norms.

Proponents of the Classical School

• Cesare Beccaria- (March 15, 1738-November 28, 1794) an Italian scholar, philosopher, reformist who is widely recognized as the founder of the classical school. He rose into fame after he published his 17 pages essay entitled, "On Crimes and Punishment" in 1764

Jeremy Bentham (26 February, 1748-June 6, 1832) was an English jurist, philosopher, and legal and social reformer.He advocated utilitarianism.

The root word in utilitarianism is "utility" which means "useful." It means the "greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. Punishment exists to ensure the continuance of society and to deter people from committing crimes. Deterrence comes, not from trying to be harsh, but from punishment that is appropriate (severity), prompt (celerity), and inevitable (certainty)

Neo-Classical School- from the word "neo" which means new. It argued that since children and lunatics are incapable of calculating pain and pleasure, they should be treated differently.

Positivist or Italian School

-views crime as a product mber the internal and external He factors which are beyond one's control. It implores science in explaining the causes of crime and prop the idea of individualized treatment of offenders. Criminal offenders should considered as part of and apart from the society.

Proponents of the Positivist School

A. Cesare Lombroso, born Ezechia Marco Lombroso (November 6, 1836-October 19, 1909) was an Italian criminologist and founder of the Italian School of Positivist Criminology. He wrote the writings entitled as THE CRIMINAL MAN.

Criminal Man- The first book which describes the causes of crime. It contains the argument that a criminal can be identified through his or her biological makeup or physical appearance

Enrico Ferri A student of Lombroso, believed that social as well as biological factors played a role, and held the view that criminals should not be held responsible for the factors causing their criminality were beyond their control.

He argued that crime is not only caused by anthropological or individual factors (e.g. intelligence, age, sex, psychological makeup, etc.), rather by sociological factors (e.g. family circumstances, religion, societal status, etc.), and even environmental or geographical factors (e.g. weather condition, etc.)Also, he held the view that criminals should not be held responsible for the factors causing their criminality were beyond their control

C. Raffaele Garofalo (1851-1934)

An Italian jurist and a student of Cesare Lombroso. He rejected the doctrine of free will and supported the position that crime can be understood only if it is studied by scientific methods. • We-are constituted having the tendency to commit crimes, which Garofalo termed as NATURAL CRIME which violating probity (correctness/moral) and pity (shame/disappointment)

4 Types of criminal by Garofalo

Murderer - refers to a criminal who kills another person and is satisfied from vengeances or revenge. This criminal totally lacks both pity and probity and kill whenever opportunity arises.

Deficient Criminal – it refers to a person who commits crime against property like thieves and robbers

Violent Criminal – this criminal lacks of pity and can be influenced by environmental factors such as consumption of alcohol.

Lascivious Criminal - it refers to a person who commits crime against chastity like act of

lasciviousness, seduction, adultery and the like

POSITIVIST SCHOOL THEORIST :(the holy three)

1.CESARE LAMBROSO

2.ENRICO FERRI

3.RAFFAELE GAROFALO

WHAT IS BIOLOGICAL THEORIES OF CRIME CAUSATION?

These are theories that link crime with human being's physical or biological dispositions. It clings on the idea that criminality has something to do with person's genetic blueprint.

Prior to Lombros's Biological theory of crime, Cesare Beccaria and Jeremy Bentham had introduced the Classical School of Crime. The Classical School of Crime was a theory based on the notion that an individual who possesses "free will" chooses a life of crime. Cesare Lombroso would dispute the concept behind the Classical School on the basis that the individual and the crime itself are two different components.

a) Biological theories: Physical Trait Theories

B) Biological theories: Body Type and Physique and Genetics

Physical Trait Theories

The belief that one can determine a person's character, moral disposition, or behavior by observing his or her physical characteristics is ancient. Pythagoras, a philosopher,

mathematician, and scientist who lived during the period around 500BC may have been one of the first to advocate this practice, known as Physiognomy.

Physiognomy Theory

• The term physiognomy comes from the Greek word physis, meaning nature, and gnomon, meaning to judge or to interpret

• dubbed as "face reading"

the study of the person's personality traits or character based on facial appearance.

Physiognomy Theorist or Physiognomists

1. Giambatitista Della Porta - Founded the Physiognomy, he examined patients during his medical practice and concluded that the appearance and character were related. For example, men who look like donkeys are similar to donkeys in their laziness and stupidity, men who resemble pigs behave like pigs.

2. Johann Kaspar Lavater - Facial Figures and Crime, He conclude that one could determine criminal behavior through an examination of a person's eyes, ears, nose, chin and facial shape.

2. Jacob Fries - Physical appearance, Fries relate nature of the crime to personality of the individual or suggested a link between crime and physical appearance.

Physiognomic Interpretations

• Men with big upper lips signified stupidity

• Flat nose like of the pig indicated stupidity

Pointed nose like of the dog signified choleric temperament Lion-like nose implied generosity

• Persons with noses like the hawk or eagle were magnanimous

• Fine hair like of the rabbit and sheep indicated timidity

Rough hair like of the lion or boar implied courage

• Fat ears like of the Ox implied laziness

Phrenology Theory

Phrenology, from a Greek word phren, meaning mind, and logos, meaning Knowledge, is based on the belief that the human behavior originated in brain.

which focuses on personality and character, should be distinguished from craniometry, which is the study of skull size, weight and shape, and physiognomy, study of facial features.

The study of the person's personality traits or character based on skull formation.

Phrenology Theorist or Phrenologists

• Franz Joseph Gall - German Neuroanatomist and physiologist who pioneered the study of the human brain as the source of mental faculties, developed the practice of cranioscopy, a technique by which to infer behavior and characteristics from external examination of the skull (cranium)

According to Gall, a person's strengths, weaknesses, morals, proclivities, character, and personality could be determined by physical characteristics of skull formation.

• Johann Spurzheim - a German physician and student of Gall, actually coined the term phrenology to replace Cranioscopy.

In 1812, Spurzheim also expanded the map of the brain organs.

Body Type and Physique and Genetics

•Body type theory is also called as biological constitutional (structure of the body), or genetic.

Body Type and Physique

• The Body Type and Physique theory view that there is a relationship on the type of human body to criminality. This theory is also called Criminal Anthropology Theory.

Criminal Anthropological Theorist

A. Cesare Lombroso - Lombroso, inspired by Charles Darwin's Evolutionary theory in 1868 presented his work on atavism in his book L'uomo delinquente (Criminal man) first published in 1876.

⚫ - grounded on the belief that criminals are identifiable through their physical anomalies or stigmata. Lombroso asserted that unlike law abiders, criminals are having the appearance of pre-human forms- a primitive stage of evolution. They closely resemble their apelike ancestor in traits, abilities, and disposition. Because Criminals were not highly evolved, they possessed stigmata or distinctive Classphysical features.

Lombroso's Theory of Anthropological Criminology essentially stated the

following

1. That the criminality is inherited; and

2. Someone is born criminal and could be identified by physical defects, which confirmed a criminal as savage, or atavistic

Stigmata related to an atavistic criminal

1. Deviation in head size and shape from type common to race and region from which the criminal came.

2. Asymmetry of the face.

3. Eye defects and peculiarities

4. Excessive dimension of the jaw and cheekbones

5. Ears of unusual size, or occasionally very small, or standing out from the head as to those of a chimpanzee

6. twisted nose,

7 Lips fleshy, swollen, and protruding

Criminal Anthropological Theorist

B. Ernst Kretschmer - Kretschmer developed his Physique Theory in his book Physique and Character published in 1921,

• Kretschmer's Body Physiques

- assumed that there is a link between the individual's physical makeup and his personality and that certain body builds correspond to certain temperaments.

Four Types of Body Physiques.

• Asthenic - are those persons who are thin, with narrow shoulders, flat chest, loose skin, and long limbs. Asthenic are shy, timid, introvert, with serious personality but with fondness in reading and studying. To Kretschmer, asthenic is likely to commit petty theft and fraud.

Athletic - people under this category are muscular and with strong development of the skeleton. The personality of being aggressive is linked to this type. Athletic people are prone to commit violence compared to asthenic.

Pyknic - are those that are fat with rounded bodies with fleshy arms and legs. This category is more likely to commit fraud and deception and sometimes violence. On the temperament side, pyknic people are into mood swings, who sometimes are happy and at other times are irritable and depressed.

. Dysplastic type (mixed type) - people who have no desired body physiques belong to this category. Kretschmer argued that individuals under this type are prone to commit crimes against decency and morality.

Somatotypes

Popularized by William Sheldon, an American psychologist who made his own version of body types which he termed somatoypes.

Criminal Anthropological Theorist William H. Sheldon. Sheldon in 1940s, developed and tested his classification system, known as Somatotyping. He attempted to document a direct link between biology (specifically, physique) and personality (specifically, crime) through the development of a classification system of personality patterns and corresponding physical builds. He associated body type (physique) to human temperament and created three classification of somatotypes, namely:

Somatotypes

1. Ectomorph - this is similar to Kretschmer`s asthenic body physique. Similarly, ectomorphs are thin or slender. Sheldon associated this type to cerebrotonic temperament with characters of being introverted, insomniac, full of complaints, sensitivity to noise and distractions, and self conscious.

2. Endomorph - this is similar to Kretschmer's pyknic body physique. Endomorphs are those whose body is fat, soft, and round. It is attributed to a viscerotonic type of temperament - extroverted,jolly, relaxed, lazy, comfortable, and sociable

3. Mesomorph - the athlectic type in Kretschmer's classification.Mesomorphs are characterized by dominated muscles, large hands and wrists, and heavy chest. Mesomorphs are somotonic having the characters of being active, aggressive, and dynamic.

2. Early Genetic Theories and Studies on Crime

Genetic theories view that traits of human being can be transferred from one generation to the next. This theory believes on the laws of inheritances.

Early Theorist and Researchers on Genetics

A. Charles Darwin.

Charles Darwin first proposed the idea that genetics and evolution both contribute to human qualities including personality. Darwin propounded his Theory of Evolution in book On the Origin of Species published in 1859.

Darwin believed that criminal behavior is inherited or could be transferred by parents to their offspring. In reiteration, the atavism of Lombroso was drawn from the concept of Charles Darwin who claimed that criminals were born and were atavistic throwbacks to earlier historical periods.

Francis Galton. Galton, a cousin of Charles Darwin, Developed his Theory of Eugenics in 1883. Eugenics advocated the encouragement, through the distribution of incentives, of "able" couples to reproduce in an effort to improve human hereditary traits.

Two Kinds of Eugenics Positive Eugenics (more fit) Negative Eugenics (less fit)

• Eugenics - the science of improving a human population by controlled

·breeding to increase the occurrence of desirable heritable characteristics.

Developed largely by Francis Galton as a method of improving the human race.

• Coming from a Greek word meaning "good in birth," the term eugenics refers to a controversial area of genetic science based on the belief that the human species can be improved by encouraging only people or groups with "desirable" traits to reproduce, while discouraging or even preventing reproduction among people with "undesirable” qualities.

• Its stated goal is to improve the human condition by "breeding out" disease, disability, and other subjectively defined undesirable characteristics from the human population.

Early Theorist and Researchers on Genetics

Her sterilization would have cost $150.

ADA JUKE 1740

92% of her Descendants

64 174

196

142 77

Mentally/Sex-perverts Illegitimates Paupers Criminals

Discosed

Classin

Murderers

Richard Dugdale. After Galtons effort, Richard Dugdale attempted to document that crime was a family traits. Dugdale published his study entitled, The jukes: a study in crime, pauperism, disease and heredity in 1877, in which he traced the descendants of matriarch Margaret Ada Jukes and found out that most of the Jukes family members were Criminals, prostitute, or welfare recipients.

• His book claimed Max Jukes, a frontiersman who was the descendant of early Dutch settlers and who was born between 1720 and 1740, had been the ancestor of more than 76 convicted Criminals, 18 brothel-keepers, 120 prostitute, over 200 relief recipients, and two cases of "feeble-mindedness".

•Many of the Criminals studied by Dugdale could also be linked to "Margaret, the Mother of Criminals", renamed "Ada" in his report, who had married one of Max's sons. • He noted that the Jukes were not a single family, but a composite of 42 families.

MARTIN KALLIKAK

He dallied with a feeble-minded tavern girl She bore a son known as "Old Horror" who had ten children From "Old Horror's" ten children come hundreds of the lowest types of human beings He married a worthy Quakeress She bore seven upright worthy children From these seven worthy children come hundreds of the highest types of human beings

D. Henry H. Goddard. Goddard published his study entitled, The Kallikak Family: A Study in the Feeble-Mindedness in 1912 that traced descendants of a man named Martin Kallikak Sr. Goddard developed the pseudonym Kallikak by combining a Greek root meaning beauty (kallos) with one meaning bad (kakos). He also introduced the term moron.

Goddard concluded that a variety of mental traits were hereditary and that should limit reproduction by people possessing these traits.

•Involved Martin Kalikak, a revolutionary war soldier. Martin had two separate relationships which in turned represents the "good offspring" and the "bad offspring"

• Martin Sr. had an illegitimate son with an unnamed barmaid, named as Martin Kallikak Jr.

• Goddard's study traced back six generations of the family of young institutionalized woman (Deborah kallikak real name Emma Wolvertonand, the great-great-great granddauther of Martin Kalikak, Jr.)

Deborah gained admission at the training school at Vineland because she did not do well at school and might possibly be feeble-minded.

Martin kallikak. Jr. have become 480 descendants:

143 were feeble-minded, only 46 have been found normal, the rest are unknown or doubtful.

36 have illegitimate

33 sexually immoral person, mostly prostitutes

· 24 confirmed alcoholics

3 epileptics

• 82 died in infancy

3 were criminal

8kept houses of ill fame

Martin Sr. went back to his legal spouse, a "Quaker"

With the "Quaker", martin begot sons, daughters, and grandchildren, who all became prosperous

They were lawyers, doctors, and ministers, and none was feebleminded.

Goddard concluded that intelligence and feeblemindedness can be inherited

WHAT ID FEEBLE-MINDED?

3. Genetics in Modern Biological Theories and Studies

a. Theory of XYY or Chromosome Imbalanced Human

cells normally have 22 pairs of Chromosomes, Plus a pair of chromosome that determines the sex, for a total of 46. Sex Chromosomes are termed X and Y chromosomes. They are combined as follows:

1. Female carry a combination of XX.

2. Males carry a combination of XY.

XYY Syndrome

During conception, the male's sperm carries genetic material to the female's egg. If the sperm fertilizes a female egg is carrying a Y chromosome, the resulting embryo will develop into male fetus (XY). If the sperm is carrying an X

chromosome, the resulting embryo will develop into female fetus (XX).

• During this process, however, things can develop

abnormally. For example, during the process, some men are left with extra Y chromosome (XYY). Erroneously termed XYY syndrome, a "supermale"

The person carrying XYY chromosome usually has a normal appearance and will probably never known that he carries an extra Y chromosome, unless he is genetically tested for some other reason.

• The presence of additional male chromosome has been found to impact on the temperament and behaviour of individuals

• Explosive temper, hyperactivity, defiance and anti social behaviour found in individuals with XYY syndrome.

Jacob et al found that males with the XYY Syndrome were more aggressive than males with an XY chromosome pattern

They found 7 out of 196 males in prison had XYY syndrome compared to 1 in 1,000 of population

Coined the term "supermale syndrome"

following research in Carstairs Prison in Scotland

b. Twin and Adoption Studies.

Correlations between Criminality and Twins (both monozygotic "identical" and dizygotic "fraternal") and between children who have been adopted and their biological families. • Identical twins have 100% of the same genetic structure - if both commit criminal acts, a genetics cause may be attributed to the behaviour Non-identical twins do not have 100% similarity in genetic structure, and so less likely to behave in a similar way due to genes.

Evidence from Twin Studies

Johannes Lange found higher concordance levels of criminal behavior in identical twins than non-identical twins

• Lange studied 30 pairs of twins who were of the same sex, 10 out of 13 sets of identical twins both had criminal records compared to 2 out of 17 non-identical twins

Evidence from Adoption Studies

• B. Hutching and S.A. Mednick found high rates of concordances between criminal behaviour in adopted boys and their biological parents

• Mednick also found low rates of concordance between adopted boys and their adoptive parents