MERP Chapter 4e Chapter 3
Chapter 3: ERP and Business Process Redesign
Business Process
Definition: A business process is a sequence of linked activities that an organization employs to create a product or service.
Comprises a set of procedures that fulfill a business objective.
Types of Business Processes:
Generic vs Unique: Some processes are standardized, while others are tailored to specific organizational needs.
Supporting vs Core: Supporting processes aid core operations, which are critical for delivering value.
Simple vs Complex: Processes can range in complexity; complex processes typically involve multiple steps and departments.
Short vs Long-Running: Some processes are brief, while others may be extensive and ongoing.
Formal vs Informal: Processes may be rigidly defined or adapt flexibly to changing circumstances.
Optimal Business Process Criteria
Cost Efficiencies: Streamline employee work to save on costs.
Customer Satisfaction and Differentiation: Enable better service and clear differentiation in the market.
Standardization: Ensure consistent performance across locations or units.
Value-Added Activities: Focus on processes that contribute positively to the organization.
Improved Agility and Speed: Maintain nimble processes to adapt to market changes swiftly.
Scalability: Design processes to handle expected future workloads to facilitate company growth.
"As Is" vs "To Be" Processes
"As Is" Process: The current flawed procedure that requires improvement.
"To Be" Process: The envisioned future design for the new or improved business process.
Problems with "As Is" Business Processes
Bottlenecks: Information flow leads to single activities, limiting performance and causing delays.
Cycle Time: The duration from beginning to end must be optimized for satisfaction and output.
Data Duplication: Results from unintegrated systems leading to inefficiencies.
Handoffs: Responsibility transfer can result in miscommunication and delays.
Inflexibility: Inability to adapt to changing requirements.
Intermediaries: Unnecessary steps causing bureaucratic delays.
Lack of Consequences: Absence of penalties for non-compliance with standards.
Lack of Visibility: Management lacks a clear overview of the processes.
Manual Steps: These increase error rates and cycle times.
Old Ways: Resistance to new technology leads to continual outdated practices.
Paper Records: Reliance on outdated records should be eliminated.
Quality Control Issues: Inefficient checks add time; processes should be as mistake-proof as possible.
Rework: Need to find and eliminate sources of errors.
Role Ambiguity: Lack of clarity hinders process efficiency.
Scalability Issues: Processes not designed to scale can hinder growth.
Segregation of Duties: Essential to prevent fraud; tasks should not enable concealment of wrongdoings.[
Business Process Reengineering (BPR)
Definition: Fundamental and radical redesign of business processes for significant improvements in performance metrics.
Focuses on enhancing efficiency, customer orientation, and overall performance.
Types of BPR: Clean slate and technology-enabled approaches.
Clean Slate Reengineering
Involves starting from scratch (a "clean sheet") and fostering innovative process design.
Encourages fresh ideas and creates unique, competitive processes.
BPR Principles
Involve those who need the output in the process execution.
Treat geographically dispersed resources as centralized for scale benefits.
Link activities in parallel instead of merely integrating end results.
Organize jobs around business processes rather than simple tasks.
Information processing should be integrated into real work, eliminating unnecessary roles.
Decision points should be accessible to those performing the work.
Capture data where it originates to ensure accuracy and audibility.
Technology-Enabled Reengineering
Utilizes technology (such as ERP systems) to guide process redesign.
Imposes specific constraints on how processes can be structured, leading to efficient designs.
Paving the Cow Paths
Refers to the practice of replicating outdated processes in new ERP systems instead of optimizing them.
Customization of ERP software to fit old methods can drive up costs significantly.
Fatal Business Process Reengineering Mistakes
Unclear Definitions: BPR is not merely downsizing, restructuring, or automating.
Unrealistic Expectations: Gains from BPR should be attainable and expectations carefully managed.
Insufficient Input: Ensure a mix of internal and external insights for the BPI project.
Prolonged Projects: Prolonged changes can undermine engagement and credibility.
Wrong Scope: Address the entire process, not just components; focus on strategically important processes.
Lack of Methodology: A structured approach aids in selecting methods and achieving goals.
Inadequate Resources: Commit sufficient time and funds to support BPR efforts.
Business Process Improvement (BPI)
Encompasses gradual and incremental changes to existing processes.
Less intensive than BPR and often involves smaller scope adjustments.
Business Process Improvement Model
Identify goals and assemble a team.
Compile an inventory of key business processes and subprocesses.
Gather information from process experts.
Analyze and measure processes to identify problems.
Adopt and promote continuous improvement practices.
Roles for Business Process Redesign
Leader: Provides overall project governance and direction.
Architect: In-depth knowledge of processes and designs solutions.
Analyst: Analyzes requirements and defines specifications.
Coordinator: Manages project logistics and communication.
Modeler: Documents processes and supports redesign efforts.
Processes in Need of Change
Customer-Facing Processes: Should facilitate customer interaction for retention.
Core Competency Processes: Essential operations that need benchmark improvements.
High Volume, Low-Margin Processes: Indicators of harsh market competition.
Quality Control: Transition from reactive management to proactive failure prevention.
High Skill Intensive Processes: Labour-heavy approaches need efficiency assessment.
Obsolete Technology: Digital transformation is necessary to upgrade legacy systems and business models.
Stakeholder Analysis
Essentials for identifying individuals/groups influential to the project's success.
Conduct assessments of risks associated with process redesign and devise mitigation strategies.
Assess the level of support for changes and the impact on the redesign process.
Questions for Identifying Key Stakeholders
Who can contribute valuable input for the project?
Who stands to benefit from the process changes?
Who could be adversely affected by the changes?
Who will require training to adapt to the new processes?
Who is responsible for managing or maintaining the revamped processes?