Microeconomics: Chapter 8 - Profit Maximization and Competitive Supply in the Long Run

Producer Surplus in the Short Run and Market

Producer surplus for a firm is the sum over all units produced of the differences between the market price of a good and the marginal cost of production. Graphically, it is measured by the area below the market price line and above the marginal cost curve between output 00 and the profit-maximizing output q∗q^*. Alternatively, producer surplus equals total revenue minus total variable cost, represented by rectangle ABCDABCD. For an entire market, producer surplus is the total area below the equilibrium market price P∗P^* and above the market supply curve between output 00 and market output Q∗Q^*.


Producer surplus for a firm

Long-Run Output Choice and Competitive Equilibrium

In the long run, a competitive profit-maximizing firm selects its output level where price equals long-run marginal cost (LMCLMC). A long-run competitive equilibrium is reached when three conditions hold: all firms in the industry maximize profit, no firm has an incentive to enter or exit because all firms earn zero economic profit, and market price equates quantity supplied with quantity demanded.


Long-run competitive equilibrium industry supply shift

When initial market price is \topstep1 at \text{\\$40} per unit, firms earn positive economic profits because long-run average cost reaches its minimum of \text{\\$30} at output q2q_2. These positive profits attract new entrants, shifting the industry supply curve rightward from S1S_1 to S2S_2. Market price falls to \text{\\$30}, driving economic profits to zero and eliminating any further incentive for entry or exit.

Accounting Profit, Economic Profit, and Economic Rent

Accounting profit equals total revenue RR minus labor costs wLwL. Economic profit accounts for opportunity costs by subtracting both labor costs wLwL and capital costs rKrK from total revenue RR. Zero economic profit means a firm earns a normal return on its investment, performing as well as it could by investing capital elsewhere.

Economic rent is the amount firms are willing to pay for an input minus the minimum amount necessary to obtain it. In competitive markets with scarce or heterogeneous inputs—such as patented technology, prime real estate, or sports franchises—economic rent is positive even when economic profit is zero. In long-run competitive equilibrium, a firm's producer surplus consists of the economic rent generated by its scarce inputs.

Industry Long-Run Supply Curves

The shape of the long-run industry supply curve depends on how output expansion impacts input costs. In a constant-cost industry, such as coffee production, input prices remain constant as industry output expands, resulting in a horizontal long-run supply curve SLS_L at the long-run minimum average cost.


Long-run supply in a constant-cost industry

In an increasing-cost industry, such as oil production, output expansion bids up input prices, resulting in an upward-sloping long-run supply curve SLS_L. In a decreasing-cost industry, such as automobile manufacturing, increased production volume reduces input costs, resulting in a downward-sloping long-run supply curve SLS_L

Effects of an Output Tax

An output tax tt placed on a single competitive firm shifts its marginal cost curve upward by tt to MC2=MC1+tMC_2 = MC_1 + t. The firm reduces output to the point where marginal cost plus tax equals product price P1P_1


Effect of an output tax on a competitive firm's output

When an output tax tt is levied on all firms in an industry, the industry supply curve shifts upward by tt from S1S_1 to S2=S1+tS_2 = S_1 + t. This shift raises market price from P1P_1 to P2P_2 and reduces total industry output from Q1Q_1 to Q2Q_2

Long-Run Supply Elasticity and Fixed Supply Constraints

Long-run elasticity of industry supply is the percentage change in quantity supplied (ΔQQ\frac{\Delta Q}{Q}) divided by the percentage change in price (ΔPP\frac{\Delta P}{P}). Supply elasticity is horizontal and infinitely large in constant-cost industries, while positive and finite in increasing-cost industries. Long-run supply is generally more elastic than short-run supply because firms can fully adjust input capacities and market entry can occur.

When input quantity or licensing is fixed by regulatory limits, supply becomes completely inelastic above that threshold. In New York, taxicab medallions were capped at 13,15013,150. While price decreases below \text{\\$15} reduce quantity supplied as drivers leave the market, price increases above \text{\\$15} cannot induce additional supply, causing the long-run supply curve S′S' to become vertical at 13,15013,150 taxicabs.


Supply curve for New York taxicabs
  • Producer Surplus: Sum over all units produced by a firm of differences between the market price of a good and the marginal cost of production.

  • Accounting Profit: Total revenue RR minus labor costs wLwL.

  • Economic Profit: Total revenue RR minus labor costs wLwL and capital costs rKrK.

  • Zero Economic Profit: State in which a firm earns a normal return on its investment, performing as well as it could by investing capital elsewhere.

  • Economic Rent: The amount firms are willing to pay for an input minus the minimum amount necessary to obtain it.

  • Long-Run Competitive Equilibrium: Market condition where all firms maximize profit, no firm has an incentive to enter or exit because all firms earn zero economic profit, and quantity supplied equals quantity demanded.

  • Constant-Cost Industry: Industry whose long-run supply curve is horizontal because input prices remain constant as industry output expands.

  • Increasing-Cost Industry: Industry whose long-run supply curve is upward sloping because output expansion bids up input prices.

  • Decreasing-Cost Industry: Industry whose long-run supply curve is downward sloping because output expansion reduces input costs.

  • Long-Run Elasticity of Supply: Percentage change in quantity supplied (ΔQQ\frac{\Delta Q}{Q}) divided by the percentage change in price (ΔPP\frac{\Delta P}{P}).