Comprehensive Study Guide to Normative Ethics
Core Ethical Frameworks and Thinkers
Virtue Ethics:
- Primary proponent: Aristotle is a virtue ethicist.
- Critic: Harman is a critic of virtue ethics.
Utilitarianism:
- Primary proponents: Bentham and Mill are utilitarians.
- Critics: Railton and Rawls are critics of utilitarianism.
Deontology:
- Primary proponent: Kant is a deontologist.
Intuitionism / Pluralistic Deontology:
- Key figure: Ross focuses on foundational duties.
Fundamental Ethical Concepts and Definitions
Utilitarian Decision-Making:
- Utilitarians calculate to decide what is right.
Deontological Decision-Making:
- Deontologists follow the categorical imperative.
Duty and Obligation:
- Obligation is a synonym for duty.
Aristotelian Virtue:
- Virtue is defined as hitting the mean between excess and deficiency.
Bentham's Pure Pleasure:
- A pure pleasure is one that does not lead to pain.
Mill's Division of Pleasures:
- Higher Pleasures: Pleasures that are distinctly human.
- Lower Pleasures: Pleasures that are shared with animals.
Kantian Classification of Duties:
- The duty to not commit suicide is categorized as a perfect duty to oneself.
Theoretical Comparisons Between Ethicists
Kant vs. Ross:
- The central difference is that Kant thinks obligations do not conflict, whereas Ross thinks obligations can conflict.
Kant vs. Mill:
- The primary divergence concerns moral evaluation criteria: Kant cares more about intentions, whereas Mill cares more about consequences.
Criticisms of Major Ethical Traditions
Criticisms of Aristotle (Virtue Ethics):
- It is not action-guiding.
- It relies on moral luck.
- It is self-centered.
- It is disproved by social psychology experiments.
Criticisms of Kant (Deontology):
- Duties can conflict with each other.
- Excludes disabled people from the moral community of persons.
- There are no exceptions to the rules.
Criticisms of Utilitarianism:
- Does not respect the separateness of persons.
- Alienates people from important relationships.
Ross's Five Foundational Duties
- 1. Fidelity: The obligation to remain faithful, keep promises, and tell the truth.
- 2. Reparation: The obligation to make amends or compensate for past wrongful acts.
- 3. Gratitude: The obligation to return favors, appreciate benefactors, and show thanks for services rendered.
- 4. Beneficence: The obligation to improve the condition of others and increase general goodness or happiness.
- 5. Non-maleficence: The obligation to avoid inflicting injury or harm on others.
Aristotle's Twelve Virtues of Character
- 1. Courage
- 2. Liberality
- 3. Proper ambition
- 4. Patience
- 5. Wittiness
- 6. Modesty
- 7. Temperance
- 8. Magnificence
- 9. Magnanimity
- Truthfulness
- Friendliness
- Righteous indignation
Quick Association and Terminological Guidance
Quick Association Framework:
- Aristotle: Associated with virtue and character.
- Kant: Associated with duty and rules.
- Bentham and Mill: Associated with consequences and happiness.
- Ross: Associated with foundational duties.
Terminological Precedence Note:
- If an individual instructor or course syllabus employs alternative or slightly different phrasing for these terms and principles, prioritize the specific wording provided in class.