Water Microbiology: Testing Recreational Water Safety and Coliform Enumeration

Page 1: Water Microbiology Overview

  • Recreational water assessment determines microbial safety for human contact by screening for indicator organisms rather than individual pathogens.

Page 2: Recreational Water Safety and Fecal Pathogens

  • Water testing focuses on detecting fecal coliforms originating from human waste, which indicate the potential presence of serious enteric pathogens.

  • Key intestinal pathogens of concern in contaminated recreational water:

    • Clostridioides difficile ("C. diff")

    • Salmonella typhi (typhoid fever)

    • Vibrio cholerae (cholera)

    • Shigella flexneri (dysentery)

    • Pathogenic protozoans, helminths, and viruses

Latrine seepage contaminating drinking water well

Page 3: Coliform Bacteria as Indicator Organisms

  • Testing for individual pathogens is cost-prohibitive and time-consuming; water quality monitoring instead detects sewage indicator organisms.

  • Coliform definition: A Gram-negative, non-spore-forming rod that ferments lactose into acids and gas.

Relationship among total coliforms, fecal coliforms, and E. coli

Page 4: Sewage Indicator Species

  • Escherichia coli:

    • Predominantly found in human and human-associated animal waste.

    • Normally absent in uncontaminated water and soil.

    • Survives slightly longer than enteric non-spore-forming pathogens without extensive persistence in aquatic environments.

  • Enterococcus faecalis: Non-coliform Gram-positive fecal indicator organism sharing similar survival kinetics.

Page 5: Enumeration Standards and Monitoring

  • Regulatory threshold: 126 E. coli/100 ml126\,\text{E. coli}/100\,\text{ml} of water is associated with an illness rate of 8/10008/1000 swimmers.

  • Water monitoring is frequently carried out by citizen-based volunteer networks requiring accessible, cost-effective methods.

  • Primary testing protocols compared: the Compact Dry method and the Most Probable Number (MPN) method.

Page 6: Study Location: Moonlight Beach and Cottonwood Creek

  • Moonlight Beach in Encinitas, CA historically receives poor water quality ratings due to urban runoff channeled via Cottonwood Creek directly into the surf zone.

Page 7: Ultraviolet Disinfection Treatment

  • An ultraviolet (UV) disinfection facility was commissioned in 20032003 to treat Cottonwood Creek runoff prior to ocean discharge, resulting in reduced beach closures.

Page 8: Experimental Sampling Sites

  • Sampling locations:

    • Upstream / Pre-UV: Influent line entering the UV treatment facility.

    • Downstream / Post-UV: Discharge line exiting the UV treatment facility.

    • Swash Water I, II, and III: Ocean mixing gradient zones, where Swash I is closest to the creek outlet and Swash III is furthest.

    • Control I and Control II: Reference baseline samples.

Aerial view of Cottonwood Creek outlet at Moonlight Beach

Page 9: Compact Dry Method Overview

  • The Compact Dry plate is a self-contained, pre-formulated chromogenic culture system for field enumeration of coliforms and E. coli.

Page 10: Compact Dry Chromogenic Substrates

  • Employs specific enzyme-substrate reactions to produce colored products:

    • β-galactosidase\beta\text{-galactosidase} reacts with Substrate 1 to yield a red product.

    • β-glucuronidase\beta\text{-glucuronidase} reacts with Substrate 2 to yield a blue product.

Page 11: Compact Dry Colony Identification

  • Coliform colonies appear red (β-galactosidase\beta\text{-galactosidase} positive).

  • Escherichia coli colonies appear blue (β-glucuronidase\beta\text{-glucuronidase} positive).

  • Non-coliform organisms display non-target colors (e.g., colorless or yellow).

Compact Dry plate displaying red coliform colonies and blue E. coli colonies

Page 12: Advantages and Limitations of Compact Dry

  • Pros:

    • Easy to operate with no media preparation.

    • High portability and extended shelf life.

    • Well-suited for volunteer monitoring programs.

  • Cons:

    • Can be expensive per test.

    • Colony counting becomes difficult at high bacterial concentrations.

    • Cannot distinguish pathogenic E. coli O157:H7, as this strain does not produce β-glucuronidase\beta\text{-glucuronidase}.

Page 13: Compact Dry Inoculation Protocol

  • Pipette 1 ml1\,\text{ml} of water sample directly into the center of the dry tray well; sample diffuses automatically across the matrix pad.

  • Avoid touching the pipette tip to the matrix pad.

  • Replace lid, invert plate, and incubate upside down at 37∘C37^\circ\text{C}.

Page 14: Compact Dry Enumeration Technique

  • Total E. coli count = number of blue colonies.

  • Total coliform count = sum of all blue and red colonies.

  • High-density plates: Count colonies within a representative 1 cm×1 cm1\,\text{cm} \times 1\,\text{cm} grid square and multiply by 2020 (the total growth surface area).

Page 15: Compact Dry Quantitative Results

  • Calculation: Multiply plate count (1 ml1\,\text{ml} plated) by 100100 to report colonies per 100 ml100\,\text{ml}.

  • Experimental plate findings:

    • Pre-UV Water: E. coli = 3.0×103/100 ml3.0 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml}; Coliforms = 6.8×104/100 ml6.8 \times 10^4/100\,\text{ml}; Total Coliforms = 7.1×104/100 ml7.1 \times 10^4/100\,\text{ml}.

    • Post-UV Water: E. coli = 3.5×103/100 ml3.5 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml}; Coliforms = 6.8×104/100 ml6.8 \times 10^4/100\,\text{ml}; Total Coliforms = 7.15×104/100 ml7.15 \times 10^4/100\,\text{ml}.

    • Swash Water I: E. coli = 1.7×103/100 ml1.7 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml}; Coliforms = 6.0×104/100 ml6.0 \times 10^4/100\,\text{ml}; Total Coliforms = 6.17×104/100 ml6.17 \times 10^4/100\,\text{ml}.

    • Swash Water II: E. coli = 3.8×103/100 ml3.8 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml} (count = 3838); Coliforms = 4.2×103/100 ml4.2 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml} (count = 4242); Total Coliforms = 8.0×103/100 ml8.0 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml} (count = 8080).

    • Swash Water III: E. coli = 1.2×103/100 ml1.2 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml}; Coliforms = 7.9×103/100 ml7.9 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml}; Total Coliforms = 9.1×103/100 ml9.1 \times 10^3/100\,\text{ml}.

Page 16: Most Probable Number (MPN) Method: The Presumptive Test

  • The Presumptive Test constitutes the opening screening stage of the MPN statistical enumeration method.

Page 17: Three Stages of the MPN Method

  • Part 1: Presumptive Test: Inoculation of a lactose fermentation tube series to establish a statistical Most Probable Number (MPN) Index.

  • Part 2: Confirmed Test: Subculturing positive broths onto selective/differential EMB and MacConkey agars.

  • Part 3: Completed Test: Re-affirming lactose fermentation, confirming Gram-negative rod morphology, and culturing on agar slants for subsequent IMViC testing.

Page 18: Screening Strategy in MPN Testing

  • The presumptive and confirmed stages serve as rapid, cost-effective screening gates.

  • Testing advances to the next step only if positive; a negative presumptive or confirmed test classifies the water as safe.

Page 19: Advantages and Limitations of MPN

  • Pros:

    • Facilitates uniform recovery of microbial populations.

    • Yields a realistic representation of viable organisms.

    • Supports recovery of bacteria unculturable on solid agar.

  • Cons:

    • Labor- and material-intensive.

    • Requires a minimum of 3 days3\,\text{days} incubation.

    • MPN statistical estimates provide lower precision than direct plating counts.

Page 20: Presumptive Test Fundamentals

  • Employs a multi-tube dilution series to detect lactose fermentation coupled with acid and gas production (+AG+\text{AG}).

Lactose fermentation into lactic acid

Page 21: Carbohydrate Fermentation Principles

  • Evaluates an organism's enzymatic profile by tracking its capacity to ferment specific sugars (e.g., glucose, lactose, mannitol) into organic acids and gas.

Page 22: Carbohydrate Fermentation Media Components

  • Key components of lactose broth:

    • Sugar substrate (lactose).

    • Phenol Red pH indicator:

    • Yellow: pH≈6\text{pH} \approx 6 (acidic)

    • Red/Orange: pH≈7\text{pH} \approx 7 (neutral)

    • Pink: pH≈8\text{pH} \approx 8 (basic / alkaline)

    • Inverted Durham tube to trap gas bubbles (CO2\text{CO}_2 / H2\text{H}_2).

Page 23: Presumptive Test Materials

  • Materials per group of four:

    • 11 water sample.

    • 66 tubes of single-strength lactose broth (SSLB) with Durham tubes.

    • 33 tubes of double-strength lactose broth (DSLB) with Durham tubes.

    • 10 ml10\,\text{ml} pipettes, p200, and p1000 micropipettes.

Page 24: Inoculation Scheme for Presumptive Test

  • Dilution setup (9 tubes9\,\text{tubes} total per sample):

    • 3 tubes3\,\text{tubes} of DSLB: Inoculate with 10 ml10\,\text{ml} of water sample each (double strength prevents media dilution).

    • 3 tubes3\,\text{tubes} of SSLB: Inoculate with 1.0 ml1.0\,\text{ml} of water sample each.

    • 3 tubes3\,\text{tubes} of SSLB: Inoculate with 0.1 ml0.1\,\text{ml} (100 μl100\,\mu\text{l}) of water sample each.

Page 25: Phenol Red Carbohydrate Broth Interpretations

  • Yellow (+A+\text{A} or +AG+\text{AG}): Positive sugar fermentation producing acid (with or without trapped gas).

  • **Orange/Red (-$*)**: Negative; no sugar fermentation.\n- **Pink (-\text{ alk})**: Negative; protein catabolism yields alkaline byproducts.\n\n![Phenol red carbohydrate fermentation tube with Durham tube showing acid and gas](https://assets.knowt.com/pdf-flow-prod/bdc7d2dd-aa91-471e-981a-3040fe4c6935-figures/24.jpg)\n\n# Page 26: Carbohydrate Fermentation Result Summary\n\n- Diagnostic tube profiles:\n - Yellow (no bubble): +\text{A} (acid only).\n - Yellow (bubble in Durham tube): +\text{AG} (acid and gas; presumptive positive for coliforms).\n - Red/Orange: -$ (no reaction).

    • Pink: -$ (alkaline reaction).\n\n# Page 27: Presumptive Test Evaluation Criteria\n\n- **Positive test**: Gas accumulation (+\text{AG})inatleast) in at least1oftheof the9\,\text{tubes}; record the 3-digit MPN code and proceed to the Confirmed Test.\n- **Negative test**: No gas formation across all 9\,\text{tubes}((-$ or +A+\text{A}); water is determined safe.

Page 28: Presumptive Test Experimental Findings

  • Experimental tube reading and MPN index values:

    • Pre-UV Water: MPN Code = 3-3-3; MPN Index = TNTC (too numerous to count).

    • Post-UV Water: MPN Code = 3-3-3; MPN Index = TNTC.

    • Swash Water I: MPN Code = 3-3-3; MPN Index = TNTC.

    • Swash Water II: MPN Code = 3-3-3; MPN Index = TNTC.

    • Swash Water III: MPN Code = 3-3-2; MPN Index = 1,100 organisms/100 ml1,100\,\text{organisms}/100\,\text{ml}.

Page 29: Most Probable Number (MPN) Statistical Table

  • Statistical index translates the number of positive tubes in the 10 ml10\,\text{ml}, 1.0 ml1.0\,\text{ml}, and 0.1 ml0.1\,\text{ml} sets into estimated coliform counts per 100 ml100\,\text{ml} alongside 95%95\% confidence limits.

  • For code 3-3-2: MPN Index = 1,1001,100; 95%95\% Confidence Limits = 150150 (lower) to 4,8004,800 (upper).

MPN index per 100 mL statistical determination table

Page 30: Confirmed Test Overview

  • The Confirmed Test uses selective and differential solid media to confirm that gas-producing isolates are Gram-negative coliforms.

Page 31: Purpose and Selective Media of Confirmed Test

  • Verifies lactose fermentation and Gram-negative status.

  • Employs Eosin Methylene Blue (EMB) agar and MacConkey (MAC) agar, both of which inhibit Gram-positive bacteria and differentiate lactose fermenters.

Page 32: Eosin Methylene Blue (EMB) Agar Chemistry

  • Selective components: Eosin and methylene blue dyes inhibit Gram-positive bacterial growth.

  • Differential components: Lactose separates coliforms from non-coliforms.

  • Reaction profiles:

    • Rapid/vigorous lactose fermentation (highly acidic): Produces a green metallic sheen (indicative of E. coli).

    • Moderate/slow lactose fermentation (acidic): Produces dark purple colonies.

    • Non-fermenters (protein breakdown / basic): Form pink or translucent colonies.

Page 33: EMB Agar Differentiation

  • Characteristic growth patterns on EMB:

    • Rapid fermenter (presumptive E. coli): Dark colonies with green metallic sheen.

    • Slow/weak fermenter: Dark purple/pink mucoid colonies.

    • Non-fermenter (non-coliform): Colorless or pale colonies.

EMB agar plate demonstrating lactose fermentation variations including metallic green sheen

Page 34: MacConkey (MAC) Agar Chemistry

  • Selective components: Crystal violet and bile salts suppress Gram-positive growth.

  • Differential components: Lactose substrate with Neutral Red pH indicator.

  • Reaction profiles:

    • Lactose fermenters (acidic): Form pink or red colonies.

    • Non-fermenters (alkaline): Form colorless colonies; agar remains orange or yellow.

Page 35: MacConkey Agar Differentiation

  • Distinguishes Gram-negative enteric bacilli:

    • Coliform lactose fermenters: Bright pink/red colonies.

    • Non-coliform non-fermenters: Colorless colonies.

MacConkey agar plate showing pink lactose-fermenting coliforms and colorless non-fermenters

Page 36: Confirmed Test Inoculation Protocol

  • Streak a loopful of broth from a positive (+AG+\text{AG}) presumptive tube onto an EMB plate using isolation streaking.

  • Repeat inoculation onto a MAC plate.

  • Invert and incubate all plates at 37∘C37^\circ\text{C}.

Page 37: Confirmed Test Result Interpretations

  • EMB Agar:

    • Positive result: Dark purple colonies or colonies displaying a green metallic sheen.

    • Negative result: Pale, colorless colonies or weak growth.

  • MacConkey Agar:

    • Positive result: Pink or red colonies.

    • Negative result: Colorless colonies or no growth.

Page 38: Confirmed Test Experimental Findings

  • Swash Water III confirmed observations:

    • EMB: Dark purple colonies with metallic green sheen (Gram-negative lactose fermenter, presumptive E. coli).

    • MAC: Pink colonies (Gram-negative coliform).

Page 39: Completed Test Overview

  • The Completed Test definitively verifies pure culture coliform identity and differentiates fecal E. coli from non-fecal environmental species.

Page 40: Objectives of the Completed Test

  • Re-confirm acid and gas production from lactose fermentation.

  • Confirm Gram-negative, non-spore-forming rod morphology via staining.

  • Screen against non-sewage coliforms; conducted exclusively following positive presumptive and confirmed tests.

Page 41: Completed Test Colony Selection and Subculture

  • Pick a well-isolated coliform colony showing characteristic morphology from the EMB plate.

  • Inoculate into an SSLB Durham tube to re-verify gas production (+AG+\text{AG}).

  • Inoculate a nutrient agar/TSA slant to evaluate purity, morphology, and Gram reaction.

Page 42: IMViC Differentiation of Indicator Organisms

  • Distinguishes Escherichia coli from environmental coliforms such as Enterobacter aerogenes (which can produce positive results in presumptive and completed tests without indicating sewage):

    • Escherichia coli IMViC profile: + + - - (Indole +, Methyl Red +, Voges-Proskauer -, Citrate -).

    • Enterobacter aerogenes IMViC profile: - - + + (Indole -, Methyl Red -, Voges-Proskauer +, Citrate +).

IMViC test series results for Escherichia coli

Page 43: Completed Test Protocol and Incubation

  • Inoculate one TSA slant and one Durham tube of SSLB lactose broth per isolated colony.

  • Incubate both media at 37∘C37^\circ\text{C}.

Page 44: Final Identification Criteria

  • Observe SSLB broth for acid and gas (+AG+\text{AG}).

  • Prepare a Gram stain from the slant culture.

  • A confirmed coliform isolate is defined by:

    1. Gas formation (+AG+\text{AG}) in lactose broth.

    2. Gram-negative, non-spore-forming bacillus morphology.

  • Slants are refrigerated for subsequent IMViC testing.

Page 45: Completed Test Experimental Findings

  • Final diagnostic summary across test waters:

    • Lactose Broth: Produces acid and gas (+AG+\text{AG}).

    • TSA Slants: Abundant bacterial growth.

    • Gram Stain: Pink/red bacilli, non-spore-forming rods, confirming Gram-negative coliform status.