Water Microbiology: Testing Recreational Water Safety and Coliform Enumeration
Page 1: Water Microbiology Overview
Recreational water assessment determines microbial safety for human contact by screening for indicator organisms rather than individual pathogens.
Page 2: Recreational Water Safety and Fecal Pathogens
Water testing focuses on detecting fecal coliforms originating from human waste, which indicate the potential presence of serious enteric pathogens.
Key intestinal pathogens of concern in contaminated recreational water:
Clostridioides difficile ("C. diff")
Salmonella typhi (typhoid fever)
Vibrio cholerae (cholera)
Shigella flexneri (dysentery)
Pathogenic protozoans, helminths, and viruses

Page 3: Coliform Bacteria as Indicator Organisms
Testing for individual pathogens is cost-prohibitive and time-consuming; water quality monitoring instead detects sewage indicator organisms.
Coliform definition: A Gram-negative, non-spore-forming rod that ferments lactose into acids and gas.

Page 4: Sewage Indicator Species
Escherichia coli:
Predominantly found in human and human-associated animal waste.
Normally absent in uncontaminated water and soil.
Survives slightly longer than enteric non-spore-forming pathogens without extensive persistence in aquatic environments.
Enterococcus faecalis: Non-coliform Gram-positive fecal indicator organism sharing similar survival kinetics.
Page 5: Enumeration Standards and Monitoring
Regulatory threshold: of water is associated with an illness rate of swimmers.
Water monitoring is frequently carried out by citizen-based volunteer networks requiring accessible, cost-effective methods.
Primary testing protocols compared: the Compact Dry method and the Most Probable Number (MPN) method.
Page 6: Study Location: Moonlight Beach and Cottonwood Creek
Moonlight Beach in Encinitas, CA historically receives poor water quality ratings due to urban runoff channeled via Cottonwood Creek directly into the surf zone.
Page 7: Ultraviolet Disinfection Treatment
An ultraviolet (UV) disinfection facility was commissioned in to treat Cottonwood Creek runoff prior to ocean discharge, resulting in reduced beach closures.
Page 8: Experimental Sampling Sites
Sampling locations:
Upstream / Pre-UV: Influent line entering the UV treatment facility.
Downstream / Post-UV: Discharge line exiting the UV treatment facility.
Swash Water I, II, and III: Ocean mixing gradient zones, where Swash I is closest to the creek outlet and Swash III is furthest.
Control I and Control II: Reference baseline samples.

Page 9: Compact Dry Method Overview
The Compact Dry plate is a self-contained, pre-formulated chromogenic culture system for field enumeration of coliforms and E. coli.
Page 10: Compact Dry Chromogenic Substrates
Employs specific enzyme-substrate reactions to produce colored products:
reacts with Substrate 1 to yield a red product.
reacts with Substrate 2 to yield a blue product.
Page 11: Compact Dry Colony Identification
Coliform colonies appear red ( positive).
Escherichia coli colonies appear blue ( positive).
Non-coliform organisms display non-target colors (e.g., colorless or yellow).

Page 12: Advantages and Limitations of Compact Dry
Pros:
Easy to operate with no media preparation.
High portability and extended shelf life.
Well-suited for volunteer monitoring programs.
Cons:
Can be expensive per test.
Colony counting becomes difficult at high bacterial concentrations.
Cannot distinguish pathogenic E. coli O157:H7, as this strain does not produce .
Page 13: Compact Dry Inoculation Protocol
Pipette of water sample directly into the center of the dry tray well; sample diffuses automatically across the matrix pad.
Avoid touching the pipette tip to the matrix pad.
Replace lid, invert plate, and incubate upside down at .
Page 14: Compact Dry Enumeration Technique
Total E. coli count = number of blue colonies.
Total coliform count = sum of all blue and red colonies.
High-density plates: Count colonies within a representative grid square and multiply by (the total growth surface area).
Page 15: Compact Dry Quantitative Results
Calculation: Multiply plate count ( plated) by to report colonies per .
Experimental plate findings:
Pre-UV Water: E. coli = ; Coliforms = ; Total Coliforms = .
Post-UV Water: E. coli = ; Coliforms = ; Total Coliforms = .
Swash Water I: E. coli = ; Coliforms = ; Total Coliforms = .
Swash Water II: E. coli = (count = ); Coliforms = (count = ); Total Coliforms = (count = ).
Swash Water III: E. coli = ; Coliforms = ; Total Coliforms = .
Page 16: Most Probable Number (MPN) Method: The Presumptive Test
The Presumptive Test constitutes the opening screening stage of the MPN statistical enumeration method.
Page 17: Three Stages of the MPN Method
Part 1: Presumptive Test: Inoculation of a lactose fermentation tube series to establish a statistical Most Probable Number (MPN) Index.
Part 2: Confirmed Test: Subculturing positive broths onto selective/differential EMB and MacConkey agars.
Part 3: Completed Test: Re-affirming lactose fermentation, confirming Gram-negative rod morphology, and culturing on agar slants for subsequent IMViC testing.
Page 18: Screening Strategy in MPN Testing
The presumptive and confirmed stages serve as rapid, cost-effective screening gates.
Testing advances to the next step only if positive; a negative presumptive or confirmed test classifies the water as safe.
Page 19: Advantages and Limitations of MPN
Pros:
Facilitates uniform recovery of microbial populations.
Yields a realistic representation of viable organisms.
Supports recovery of bacteria unculturable on solid agar.
Cons:
Labor- and material-intensive.
Requires a minimum of incubation.
MPN statistical estimates provide lower precision than direct plating counts.
Page 20: Presumptive Test Fundamentals
Employs a multi-tube dilution series to detect lactose fermentation coupled with acid and gas production ().

Page 21: Carbohydrate Fermentation Principles
Evaluates an organism's enzymatic profile by tracking its capacity to ferment specific sugars (e.g., glucose, lactose, mannitol) into organic acids and gas.
Page 22: Carbohydrate Fermentation Media Components
Key components of lactose broth:
Sugar substrate (lactose).
Phenol Red pH indicator:
Yellow: (acidic)
Red/Orange: (neutral)
Pink: (basic / alkaline)
Inverted Durham tube to trap gas bubbles ( / ).
Page 23: Presumptive Test Materials
Materials per group of four:
water sample.
tubes of single-strength lactose broth (SSLB) with Durham tubes.
tubes of double-strength lactose broth (DSLB) with Durham tubes.
pipettes, p200, and p1000 micropipettes.
Page 24: Inoculation Scheme for Presumptive Test
Dilution setup ( total per sample):
of DSLB: Inoculate with of water sample each (double strength prevents media dilution).
of SSLB: Inoculate with of water sample each.
of SSLB: Inoculate with () of water sample each.
Page 25: Phenol Red Carbohydrate Broth Interpretations
Yellow ( or ): Positive sugar fermentation producing acid (with or without trapped gas).
**Orange/Red (-$*)**: Negative; no sugar fermentation.\n- **Pink (-\text{ alk})**: Negative; protein catabolism yields alkaline byproducts.\n\n\n\n# Page 26: Carbohydrate Fermentation Result Summary\n\n- Diagnostic tube profiles:\n - Yellow (no bubble): +\text{A} (acid only).\n - Yellow (bubble in Durham tube): +\text{AG} (acid and gas; presumptive positive for coliforms).\n - Red/Orange: -$ (no reaction).
Pink: -$ (alkaline reaction).\n\n# Page 27: Presumptive Test Evaluation Criteria\n\n- **Positive test**: Gas accumulation (+\text{AG}19\,\text{tubes}; record the 3-digit MPN code and proceed to the Confirmed Test.\n- **Negative test**: No gas formation across all 9\,\text{tubes}-$ or ); water is determined safe.
Page 28: Presumptive Test Experimental Findings
Experimental tube reading and MPN index values:
Pre-UV Water: MPN Code =
3-3-3; MPN Index =TNTC(too numerous to count).Post-UV Water: MPN Code =
3-3-3; MPN Index =TNTC.Swash Water I: MPN Code =
3-3-3; MPN Index =TNTC.Swash Water II: MPN Code =
3-3-3; MPN Index =TNTC.Swash Water III: MPN Code =
3-3-2; MPN Index = .
Page 29: Most Probable Number (MPN) Statistical Table
Statistical index translates the number of positive tubes in the , , and sets into estimated coliform counts per alongside confidence limits.
For code
3-3-2: MPN Index = ; Confidence Limits = (lower) to (upper).

Page 30: Confirmed Test Overview
The Confirmed Test uses selective and differential solid media to confirm that gas-producing isolates are Gram-negative coliforms.
Page 31: Purpose and Selective Media of Confirmed Test
Verifies lactose fermentation and Gram-negative status.
Employs Eosin Methylene Blue (EMB) agar and MacConkey (MAC) agar, both of which inhibit Gram-positive bacteria and differentiate lactose fermenters.
Page 32: Eosin Methylene Blue (EMB) Agar Chemistry
Selective components: Eosin and methylene blue dyes inhibit Gram-positive bacterial growth.
Differential components: Lactose separates coliforms from non-coliforms.
Reaction profiles:
Rapid/vigorous lactose fermentation (highly acidic): Produces a green metallic sheen (indicative of E. coli).
Moderate/slow lactose fermentation (acidic): Produces dark purple colonies.
Non-fermenters (protein breakdown / basic): Form pink or translucent colonies.
Page 33: EMB Agar Differentiation
Characteristic growth patterns on EMB:
Rapid fermenter (presumptive E. coli): Dark colonies with green metallic sheen.
Slow/weak fermenter: Dark purple/pink mucoid colonies.
Non-fermenter (non-coliform): Colorless or pale colonies.

Page 34: MacConkey (MAC) Agar Chemistry
Selective components: Crystal violet and bile salts suppress Gram-positive growth.
Differential components: Lactose substrate with Neutral Red pH indicator.
Reaction profiles:
Lactose fermenters (acidic): Form pink or red colonies.
Non-fermenters (alkaline): Form colorless colonies; agar remains orange or yellow.
Page 35: MacConkey Agar Differentiation
Distinguishes Gram-negative enteric bacilli:
Coliform lactose fermenters: Bright pink/red colonies.
Non-coliform non-fermenters: Colorless colonies.

Page 36: Confirmed Test Inoculation Protocol
Streak a loopful of broth from a positive () presumptive tube onto an EMB plate using isolation streaking.
Repeat inoculation onto a MAC plate.
Invert and incubate all plates at .
Page 37: Confirmed Test Result Interpretations
EMB Agar:
Positive result: Dark purple colonies or colonies displaying a green metallic sheen.
Negative result: Pale, colorless colonies or weak growth.
MacConkey Agar:
Positive result: Pink or red colonies.
Negative result: Colorless colonies or no growth.
Page 38: Confirmed Test Experimental Findings
Swash Water III confirmed observations:
EMB: Dark purple colonies with metallic green sheen (Gram-negative lactose fermenter, presumptive E. coli).
MAC: Pink colonies (Gram-negative coliform).
Page 39: Completed Test Overview
The Completed Test definitively verifies pure culture coliform identity and differentiates fecal E. coli from non-fecal environmental species.
Page 40: Objectives of the Completed Test
Re-confirm acid and gas production from lactose fermentation.
Confirm Gram-negative, non-spore-forming rod morphology via staining.
Screen against non-sewage coliforms; conducted exclusively following positive presumptive and confirmed tests.
Page 41: Completed Test Colony Selection and Subculture
Pick a well-isolated coliform colony showing characteristic morphology from the EMB plate.
Inoculate into an SSLB Durham tube to re-verify gas production ().
Inoculate a nutrient agar/TSA slant to evaluate purity, morphology, and Gram reaction.
Page 42: IMViC Differentiation of Indicator Organisms
Distinguishes Escherichia coli from environmental coliforms such as Enterobacter aerogenes (which can produce positive results in presumptive and completed tests without indicating sewage):
Escherichia coli IMViC profile:
+ + - -(Indole +, Methyl Red +, Voges-Proskauer -, Citrate -).Enterobacter aerogenes IMViC profile:
- - + +(Indole -, Methyl Red -, Voges-Proskauer +, Citrate +).

Page 43: Completed Test Protocol and Incubation
Inoculate one TSA slant and one Durham tube of SSLB lactose broth per isolated colony.
Incubate both media at .
Page 44: Final Identification Criteria
Observe SSLB broth for acid and gas ().
Prepare a Gram stain from the slant culture.
A confirmed coliform isolate is defined by:
Gas formation () in lactose broth.
Gram-negative, non-spore-forming bacillus morphology.
Slants are refrigerated for subsequent IMViC testing.
Page 45: Completed Test Experimental Findings
Final diagnostic summary across test waters:
Lactose Broth: Produces acid and gas ().
TSA Slants: Abundant bacterial growth.
Gram Stain: Pink/red bacilli, non-spore-forming rods, confirming Gram-negative coliform status.