Moonlight as Queer Cinema

Introduction to Moonlight

James Baldwin writes, 'The sexual question and the racial question have always been entwined' (Baldwin 2014: 64). One of the most significant ways in which the film Moonlight counters dominant representations of Black masculinity is through its presentation of a Black gay man. Moonlight has achieved significant commercial and mainstream success within an industry that has traditionally prioritized white, middle-class LGBT narratives when telling queer love stories. Critics have lauded the film for its pioneering depiction of queer sexualities in minority communities and for its sensitive portrayal of the difficulties associated with gay adolescence (Als 2016; Copeland 2017; Bastién 2017). Furthermore, the film's focus on the intersectionality of Chiron’s identity contributes to a deeper understanding of the histories of audio-visual representation of Black queer people.

In this chapter, the discussion centers on the film's position within LGBTQ-themed films of the 2000s and 2010s, followed by a brief history of Black queer films, filmmakers, and critical debates. The chapter will then question whether Moonlight is more accurately categorized as queer cinema or LGBT cinema by exploring debates surrounding gender, intimacy, the film’s elision of explicit sexual content, and its ending.

Moonlight's Significance in LGBT Cinema

Moonlight’s Oscar win for Best Picture was hailed as a groundbreaking achievement for the LGBT community. GLAAD President and CEO Sarah Kate Ellis tweeted that the win 'sends a strong message to the film industry that it needs to embrace inclusive stories if it wants to remain competitive and relevant' (quote in Townsend 2017). While films such as Ang Lee’s Brokeback Mountain (2005), Todd Haynes’s Carol (2015), and Kimberly Peirce’s Boys Don’t Cry (1999) had previously been nominated for and won Oscars, Moonlight was the first film to win the Best Picture award. Following the film's win, its publicity posters proclaimed, 'it changes everything'.

Critic Guy Lodge notes that although the film is not radical, it remains a 'pathbreaker' in the history of LGBT cinema (2017a). This juxtaposition between mainstream and innovative nature of Moonlight speaks to broader debates about universality and specificity within queer and LGBT cinema as a whole. Various definitions of queer cinema have been proposed by critics and filmmakers alike. Benshoff and Griffin offer a comprehensive definition that includes films made by queer filmmakers, featuring queer actors, themes, and characters, as well as the cultural reception of these works. They contend that queer film study must understand sexualities on screen as complex, multiple, overlapping, and historically nuanced.

Conversely, director Todd Haynes defines queerness in film as reflecting more about form and structure than content. While many perceive a 'gay' film based on its characters, he asserts that 'heterosexuality to me is a structure as much as it is a content' (Wyatt 1993: 8). This aligns with formal innovations of the New Queer Cinema movement of the 1980s and 1990s, characterized by fragmented subjectivities and dystopian themes that served as artistic responses to the depredations of the AIDS crisis (Arroyo 1993: 90). The New Queer Cinema was largely an arthouse movement centered on film festivals and auteur aesthetics (Rich 2004: 16).

Mainstream Hollywood’s Response

In response to shifting social attitudes regarding homosexuality and queer identities, mainstream Hollywood started portraying more inclusive narratives in the 1990s and particularly during the 2000s. A key film of this era is Lee’s Brokeback Mountain, an emotionally expansive tale of love in the closet among cowboys in Wyoming during the 1960s and 1970s. The film features Heath Ledger and Jake Gyllenhaal in the lead roles and received nine Academy Award nominations, ultimately winning five. Critics initially recognized the film’s significant gay plot but later perceived it more as a 'universal' story, with reactions suggesting that 'the fact that the love story involves two men is secondary because the movie’s underlying theme is so universal' (quoted in Cooper and Pease 2008: 257). Gary Needham described Brokeback Mountain as both indie and queer, popular yet specific, where labeling it queer signifies a disruptive force against conventional assumptions surrounding normality (2010: 2).

Conversely, critic D.A. Miller criticized the film's appeal to universality, deriding its meticulous craftsmanship where 'the Homosexual is not his sexuality, but his agonized attempt to fight it, suggesting a devotion to normality' (2007: 50). The film sharply illuminated issues of universality versus particularity, a tension that would persist into the 2010s.

The Mainstreaming of LGBT Cinema

Moonlight exemplifies a broader mainstreaming of LGBT cinema, joining films such as Lisa Cholodenko's The Kids Are All Right (2010), Abdellatif Kechiche’s Blue Is the Warmest Color (2013), Park Chan-wook’s The Handmaiden (2016), and Luca Guadagnino’s Call Me By Your Name (2017). These films blur the lines between arthouse and mainstream filmmaking, as evidenced by shared production companies, audience demographics, and critical reception, alongside the auteur status of their directors.

Films such as The Kids Are All Right and Call Me By Your Name sparked discussions surrounding the tension between universality and queer specificity. Critics celebrated The Kids Are All Right, not due to its representation of a gay family but rather because of the family’s 'normal' portrayal (see Walters 2012: 924). By 2017, with the release of Call Me By Your Name, debates concerning universality in queer film had entered the mainstream narrative. Critiques pointed out the film’s neglect of the AIDS crisis in favor of a nostalgic beauty appealing to mainstream audiences. Director Guadagnino, himself gay, expressed the desire to create a 'powerful universality', achieved through exquisite landscapes and high-art references while excluding explicit sex scenes (quoted in Lee 2017a).

Critics of Call Me By Your Name drew parallels between it and Moonlight, suggesting that the dignified aesthetics of both films diminished their erotic potential (Gray 2017). Additionally, E. Alex Jung categorizes the recent series of commercially successful Hollywood films that feature LGBT themes as distinctly LGBT cinema rather than queer cinema. Jung delineates Call Me By Your Name, The Kids Are All Right, and similar films as epitomes of a 'catholic spirit' that focus on similarities rather than differences, describing them as safe, often dull and sentimental films designed to relay a universal narrative (2018).

Debates Surrounding Queerness in Film

Underlying these discussions is the critical inquiry into what defines a queer film compared to one that merely resembles an LGBT-themed film. New Queer Cinema emerged as a dialogue between margin and center, indie versus Hollywood. It raises crucial questions: What occurs when films portraying LGBT themes and characters are conceived, produced, or honored by mainstream Hollywood? Michele Aaron astutely encapsulates this dilemma with the query, 'how can a marriage between the popular and the radical be sustained when such an association erodes the very meaning of each?' (2004: 8).

Definitions of Queer Cinema

Critic Alexander Doty offers a succinct definition of queer films as those that 'challenge or transgress established straight or gay and lesbian understandings of gender and sexuality' (1998: 149). Central to this definition is the term 'established understandings', indicating that both heterosexual and queer normative definitions of sexuality evolve over time. While New Queer Cinema garnered acclaim for its innovative and radical aesthetics, it predominantly showcased the visions of white, middle-class men. Director Pratibha Parmar cautions against generalizing a dominant queer aesthetic, asserting that her sensibility is shaped equally by her cultural and racial background as by her queerness (1993: 175).

This observation suggests that the persistent association of whiteness with LGBT film movements can be identified as a 'norm' continually challenged and transcended by female and minority filmmakers. Subsequent sections will navigate these debates, determining whether Moonlight is best labeled as a queer film or one that simply features LGBT themes. In particular, the impact of race on Chiron’s sexuality is examined, demonstrating that analyses rooted in both race and sexuality, alongside critiques from queer people of color, yield a multifaceted understanding of the character’s sexual identity and the film's overarching queerness.

Examining Race, Sex, and Sexuality in Moonlight

Sex and sexuality intricately relate to issues of racial and ethnic identity. These concepts connect to the body and its lived experience dictated by societal norms, particularly those of whiteness and heterosexuality. Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, mainstream Hollywood frequently centered on white, cisgendered, middle-class protagonists, effectively erasing racial and ethnic minorities from queer narratives. Scholars, including Judith Halberstam (2000) and Jennifer Devere Brody (2007), have noted how racial and ethnic minorities are not only marginalized in queer stories, but also actively erased by 'history's white lies', particularly in films like Boys Don’t Cry.

In contrast to The Kids Are All Right, featuring an upper-middle-class white LGBT family, Tammie M. Kennedy asserts that acceptance into the heteronormative society often hinges on the erasure of 'racial, ethnic, socioeconomic, and gender diversity' (2014: 119).

While much discourse on Black queer lives has emerged, Moonlight was not the inaugural film to challenge the 'lavender ceiling' (O’Hara 2017). As L.H. Stallings reminds, there have been numerous films depicting Black gay lives long before Moonlight, including Dee Rees's Pariah (2011) and Sean Baker’s Tangerine (2015), as well as television programs like Ryan Murphy’s Pose (2018) and Justin Simeon’s Dear White People (2017).

Antecedents in New Queer Cinema

It is vital to recognize Moonlight’s antecedents within the New Queer Cinema movement. Pioneering films from the late 1980s and 90s such as Marlon Riggs's Tongues Untied (1989), Isaac Julien’s Looking for Langston (1989), Jennie Livingston’s Paris is Burning (1990), and Cheryl Dunye’s The Watermelon Woman (1996) provided essential representations of the Black queer community. These films employed formal innovations characteristic of the New Queer Cinema movement, integrating narrative and documentary forms with personal reflections alongside fictional plots or abstract sequences. Notably, Paris is Burning has had lasting influence, even within a predominantly white directorial context.

The documentary chronicles the lives of Black and Hispanic queer individuals participating in New York’s ball scene during the 1980s and 90s, offering a distinctive insight into the drag scene, particularly the experiences of trans women. Daniel T. Contreras notes Paris is Burning as one of the few New Queer Cinema works that accurately engages with race within a highly queer context (2004: 120). However, bell hooks critiques the film for expressing a 'white ethnographic gaze', arguing that Livingston's portrayal of the ball scene distorts and detaches viewers from the authentic hardships and discrimination faced by the characters (2015: 149-51).

Marlon Riggs's Tongues Untied constitutes a sustained reflection on the experiences of Black gay men, expressing a call for recognition of the intertwining identities of Blackness and queerness. The film combines personal narratives, archival footage, and poetic voiceovers to illustrate how Riggs's sexuality marginalized him in the Black community whilst simultaneously alienating him from the gay community. Riggs's work challenges dualistic identity representations, positing that ‘black queerness, or queer blackness, cannot be divided to serve different communities at different times’ (Landenberg 2004: 129). In a resonant conclusion, Tongues Untied ends with a powerful call to brotherhood and love among Black gay men, stating, 'Black men loving black men is the revolutionary act'.

The Issue of Homophobia

It is crucial to understand that a specific form of homophobia cannot solely be attributed to the Black community. Such assignments reflect enduring tendencies of white society to Other marginalized groups through racist oppression (Jones 2019; Simmons 1991; Johnson 2003). Simultaneously, as Patricia Hill Collins outlines, 'race complicates the closeting process and resistance to it' (2005: 112). Collins articulates how discourses on white homosexual visibility, coupled with images of Black hyper-heterosexuality, obfuscate a comprehensive analysis of Black sexuality, essential for addressing the needs of both straight and gay Black individuals.

Riggs critiques certain prominent Black male entertainers, whom he describes as the 'Black Pack,' for contributing to a homophobic culture by ridiculing effeminate representations of Black men. He denounces figures like Eddie Murphy and characters such as Blaine Edwards and Antoine Merriweather as embodiments of the 'Negro Faggot', caricatures of weak and effeminate Black men invoked for comedic effect without regard for the lived realities of Black gay men. Riggs asserts this portrayal reflects a desperate societal need for an Other, a scapegoat onto which displaced fears and frustrations about racism can be imposed (1991: 390). The reinforcement of this Other illuminates the deep-seated racism entrenched in American societal constructs around African American identity.

E. Patrick Johnson further articulates the historical separation of homosexuality from Black identity, arguing that representations of effeminate homosexuality undermine the fight against oppression by portraying femininity as weakness. Johnson notes, 'the representation of effeminate homosexuality as disempowering is at the heart of hegemonic blackness' (2003: 220).
 

Critical Reception of Moonlight

In discussing Moonlight, it’s essential to examine both popular and academic receptions. Online reactions from journalists and LGBT bloggers were mostly positive, with many Hispanic and Black reviewers identifying personal connections to the film. Several expressed reflections on their own childhood experiences of being closeted and grappling with identity. Hilton Als, reflecting on his own experiences, was profoundly moved, stating, 'did I ever imagine, during my anxious, closeted childhood, that I’d live long enough to see a movie like “Moonlight,” Barry Jenkins’s brilliant, achingly alive new work about black queerness?' (2016). Angelica Jade Bastién detailed her emotional reaction rooted in her struggles growing up in Miami, feeling isolated between two worlds as an Afro-Latina (2017).

Others recounted vivid flashbacks to their experiences of childhood trauma and fear faced by young queer individuals. Michael Cuby described feeling actual fear while watching Moonlight, recalling moments when Chiron was chased through the streets (2017). Many audiences perceived the film as aligned with a broader drive for social and political progress, viewing it as a representation of queer political allegiance focused on social and cultural transformation (Stacy and Street 2007: 1). Bahamian filmmaker Sekiya Dorsett emphasized the film's historical significance in recognizing the lives of 'black and brown queer individuals' (quoted in O’Hara 2017). Activist Tiq Milan articulated that the Black queer community was searching for elements of tenderness and stillness, which they found represented in Moonlight (quoted in O’Hara 2017).

Conversely, academic critiques of the film were less straightforward in their praise. Some scholars scrutinized Chiron's embodiment of heteronormative masculinity in the film's third section. Drawing from Riggs's scholarship, Stallings asserts that Moonlight presents 'updates of hegemonic blackness', that perpetuate gender binaries in which femininity and feminine traits are continually devalued (2019: 342). Stallings further argued that the film critiques homophobia without addressing the real issue of femme phobia, whereby the absence of Black queer femininity heavily influences the narrative. Rinaldo Walcott points out that Moonlight evokes stereotypes about Black queer men while positing that the film receives acclaim from audiences because it does not fully manifest these stereotypes (2019: 337).

Further discussing motifs of bullying and exclusion, Walcott notes that these elements have become tropes in contemporary queer cinema, as observed in The Miseducation of Cameron Post (2018) and Dating Amber (2020). He observes that according to the critiques, Moonlight trades on stereotypes to disrupt preconceived notions, yet finds the film's lack of sexual intimacy deeply disaffecting and ultimately unsatisfying (2019: 340). Similarly, Stallings argues that the representation of Kevin and Chiron's relationship, wherein kissing is depicted merely as adolescent exploration, fails to adequately portray grown Black men in loving intimacy (2019: 350).

La Marr Jurelle Bruce initially expressed disappointment with the film's ending, longing for a fourth act showcasing Black men engaged in multiple forms of affectionate touch (2019: 356). This desire for romantic resolution is echoed by actor Trevante Rhodes, who dreams of an elderly Chiron and Kevin walking hand in hand in a park (quoted in Brathwaite 2017).

Sex and Intimacy in Mainstream LGBT Cinema

The representation of sex and intimacy in mainstream LGBT cinema is steeped in ongoing debates. Films representing same-sex female relationships often display explicit, sometimes pornographic, content that caters to the male gaze, exemplified in films like The Handmaiden and Blue Is the Warmest Colour. In stark contrast, many popular films featuring gay male protagonists notably elide or skim over the explicit depiction of sex. Guy Lodge questions whether Moonlight demonstrates that gay cinema must remain sexless to achieve commercial and critical success (2017b).

Similar critiques emerged surrounding Call Me By Your Name, condemning its refusal to depict explicit gay sexual acts, arguably as a concession to a 'universal', heterosexual audience. Guadagnino defended his artistic choice, stating the decision to avoid explicit scenes was meant to preserve intimacy while avoiding an unwelcome intrusion into private moments (Miller 2018). Critics counter this justification, linking the film's avoidance of sex to a 'beautification campaign', erasing discomfort and unpleasantries associated with sexual experience (Miller 2018). David Greven further interprets this distance as aligning with broader themes of longing and deprivation present in the film (2018).

Gendered Representation and Choice of Intimacy

In the following explorations of Moonlight, the connection between gender representation, quiet demeanor, and various forms of intimacy will be discussed. While Moonlight does not explicitly portray Black queerness embracing femininity, it utilizes symbolism to link Chiron with feminine elements, such as the imagery of water, mirrors, and moonlight (Berger 1973). Rather than devalued, these symbols reveal key aspects of Chiron's identity.

Taylor Barfield identifies a connection between Chiron and the mythological Yoruba goddess Yemoja, known for embodying fluidity in sexuality and identity (2017). The film presents a veneer of hegemonic masculinity, which, beneath its façade, is revealed to be a complex construct. Jenkins's representation of Chiron in relation to masculinity is reminiscent of Mary Anne Doane’s view of femininity as a mask, one that can be donned or discarded (Doane 1999: 427).

Chiron's interaction with Kevin in the diner exemplifies this complexity when Kevin comments on Chiron's bulk. This moment can be understood as reflective of the masks of masculinity Chiron constructs, manifested through his gold fronts, muscularity, and external tough-guy persona. The song 'Classic Man' (2015) underscores this concept, articulating a performance of masculinity that conceals true self beneath decorum and politeness.

For Zaman, Chiron’s character, imbued with palpable queerness, represents a hesitance shaped by his environment and experiences (2016: 42). The choice of actors for Moonlight was made based on their gaze and expressivity, highlighting Chiron's distinct patterns of watchfulness and introspection. Chiron's gaze contrasts with dominant masculine visibility; it stems from a place of caution born of societal expectations and dangers surrounding his identity.

Chiron’s attentive observation of his surroundings aligns with a feminized form of looking, as articulated by Richard Dyer (1982). Dyer underscores how women’s looks tend toward surveillance, emphasizing that Chiron's visual vigilance stems from a need to protect himself from off-screen threats, evidenced in his interactions with Juan and Kevin.

Constructing Gendered Views within the Film

Moonlight employs a poetic dream sequence encapsulating Kevin's character smoking outside the diner, providing an avenue for exploring gender queering aspects and forms of visual perception. The close-up shots command a look that draws parallels to moments in films where female characters break from male-centric viewing experiences. In this regard, Kevin's engagement with the camera signifies an awareness of queerness and offers insight into unseen dynamics between himself and Chiron.

Despite Chiron's reticent nature, his silence during poignant moments—like discussions around Juan and Paula—carries significant weight. Critics observe that Chiron’s quiet disposition is fundamentally linked to the broader topics of sexuality explored throughout the film. Jung notes that Moonlight's resonance lies in its unsaid moments, particularly as they relate to Chiron's burgeoning sexual identity (2018).

Many viewers connect their own narratives of childhood and adolescent identity issues to Chiron's quiet journey. Josh Lee illustrates this link by pointing to shared experiences of fear and survival that queer children face in their environments (2017). Kevin Quashie’s perspective on the representation of Black ‘quiet’ calls for moving away from caricatured portrayals, instead recognizing nuanced aspects of human experience that are often overlooked in traditional depictions (2012: 334).

The Significance of Silence and Touch

Jenkins, who identifies as less loquacious, believes that silence conveys the core of character narratives, allowing the audience to perceive layers beneath the surface. Quiet moments build an intimate connection between Kevin and Chiron, effectively avoiding overt sexual representations. Critics argue that representations of Black intimacy have been notably absent in mainstream media, reflecting broader patterns of homogenized portrayals of Black male identity (Guerrero 1993: 144; Collier 1989).

Marlon Riggs contends that portrayals of Black masculinity oscillate between two extremes: muted hyposexuality and wild hypersexuality (1991: 392). Jacquie Jones maintains that as Hollywood’s narratives have grown increasingly violent, authentic forms of sexuality have been neglected, leaving emotional intimacy as the only avenue for characters to connect (1993: 248). With that, the absence of Black male intimacy on screen implies an inability to appreciate Black male characters as fully realized individuals.

Viewers like Matthew Progress expressed gratitude for the focus on emotional intimacy over explicit sexual content, noting the rarity in cinema of such representations of love between Black men (quoted in Parris 2016). The film's eroticism unfolds principally through tenderness and emotional depth, marked by one key explicit scene on the beach where Kevin stimulates Chiron.

The scene resonates with quietness, encapsulated in the boys’ interaction and their longing gaze prior to sex, suggesting a unique intimacy elevated by environmental sensory detail and muted surroundings. Critics note the absence of a lush visual palette stands in stark contrast to the beach scenes where emotional stakes are paramount.

Chiron's vocalizations during the beach scene underline shared desires and unspoken queries as they explore their intimacy. The brief moments of conversation dynamically capture Chiron's journey through self-discovery and highlight the vulnerability accompanying intimacy. Dialogues in this sequence reveal deeper connections and emerging sensations of closeness while punctuated with ambient sound and silence that softens the experience.

Laura Marks highlights the idea of 'haptic' viewing, where sensory engagement supersedes visual connections, granting a richer emotional experience from mundane, perhaps grainy, visual elements (Marks 2000: 181). Disoriented by the film’s touch, Yancy reflects that the 'touch' of Moonlight unnerved him, indicating that watching it transcends mere observation (2019: 65).

Exploring Intimacy and Materiality

This tension and disorientation intertwine tactile experiences and identity orientation throughout Moonlight. Baldwin’s considerations of race intertwine directly with sexuality; the queries surrounding racial identity often precede those related to sexual identity. Baldwin asserts sexual questions are secondary to experiences of color, compelling Black individuals to navigate societal dangers uniquely, which white queer individuals may perceive as a lack of security.

E. Patrick Johnson's examination of race, sexuality, and class opens new interpretations of Moonlight, highlighting how deployments of 'queer' may not resonate with the same frequency among queer people of color (Johnson 2001). Johnson proposes 'quare', a term that rejects the universality of 'queer' by foregrounding embodied knowledges deeply tied to race and class (Johnson 2019: 71).

For Johnson, Moonlight exemplifies quare cinema, where narratives of masculinity resonate as a makeshift creation grounded in the material conditions superheroing discussions about normalized queerness, enacting an understanding of sexuality that diverges substantially from mainstream representations.

The diner reunion scene stands as a crucial moment in Moonlight, filmed in real-time over a period of 20 minutes, allowing for profundity amid silence. This change of pacing sharply contrasts previous film sections, emphasizing their timeline gloss. Fight losses and gender constructions discussed earlier intertwine here, manifesting during the meal preparation, which bears deep social and material significance.

As a meal becomes a site of past nourishment and emotional complexities, the preparation by Kevin echoes initial tenderness extended towards Chiron, reigniting feelings of connection amid poverty and longing. Johnson identifies these representations of food as fundamental elements of humanizing narratives that explore community and kinship depicted in Moonlight (Johnson 2019: 78).

The recurrence of food as an experiential medium implies that the act of sharing and providing sustenance speaks to emotional engagement across Chiron's journey of self-discovery and identity negotiation amid relationship dynamics. The potential of intimacy established in these moments creates resonance beyond physical barriers and expounds deeper emotional truths. Johnson further reflects that the emotional landscape of the diner scene conveys powerful intimacy entwined with lingering glances and silent affirmations.

Ultimately, Moonlight’s dialogue and musical interjections catalyze lingering themes surrounding love and connection. The song 'Hello Stranger' (1963) invokes nostalgia of memories shared, insinuating profound reflections on connection drifting back into consciousness as they navigate complexities of their past dynamics. As Chiron and Kevin reconcile aspects of their identities—embodied awareness towards potent moments—the emotional aftermath of their reunion underscores vulnerability and longing that define both characters.

Conclusion

The film's conclusion reflects a landmark transformation in Chiron's journey toward self-acceptance and intimacy. Jenkins articulates Chiron’s admission of long-lived unworthiness intertwined with vulnerability and longing, suggesting greater uncertainty rather than absolute closure. While they ensure a reaffirming embrace at the film’s conclusion, this dynamic invites consideration of the threads connecting their experiences and transformation. As Johnson aptly summarizes, 'intimacy might be the salve for the wound of poverty', highlighting how connections forged through trauma and emotion may reshape understandings of identity and belonging (Johnson 2019: 71). Overall, Moonlight becomes not just an exploration of queerness but a profound reflection on the intersectionality of race, sexuality, and class.