U.S. Government Foundations, Elections, and Polarization

Constitutional Foundations and Philosophical Roots

  • Articles of Confederation (A.O.C.): First constitution; created a weak national government without the power to tax, regulate commerce, enforce laws, or coerce states.

  • 1787 Constitutional Convention: Triggered after Shay's rebellion highlighted the weaknesses of the A.O.C.; James Madison moved to replace the framework entirely.

  • Philosophical Roots:

    • Locke: Popular sovereignty and limited government.

    • Montesquieu: Separation of powers.

    • Hume: Politics defined as a competition of interests.

    • Sir Isaac Newton: Balancing power with power.

  • The Great Compromise: Resolved representation disputes between states by combining the population-based Virginia Plan with the proportion-based New Jersey Plan (Senate).

Institutional Structure and Separation of Powers

  • Article I (Legislative): Congress holds expansive authority to tax, regulate commerce, declare war, and enact laws.

    • House of Representatives: Representation based on population; does not allow filibusters.

    • Senate: Equal representation by state; permits filibusters.

  • Article II (Executive): The president holds veto power, negotiates treaties, and faithfully executes laws.

  • Article III (Judicial): Supreme Court holds lifetime tenure to check the other branches.

  • Executive Power Expansion: Substantially broadened through statutory delegation granted by Congress.

  • Major Question Doctrine: Supreme Court rule mandating explicit congressional authorization for executive actions carrying vast economic impact (e.g., striking down Pres. Trump's unilateral tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act).

The Federalist Papers

  • Overview: Series of essays written in defense of the Constitution.

  • Fed 10: James Madison argued that a large, extensive republic dilutes the factional influence and violence.

  • Fed 51: James Madison argued for the necessity of a system of checks and balances, noting that "ambition must be made to counteract ambition."

Congressional Apportionment, Gerrymandering, and Elections

  • Congressional Apportionment: House of Representatives capped at 435 members since 1911; seats are reapportioned following each census.

  • Gerrymandering: Partisan manipulation of electoral district boundaries to maximize party seats:

    • Packing: Concentrating as many opposing voters into a single district as possible to waste their surplus votes and forfeit surrounding seats.

    • Cracking: Dispersing opposing voters across several districts to dilute their influence and prevent them from winning.

    • Rucho v. Common Cause (2019): Supreme Court ruled that partisan gerrymandering is non-justiciable and outside federal court jurisdiction, leaving oversight to state legislatures.

  • Campaign Financing: Characterized by perpetual outside fundraising. Under Citizen's United, Super PACs may spend unlimited amounts provided they do not coordinate directly with campaigns.

  • Voter Behavior:

    • Ticket-Splitting: Casting votes for candidates from different political parties on one ballot; has declined due to extreme polarization and diminished comfort across party lines.

    • Primaries: Typically draw the most ideologically extreme voters within each party.

2024 Election Dynamics

  • Turnout: Marked by high voter turnout.

  • Primary Issues: Inflation and the cost of living served as the leading voter concern.

  • Demographic Shifts (2016–2024): Swings away from the Democratic Party among Hispanics, Asians, and some moderate Black voters (particularly men).

Political Parties and Polarization

  • Role of Parties:

    • The Founders viewed factions as dangerous, but the constitutional design incentivized party formation.

    • Three core operational functions: party in government, party organization, and party in the electorate.

    • Winner-take-all electoral rules structurally suppress third parties.

  • Evolution of the Party System:

    • The New-deal coalition fractured in the 1960s over civil rights and cultural issues.

    • Sixth Party System: Contemporary era characterized by severe division and voters who are more ideologically sorted into parties than before.

  • Institutional Polarization: High-stakes competition for control in Congress marked by straight-party voting, a vanishing political center, and no ideological overlap between elected Democrats and Republicans.

  • Social Polarization: Partisanship functions as an encompassing "mega-identity" aligned with race, religion, and geography, eroding the cross-cutting social ties that historically fostered political compromise.