T-Cell Redirecting Tri-Specific Antibodies for Solid Tumor Treatment Notes
T-Cell Redirecting Tri-Specific Antibodies for Solid Tumor Treatment
Objective
- Determine whether Tri-specific antibodies (tsAb) that simultaneously block immune checkpoint proteins (PD-L1 and LAG-3?) while redirecting CD3+ T Cells work better in enhancing T cell activation and solid tumor cell death than current bispecific antibodies (bsAb).
Background
- Immunotherapy is a relatively new form of cancer treatment.
- T-Cell Redirecting Bispecific Antibody (bsAb) is a type of immunotherapy.
- Has been proven to work in blood cancers like leukemia.
- Less effective in solid tumors.
- Challenges with solid tumors:
- Tumor immunosuppressive microenvironment.
- Immune checkpoint proteins that help tumors evade the immune system.
- T-Cell Redirecting Tri-Specific antibody (tsAb) has three targets.
- Current tsAbs mostly target two tumor-associated antigens and one antigen on the T cell.
- Proposed strategy: target an immune checkpoint protein on the cancer cell, block it, and then target a T-Cell.
- This could help suppress the immunosuppressive tumor microenvironment.
Review of Literature
- Article 1: A novel CD19/CD22/CD3 tri-specific antibody… (liquid tumor).
- Article 2: A novel engineered EpCAM/CD3/4-1BB tri-specific antibody… (solid tumor).
- Article 3: The redirected killing of PDL1…(bispecific).
Research Question
- Does a tri-specific antibody that simultaneously blocks immune checkpoint proteins while redirecting CD3+ T cells work better in enhancing T cell activation and tumor cell death than current bispecific antibody treatments?
Methods
- Solid tumor cell line.
- Treatment groups (3 each):
- Control (no treatment).
- bsAb alone (EpCAM and CD8).
- Anti-PDL-1 antibody alone.
- Combination tsAb (bsAb + anti-PD-L1).
- T cells: Primary CD3+ T cells isolated from healthy donors.
- Measurements:
- Tumor cell capability.
- T cell activation.
- Cytokine levels.
- Apoptosis in tumor cells.
Expected Results
- Expected results:
- Combination therapy resulted in the greatest reduction in tumor viability, highest T cell activation, and elevated cytokine production.
- tsAb worked the best out of everything.
Treatment | Tumor Cell Survival (%) | T Cell activation (%) | Cytokine Levels |
---|
Control | 100 | 5 | 20 |
bsAb only | 60 | 45 | 110 |
Checkpoint inhibitor (anti-PD1) | 75 | 20 | 60 |
tsAb | 20 | 75 | 220 |
Conclusion
- tsAbs that both bind to and block the checkpoint inhibitors on cancer cells enhance the immune response and overcome immunosuppression in solid tumors.
- This strategy could improve the effectiveness of T Cell redirecting therapies.
JNJ Article: Creating the Antibody (JNJ-78306358)
- Scientists engineered a bispecific antibody that can bind to:
- CD3 on T cells
- HLA-G on tumor cells.
- It acts like a bridge bringing T cells close to tumor cells so they can kill them.
How They Measured Everything
Where is HLA-G Found?
- Technique: Immunohistochemistry (IHC).
- Purpose: Check which human tissues have the HLA-G protein.
- How it works:
- They used a dye-labeled antibody (called 4H84) that sticks to HLA-G.
- They applied it to thin slices of tissue from organs and tumors.
- Under a microscope, brown staining = HLA-G present.
- This helped them learn that HLA-G is mostly in tumors, placenta, and pituitary glands, but not much in other healthy tissues.
How Strongly Does the Antibody Bind?
- Techniques: Flow Cytometry & HDX-MS (Mass Spectrometry).
Flow Cytometry
- Purpose: Measure how well the antibody binds to cells and if it causes T cells to get activated or kill.
- How it works:
- Cells are mixed with the antibody.
- Cells go one-by-one through a laser beam.
- If the antibody sticks to a cell, it glows due to a special fluorescent tag.
- They can measure:
- How much HLA-G a cell has.
- Whether T cells get activated (CD25 turns on when T cells are activated).
- Whether cancer cells die after treatment.
HDX-MS (Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry)
- Purpose: Find out exactly where the antibody binds on HLA-G.
- How it works:
- Parts of HLA-G that are covered by the antibody change more slowly in heavy water (D_2O).
- Mass spectrometry detects those changes, revealing the "landing spot" of the antibody.
Can It Block Cancer's Defense System?
- Technique: Receptor Blocking Assay
- Purpose: See if JNJ-78306358 can block HLA-G from stopping the immune system.
- How it works:
- They used cells with HLA-G receptors (called ILT2 and ILT4).
- Added HLA-G and saw if it would bind.
- Then added JNJ-78306358 to see if it blocks that binding (it did!).
Does It Kill Tumor Cells?
- Technique: In Vitro Killing Assay (lab dish)
- Purpose: Check if T cells will destroy cancer cells when JNJ-78306358 is added.
- How it works:
- Mix cancer cells with T cells and the antibody.
- After a few days, measure how many cancer cells died.
- More cancer cell death = better performance.
- They used different doses and different cancer cell types.
Does It Work in Living Animals?
- Technique: Mouse Studies (in vivo)
- Purpose: See if JNJ-78306358 kills tumors in live animals.
- How it works:
- Mice were given human tumors and human T cells.
- They injected the antibody and measured:
- Tumor size over time (with rulers or imaging).
- How many T cells entered the tumor (using IHC and flow cytometry).
- Antibody levels in the mouse’s blood and tumors (to check how long it lasts = pharmacokinetics).
How Much HLA-G is Needed to Work?
- Techniques:
- Wes (a small version of Western blot) to measure protein levels.
- Cytokine tests (like IFN-γ release) to see how strong the T cell response is.
- Result: They found that the therapy only works well if the tumor has enough HLA-G on its surface.
Method | What It Does | What They Learned |
---|
IHC | Detects protein in tissues | Found where HLA-G is located |
Flow Cytometry | Measures binding, killing, and T cell activation | Proved antibody is specific and effective |
HDX-MS | Shows binding site of the antibody | Confirmed where JNJ-78306358 binds |
In vitro killing assay | Tests cell death in lab dishes | Showed it kills cancer cells with HLA-G |
In vivo mouse tests | Tests therapy in living animals | Showed tumor shrinkage |
Wes & cytokine tests | Measures protein and immune signals | Identified which tumors respond best |
Article 1: A novel CD19/CD22/CD3 trispecific antibody enhances therapeutic efficacy and overcomes immune escape against B-ALL
- CD19/CD3 bispecific antibody: blinatumomab shows success in leukemia
- Really bad relapse though because of the loss of the CD19 TAA
- Researchers developed a CD19/CD22/CD3 Tri specific antibody to address this
- Methods:
- Fused anti-CD19 & anti-CD22 --> anti-CD3
- They made many formats of bsAbs and tsAbs to find the best configuration
- CC format was best: CD19/FMC63 to C terminus of CD3 heavy chain; CD22/Nb25 to C terminus of CD3 light chain
- In Vitro Testing:
- Nalm6 cell line (B-ALL cell line with CD19 and CD22 expression)
- Assays
- Cytotoxicity (how well antibody caused T cells to kill cancer cells)
- Cytokine production: indicate T cell activation
- Synapse formation: see if tight contacts form between T cells and cancer cells
- Binding: flow cytometry to make sure that each antibody binds correctly
- In Vivo Testing:
- NCG mice lacking immune cells
- Mice injected with B-ALL cells initially; few days later human T cells
- Treated with either tsAb, bsAb (CD19/CD3 or CD22/CD3), or combination
- Measurements:
- Tumor burden: bioluminescent imaging (B-ALL cells have luciferase enzyme)
- Survival of mice
- Cytokines in blood
- How long T cells lasted in the mice
- Immune escape model: mixed tumor with CD19 and CD22 to simulate antigen loss
- Only tsAb could target both AND prevent tumor relapse
More In Vivo
- B-ALL cells from a real patient were injected into the mice
- Medium CD19 and low CD22.
- tsAb worked better with this even when bsAbs were used together.
- Mice with tsAb had longer survival AND less relapse
- Compared tsAb with blinatumomab: both killed CD19+ cells well
- Only tsAb could kill CD19-/CD22+ cells
- This tsAb could have lots of potential
- Researchers created a tsAb targeting CD19, CD22 TAAs and CD3+ T cells to overcome antigen loss in solid tumors
- In vitro tests: tsAb effectively activated T cells, promoted cytotoxicity, and formed strong immune synapses
- In vivo tests: tsAb reduced tumor burden in immunodeficient mice, prolonged survival, and prevented relapse better than tested bsAbs
- tsAb only therapy that worked in models where either CD19 or CD22 were missing
- Compared to current bsAb, blinatumomab, tsAb eliminated wider variety of cells Ex: CD19-/CD20+
- This tsAb shows strong promise in leukemia therapy with reduced relapse risk
Article 2: The redirected killing of PD-L1 positive tumor cells by expanded MAIT cells is mediated with a bispecific antibody targeting TCR Vα7.2 and PD-L1
- Currently, most bsAbs target CD3 (also on regulatory T cells that suppress immune responses)
- Looked into targeting MAIT cells (rare immune cells; type of T cell)
- Methods:
- White blood cells from healthy donors
- Stimulated the cells with antibodies specific to MAIT cells
- Also with cytokines to help the MAIT cells grow
- 90% of cells were now MAIT cells
- Most had CD8, naïve phenotype, and low inhibitory markers
- bsAb: one arm to Vα7.2 on MAIT and other to PD-L1 on tumor
- PD-L1+ tumor cell lines (lung/ovarian cancer)
- Engineered to express luciferase so it could be measured by light
- Binding tests
- Tumor binding: very strong binding
- MAIT binding: okay
- MAIT x Tumor bridging: worked!
- Tested if the bsAb could turn on the MAIT cells only in presence of tumor (yes)
- Tested tumor cell killing (less light = more killing)
- bsAb had strong tumor killing in the PD-L1 cell lines
Main Ideas:
- This study explored targeting MAIT cells, a rare type of T cell, instead of CD3
- Created a novel bsAb binding to Vα7.2 on MAIT cells and PD-L1 on tumor cells
- PD-L1 (programmed death-ligand 1) is often overexpressed on cancer cells to inhibit T cell response
- Engineered tumor cell lines (lung and ovarian) to express PD-L1
- This bsAb only activated the MAIT cells in the presence of the PD-L1+ tumor cells
- This bsAb showed strong tumor killing in these cell lines
Article 3: IMT030122, A novel engineered EpCAM/CD3/4-1BB tri-specific antibody, enhances T-cell recruitment and demonstrates anti-tumor activity in mouse models of colorectal cancer
- Colorectal cancer is one of the most common digestive system cancers
- EpCAM is very much expressed in over 97% of CRC tumors
- Needed for cell adhesion, signaling, proliferation, differentiation
- Designed tsAb targeting EpCAM/CD3/4-1BB
- 4-1BB co-stimulatory receptor on activated T cells, NK cells, other immune cells
- Boosts T cell proliferation (especially in CD8+), enhances cytokine production, prevents T cell exhaustion/death, promotes formation of memory T cells
- Wanted to activate T cells only in presence of EpCAM
- Measured:
- Tumor cell killing
- Cytokines
- Effector memory T cells
- Anti-apoptotic protein expression
- Mice transplanted with human blood cells and tumors; tsAb injected daily for 11 days
- Tracked with bioluminescent imaging, tumor volume, and survival of mice
- Target specific binding:
- EpCAM: high affinity
- 4-1BB: high affinity
- CD3: low affinity (on purpose)
- Tumor specific T cell activation confirmed!
- CD8^+ T cells are essential
- CD8^+ T cells are the main killer
- Main cells that this tsAb activates to attack the cancer isCD8^+
Main Ideas:
- Novel trispecific antibody
- Over 97% of colorectal cancer (CRC) tumors express EpCAM
- Researchers developed a tsAb targeting EpCAM, CD3, and 4-1BB
- 4-1BB is a co-stimulatory receptor on activated T cells and NK cells that boosts CD8^+ T cells
- Goal: activate T cells only in presence of EpCAM on tumor cells
- Results showed tumor-specific T cell activation
- However, activating CD3 on the T cell as well as a T cell booster can lead to overactive immune response
- EpCAM/PD-L1/CD3