Chapter 7

Short Run vs. Long Run

• Short run: A period where at least one factor of production is fixed (e.g., plant size, capital). In this context, firms can only adjust variable inputs like labor and raw materials. This leads to the principle of diminishing marginal productivity, where adding more variable input to a fixed input eventually yields smaller increases in output.

• Long run: A period where all factors of production are variable. Firms have sufficient time to alter their plant size, acquire new machinery, or even exit the industry. Consequently, all costs are variable, and the concept of diminishing marginal productivity, which relies on a fixed input, is no longer directly relevant.

• Operational Horizon: Firms always produce and operate within their current short-run capacity, as they exist in a specific physical plant at any given moment. However, all strategic decisions, such as investing in new facilities or expanding production lines, are made with a long-run perspective, considering all potential adjustments to inputs.

Long-Run Average Cost (LRAC)

• Definition: The LRAC curve is an 'envelope' curve that represents the lowest possible average cost of producing any given level of output when all inputs are variable. It is formed by the points of tangency with the short-run average cost (SRAC) curves of different plant sizes, indicating the most efficient scale of operation for various output levels.

• Shape Determinants: The shape of the LRAC curve is fundamentally determined by the presence of economies of scale, constant returns to scale, or diseconomies of scale. These translate into downward-sloping, horizontal, or upward-sloping sections of the LRAC, respectively.

• Core Formula: The fundamental formula used to calculate average cost, AC = \frac{TC}{Q}, is crucial for comparing the cost efficiency of different production scales and understanding the behavior of the LRAC.

Constant Returns to Scale (CRS)

• Description: Occurs when a proportional increase in all inputs results in an equally proportional increase in output. For example, if inputs double, output also doubles.

• Cost Implication: Under CRS, the minimum Average Cost (AC) remains identical across various plant sizes. This implies that there is no cost advantage to being either very small or very large, leading to a horizontal segment of the Long-Run Average Cost (LRAC) curve. Firms can replicate their production process without changes in per-unit cost.

Economies of Scale (Increasing Returns)

• Description: Achieved when output increases by a greater percentage than the percentage increase in all inputs. This means that as a firm grows larger, its minimum average cost of production falls.

• Sources: These cost advantages arise from several factors:

  • Technical Economies:

    • Division of Labour: Specialization of workers in specific tasks leads to increased efficiency, reduced training costs, and higher skill levels.

    • Specialized Machinery: Large-scale production allows the use of highly specialized and efficient machinery or automation, which may be uneconomical at smaller scales.

    • Management Integration: Optimized organizational structures and improved coordination in larger firms can lead to more efficient decision-making and better resource allocation.

  • Pecuniary Economies:

    • Bulk Buying: Larger firms can negotiate discounts for raw materials and other inputs due to their large purchase volumes, lowering per-unit input costs.

    • Lower Borrowing & Advertising Costs: Larger, more established firms often have better credit ratings, allowing them to secure loans at lower interest rates. Similarly, fixed advertising costs can be spread over a much larger output, reducing the average advertising cost per unit.

    • Sale of By-products: Large-scale production might generate significant quantities of by-products that can be sold, creating an additional revenue stream and effectively reducing net production costs.

• LRAC Impact: Presence of economies of scale results in a downward-sloping LRAC curve, indicating that the firm's average costs decrease as its scale of operation expands, up to the point where these economies are fully exploited.

Diseconomies of Scale (Decreasing Returns)

• Description: Occur when output increases by a smaller percentage than the percentage increase in all inputs, causing the minimum average cost (AC) to rise as the firm's size expands beyond a certain point.

• Causes: Primarily linked to managerial and organizational inefficiencies that become more pronounced in very large organizations:

  • Bureaucratic Inefficiencies: As an organization grows, management layers increase, leading to:

    • Longer Communication Lines: Information must pass through more hierarchical levels, slowing down decision-making and potentially distorting messages.

    • Higher Information Costs: It becomes more challenging and costly to gather, process, and disseminate information effectively across the vast organization.

    • Blurred Responsibilities: Defining clear roles and responsibilities becomes difficult, potentially leading to a lack of accountability, duplication of efforts, or neglected tasks.

• LRAC Impact: The LRAC curve slopes upward beyond the efficient range of production, signifying that average costs rise as the firm continues to expand due to these inefficiencies.

Minimum Efficient Scale (MES)

• Definition: The Minimum Efficient Scale (MES) is the smallest output level at which a firm can achieve the lowest possible long-run average cost. Operating at MES signifies that the firm is producing at the most cost-efficient output level per unit, having fully exploited all available economies of scale.

• **