Consequentialism-Ethics Defined

Consequentialism

  • Definition: Consequentialism is an ethical theory that evaluates the morality of an action based on its outcomes or results.

    • It asserts that the rightness or wrongness of actions is determined by their consequences.

    • Example: While lying is generally considered immoral, under consequentialism, it could be deemed acceptable if it serves to save a person's life.

Examples of Consequentialism

  • Utilitarianism:

    • Definition: A form of consequentialism that assesses actions based on the principle of promoting the greatest good for the greatest number of people.

    • Key Idea: The moral rightness of an action is determined by how well it maximizes overall happiness or utility.

  • Hedonism:

    • Definition: A variant of consequentialism that identifies actions as “good” if they result in pleasure or help avoid pain.

    • Key Idea: Happiness and pleasure are the ultimate values to be pursued in ethical decision making.

Critique of Consequentialism

  • Knowledge of Consequences:

    • Challenge: It is often difficult or even impossible to predict the outcomes of actions in advance.

    • Assertion: Certainty regarding future consequences is unattainable, leading to potential moral dilemmas.

  • Objectionable Outcomes:

    • Issue: Consequentialism may justify actions that are intuitively objectionable if they yield seemingly beneficial outcomes.

    • Example Scenario:

    • Hypothetical situation: Economists suggest that the world economy would be enhanced, resulting in increased happiness, health, and wealth for most people, if 2% of the population were enslaved.

    • Moral Conflict: Although the perceived benefits would be significant for the majority, moral intuitions strongly oppose the concept of enslavement.

    • Conclusion: Classic consequentialism's perspective that "the end justifies the means" can lead to ethically troubling justifications.