ethics concept 40

Concept of Ethics in Nursing Practice

Lesson Overview

  • Objectives:

    1. Define and describe the concept of ethics.

    2. Discuss ethical principles and theories.

    3. Identify ways that ethical issues impact nursing and health care.


Definition of Ethics

  • Ethics:

    • The study or examination of morality through various approaches.

    • Morality: An accepted set of social standards (or morals) that guide behavior.

    • Ethical responses reflect core values, beliefs, and character, shaping one’s professional identity.

Related Terms in Ethics

  • Ethical Sensitivity: The ability to recognize ethical issues and dilemmas in situations.

  • Ethical Reflection and Analysis: The process of contemplating ethical implications and reasoning.

  • Ethical Decision Making: The method of processing ethical dilemmas to reach a resolution.

  • Moral Courage: The willingness to act rightly in the face of popular opposition or personal loss.

Approaches to Ethics
  • Metaethics: Examines the nature of moral judgments and what they mean.

  • Normative Ethics: Sets out the principles that govern what constitutes right action.

  • Applied/Practical Ethics: Looks at how ethical principles apply to specific cases and instances in areas such as healthcare.


Complexity of Ethics

  • Ethics encompasses various dimensions of a person’s life, highlighting its multifaceted nature.


Societal Ethics

  • Society establishes a normative basis for ethical behavior through laws and regulations.

  • Law: Serves as the minimum standard of behavior required from all societal members.

  • Legal standards relevant to nursing include:

    • Clinical standards of care

    • Liability

    • Negligence

    • Malpractice


Organizational Ethics

  • Organizations adhere to formal and informal principles and values that guide members' behavior and decisions.


Professional Ethics

  • Standards and expectations specific to a profession.

  • Professionals are held to a higher standard due to their privileged role in society.

  • Ethics involve a code of conduct aimed at achieving the highest ideals of practice.


Bioethics, Clinical Ethics, and Research Ethics

  • Bioethics: Involves ethical questions related to biological sciences and technology.

  • Clinical Ethics: Concerns the decisions made in direct patient care settings.

  • Research Ethics: A subset of bioethics that pertains to ethical conduct in research involving humans and animals.


Personal Ethics

  • Intersects continuously with societal, organizational, and professional ethics.

  • Relationships and conflicts between different ethical categories exist, illustrating the dynamic nature of personal ethics.

  • Sources and influences of personal ethics are not static; they evolve over time.


Ethical Principles

  • Ethical principles serve as lenses to analyze situations, which include:

    • Respect for Persons: Acknowledging the intrinsic worth and autonomy of individuals.

    • Nonmaleficence: The principle of doing no harm.

    • Beneficence: The obligation to act for the benefit of others.

    • Justice: Fair distribution of resources and treatment.

    • Fidelity: The promise to maintain trust and keep commitments.


Ethical Theory

  • Ethics of Duty: Focuses on doing what is considered the right action regardless of the consequences.

  • Ethics of Consequence: Centers on actions that produce the greatest good for the greatest number.

  • Ethics of Character: Emphasizes personal integrity shaped by life experiences and reflective thought.

  • Ethics of Relationship: Discusses the obligations and nature of interpersonal connections.


Impact of Ethical Issues on Nursing and Health Care

Confrontation with Ethical Choices
  • Ethical practice in nursing requires making crucial decisions amidst complex situations.

  • Factors that may cause ethical faltering in decision-making include:

    • High-stakes scenarios

    • Conflicting values and beliefs

Ethical Decision Making
  • Health care decisions involving ethical dilemmas generally require collaborative efforts.

  • Compliance officers and committees ensure that ethical standards are observed within healthcare institutions.

  • Organizations maintain mechanisms for reporting unethical behaviors.


Ethical Issues in Nursing

  • Key ethical concerns include:

    • Protecting patients’ rights and human dignity

    • Respecting informed consent for treatments

    • Providing care at the risk of the nurse's health

    • Ethical implications of using restraints

    • Staffing issues leading to limited patient care

    • Decisions regarding life-prolonging measures

    • Quality of life considerations for patients

    • Organizational policies affecting care standards

    • Navigating professional relationships with impaired or unethical colleagues


Moral Distress

  • Moral Distress: The experience of feeling unable to act in a morally desirable way, coupled with acting against one’s personal and professional morals.

  • Situational triggers for moral distress include:

    • End-of-life care dilemmas

    • Encounters with incompetent practitioners

  • Symptoms of moral distress can manifest as frustration, anger, guilt, anxiety, withdrawal, self-blame, and other stress-related issues.

Reactive Distress or Moral Residue
  • Moral Residue: The accumulation of feelings and stress from unresolved ethical dilemmas over time.

  • Responses to moral residue can manifest in multiple ways, such as:

    • Conscientious Objection: Withholding participation in actions that conflict with one’s ethical beliefs.

    • Passivity or Withdrawal: Disconnecting from challenging situations.

    • Burnout: Resulting in leaving the profession altogether.

  • Moral Resilience: The capacity to cope and maintain integrity amidst ethical challenges.


Interrelated Concepts Impacting Ethics in Nursing

  • Several concepts interact with ethics in nursing including:

    • Health Policy

    • Health Care Law

    • Health Care Economics

    • Professional Identity

    • Health Care Quality

    • Safety

    • Evidence-based Practice

    • Collaboration

    • Technology and Informatics

    • Leadership

    • Culture

    • Spirituality

    • Health Disparities


Featured Exemplars in Ethical Practice

  • Practical scenarios illustrating ethical constructs include:

    • Pain management and addiction issues

    • Confidentiality and privacy concerns in care

    • Advance directives and patient autonomy

    • Uncompensated care dilemmas

    • Conflict of interest situations