Postmodernism, Pop, and Commodity Art Notes
Introduction to Postmodernism, Pop, and Commodity Art
Pop Art as the First Postmodern Art Movement
- Postmodern era: Generally dated from 1972.
- Pop art: Considered the initial postmodern art movement.
- Art Market Evolution: Production for the marketplace has been integral to art since the Renaissance. The contemporary art market developed more recently, influenced by the growth of an international bourgeoisie in the 1960s with expendable capital.
- Thomas Crowe's perspective: Noted that American pop art resembled products being sold as products.
Andy Warhol
- American artist: Known for work that reveres and playfully exploits American commercial culture, fame, and glamour.
- Early Life and Interests:
- Developed artistic interests early, particularly during a childhood illness.
- Spent time drawing, taking pictures, and collecting celebrity autographs.
- His fascination with both art and celebrity shaped his career.
- Celebrity Fascination:
- As Warhol's own fame increased, he became more interested in the phenomenon of celebrity itself.
- He combined popular culture images with mass media dissemination using printmaking techniques to highlight and explore celebrity culture.
- Breaking Boundaries:
- Warhol's work blurred the lines between high and low art, a common trait in pop art.
- American pop art looked toward mass media sources like advertising, car design, science fiction, comic books, popular movies, and consumer products.
Warhol's Campbell's Soup
- First solo pop exhibition: Held at the Ferris Gallery in Los Angeles.
- Production Method: Initially created images by hand but later adopted the silk screen printing method.
- Impersonal Aesthetic: Warhol wanted his work to appear machine-made and impersonal.
- Quote: "The reason that I am painting this way is because I want to be a machine. Whatever I do, and do machine-like it is because that is what I want to do."
- He expressed a desire for uniformity, reflected in the repetition of images.
Repetitive Imagery
- Mechanical Reproduction: The repetitive imagery and standardized format resemble mechanical reproduction.
- Handmade Elements: Black outlines were likely stamped by hand from a carved woodblock, introducing subtle variations.
- Variations: Each bottle differs in greenness, underpainting, and stamped profile clarity.
- Irregularities: The bottles are slightly askew, disrupting the grid's regularity, making the work appear both handmade and mass-produced.
Brillo Box
- Meticulous Copies: The Brillo boxes are precise copies of commercial packaging.
- Art Imitates Life: These works embody the idea that art should imitate life but also question the identification and valuation of art.
- Challenging Art Definitions:
- The boxes challenged the definition of fine art and the concept of originality.
- Warhol produced and sold numerous Brillo boxes to art collectors and museums.
- His work not only retained the aesthetic of mass-produced consumer goods but essentially became them.
Marilyn Diptych
- Silkscreen Depiction: Features Marilyn Monroe and is one of Warhol's most famous pieces.
- Source Image: Consists of 50 images from a 1953 publicity photograph from the film Niagara, owned and distributed by her movie studio.
- Timing: Completed shortly after her death in August 1962.
- Trademark Style: Utilized silkscreen printing, a commercial process for easily reproducing images from popular culture.
- Color Scheme: The left 25 images are in color, while the right side is in black and white.
Rosalyn Drexler's Marilyn Pursued by Death
- Technique: Cut magazine images and overpainted them onto canvas.
- Original Photograph: Used the bodyguard as a key figure, but implies a different interpretation.
- Interpretation:
- Monroe is depicted rushing off the canvas, pursued by a man in black and white.
- It's a commentary on the objectification of celebrities and women, particularly Marilyn Monroe.
- Represents her pursuit by fans or stalkers.
- Aesthetic:
- Monochromatic color scheme with red outlines.
- Figures appear caught between a photograph, painting, or cartoon, reflecting a pop art quality.
- Reminder of Humanity: Aims to represent Marilyn as a person, not just a subject or film icon.
Audrey Flack's Marilyn Vanitas
- Combination of Styles: Combines Dutch Baroque still life (vanitas) and trompe l'oeil paintings with a photorealistic appearance and pop references.
- Vanitas Theme: A vanitas scene reminds of death and the transitory nature of life, while also celebrating Monroe's life and emphasizing her humanity.
- Symbolism:
- Symbols of death: hourglass, clock, and candle.
- Images of her youth from before her stardom.
- Emphasis: Reflects Marilyn as a woman and artist, not just a celebrity, stressing her humanity.
Roy Lichtenstein
- Connection to Pop Art: Inextricably linked to the pop art movement and is considered one of its originators.
- Imagery: His work was based on imagery from comic strips and advertisements.
- Impersonal Style: Intended his work to appear impersonal.
- Printing Process: His style draws upon newspaper reproduction techniques, incorporating those stylistic elements.
- Career Output: Created over 5,000 paintings, prints, drawings, sculptures, and other objects.
Lichtenstein's Drowning Girl
- Depiction: An image of a girl drowning, depicted dispassionately with a comical quote.
- Artistic Goal: Lichtenstein aimed to create art where one image could substitute for another.
- Composition: Juxtaposed planes and tight dots against planes of vibrant colors.
- Ben-Day Dots: Dots are a characteristic trademark, derived from commercial printing techniques.
- Inspiration: Inspired by Hokusai's woodblock print from the late Edo period.
- Influence: Evident in the subject matter and the contour lines of the waves, suggesting movement.
- Lichtenstein's Definition of Pop Art:
- Quote: "I don't know. The use of commercial art as a subject matter in painting, I suppose. It was hard to get a painting that was despicable enough so that no one would hang it. Everybody was hanging everything."
- It was almost acceptable to hang a dripping paint rag. Everybody was accustomed to this. The one thing everyone hated was commercial art. Apparently, they didn't hate that enough either."
Tom Wesselmann
- Style: Strongly figurative, featuring representations of the female nude, still life, and landscape painting in the style of pop art.
- Series: Completed a series titled The Great American Nude.
- Content: Combined erotic depictions of the female figure with references from art history and popular culture.
- Provocative Nature:
- The nudes are provocative, emphasizing areas of erotic interest (lips, tan lines, breasts, and pubic region).
- Facial features are not articulated.
- Commodity: The female figure becomes a commodity, seductive and depersonalized, resembling a page of advertising.
Claes Oldenburg
- Background: Originally from Sweden, moved to New York in 1956.
- Fascination: Became fascinated with street life elements: store windows, graffiti, advertisements, and trash.
- New York: During this period, New York was a nucleus of the Western art world with a burgeoning art culture.
The Store
- Creation: In 1961, created The Store, a collection of painted plaster copies of food, clothing, jewelry, and other items.
- Setup: Rented an actual storefront to stock his constructions and sell his work.
- Offerings: Included sculptures of undergarments, slices of blueberry pie, and other pastries made out of painted plaster.
- Promotion: Created business cards, stationery, and posters to advertise the storefront.
- Significance: Considered an important milestone in pop art.
- Themes: Represented his interest in the intersection of artistic production, self-promotion, and the commodification of art.
Claes Oldenburg's Floor Cake
- Known For: Best known for his soft sculptures of common everyday objects, such as the cake scene.
- Happenings: Created objects specifically for his happenings, often giant objects made of cloth and stuffed with paper or rags.
- Later Pieces: Retained much of the same style and subjects of his earlier career involving soft sculpture.
- Public Sculpture: Manifested in public sculptures, like those found in sculpture parks.
Wayne Thiebaud
- Famous For: Known for his colorful paintings of food, including cakes, pies, pastries, and American classics like hot dogs.
- Background: Worked as a graphic designer and cartoonist before becoming a fine artist in the 1950s.
- Nostalgia: His work evokes a distinctly American nostalgia, utilizing subjects typical of popular culture.
- Style: Though his subject matter is derived from commercial imagery, his style is more painterly with thick, gestural brushwork.
- Serial Repetition: Like Warhol, Thiebaud's work uses serial repetition.
Thiebaud's Boston Creams
- Modern Still Life: Uses synthetic and pastel hues to modernize the still life genre through a depiction of modern sugary foods that embody the age of mass consumption.
- Light and Shadow: His portrayal of light and shadow seems complex given the simplicity of the subject and overall composition.
- Influences: His work draws upon early pop art and the tradition of still life painting.
Jim Nutt and the Chicago Imagists
- Jim Nutt: Member of the Hairy Who, a group of six Chicago artists who exhibited together in the mid-1960s.
- Context: At the time, the art world was dominated by NYC and LA.
- Lack of Opportunities: Limited exhibition venues and opportunities in cities like Chicago.
The Hairy Who
- Members: Jim Falconer, Art Green, Gladys Nilsson, Jim Nutt, Suellen Rocca, and Karl Wirsum.
- Background: Recent graduates of the School of the Art Institute in Chicago.
- Style: Predominantly figurative, influenced by surrealism and expressionism.
- Influences: Utilized advertisements, comics, posters, and sales catalogs.
- Characteristics: Called ambiguous, provocative, and strategic.
- Exploration: Explored progressive ideas challenging notions of gender, sexuality, social mores, standards, beauty, nostalgia, and obsolescence.
Nutt's Miss Sue Port
- Depiction: Depicts a grotesque and highly sexualized figure.
- Purpose: Not a satire of ideal feminine beauty but a subversive parody of popular art that places women as sexual objects.
- Exaggeration: The genitalia is highly exaggerated and adorned with the words shiny hair.
- Deconstruction: Deconstructs the cosmopolitan ideal of beauty.
- Spatial Arrangement: Utilizes overlapping rather than perspective.
- Production: Done on the reverse side of plexiglass, with the finished smooth side turned toward the viewer, eliminating surface texture.
- Aesthetic: Has an almost machine-like rendering.
Nutt's Missy Knows
- Style: Another example of his work during this period, making use of the same style and compositional elements.
- Humor: The title is a pun, meant to be humorous and subversive.
- Cartoonish Element: The cartoonish light beam across her eyes references cinema.
- Deconstruction: Deconstructs ideals of feminine beauty found in advertising and popular films.
Postmodernism
- Definition: Not a style but a cultural phenomenon and a paradigm shift.
- Origins: Started in architecture because architects were steeped in modernist values.
- Challenge: Challenges us to question what we consider known and objective.
Modernism vs. Postmodernism
- Modernism:
- Cultural Progress: Notion that newer is better.
- Rational Certainty: Belief in and pursuit of objective truth.
- Neutrality: Considered enlightened and emphasized.
- Western Superiority: Belief in Western superiority.
- Cultural Hierarchies: Respect for high versus low art (e.g., classical music superior to popular music).
- Postmodernism:
- Revised History: History seen as repetitive, not progressive.
- Rejection: Rejects modernist certainties and deconstructs the idea of a single universal truth.
- Ideological Agendas: Emphasis on identifying hidden agendas in any assertion or creation.
- Cultural Validity: Recognizes the validity of other cultural traditions, sometimes resulting in relativism.
- Elimination: Eliminates the distinction between high and low culture.
Jean Baudrillard
- Simulacra and Simulation: Discusses the successive stages of the image:
- Reflection: The image is a reflection of a basic reality.
- Masking: It masks and perverts a basic reality.
- Absence: It masks the absence of any basic reality.
- Simulation: It bears no relationship to any reality whatsoever and becomes its own pure simulation.
- Questioning Reality: Calls the notion of reality into question.
- Art as Reflection: Art reflects experiences in the physical world but is understood as a world of reflections, images, and representations.
- Deconstruction: Deconstructs our conception of reality and, in a sense, becomes more real than reality itself.
- Transformation: The very nature of reality is transformed under contemporary cultural conditions.
- Fundamental Text: Considered one of the fundamental texts of postmodern theory.
- Images Referencing Themselves: A notion of images that can refer only to themselves, copies of copies without any original.
Richard Prince
- Untitled Cowboy: From the Pictures Generation.
- Pictures Generation:
- Loose affiliation of artists influenced by conceptual and pop art.
- Utilized appropriation and montage to reveal the constructed nature of images.
- Revealing Agendas: Revealing the ideological underpinnings and agenda behind an image.
- Experimentation: Experimented with various media, including photography and film.
- Deconstruction: Deconstructed cultural tropes and stereotypes found in popular imagery.
- Challenging Notions: Challenged notions of individuality and authorship by reworking well-known images, making the movement an important part of postmodernism.
- Social Criticism: Expanded notions of art to include social criticism for viewers saturated with mass media.
- Members: Included Cindy Sherman and Barbara Kruger.
Douglas Crimp
- The Picture's Generation Exhibition: Assembled under art historian and curator Douglas Crimp.
- Definition: Defined as a practice of appropriation and opposition to formalist concerns of modernism.
- Rejection: Turned away from the idea of high versus low culture and canonical definitions of art.
- Appropriation: Often appropriated cliches from advertising and magazines.
Prince's Untitled Cowboy
- Appealing Aesthetic: Meant to appeal in a way not typical of the sophistication in a gallery, challenging notions of high versus low art.
- Marlboro Man: Appropriates the Marlboro Man, the 1950s advertising mascot, to excite visual pleasure and exude macho allure.
- Echoes: Echoes early 20th-century interest in the American West found in film, television, music, and literature.
- Decontextualization: Isolated from advertisement text, recontextualized as fine art.
Prince's New Portraits
- Appropriation: Appropriates images from an Instagram feed with comments and places them in a gallery.
- Social Media as Art: These become fine art taken directly from his Instagram feed.
- Comparison: Compares Instagram to advertising.
- Commodity: On Instagram, products and people position themselves as products.
- Deconstruction: Deconstructs and recontextualizes social media (traditionally considered low art) in a fine art environment to deconstruct those hierarchies and the commodity itself.
Sherrie Levine
- Untitled (President): Created a series of fashionable women and sentimental mother and child groups to fit in silhouettes of US Presidents.
- Source: Images taken from women's magazines that shaped women's ideas of femininity and popular cultural images of femininity.
- Juxtaposition: Places these within masculine portraits of presidents.
- Connection: Establishes an intimate connection between the conventions of domestic life and established forms of government.
- Social Myths: Highlights that US society was built on myths of gender, with women as mothers and images of beauty, while men served as leaders.
- Deconstruction: Deconstructs this typical social standard.
Levine's After Walker Evans
- Inspiration: Inspired by early work being labeled derivative of other artists, tackling the issue of originality.
- Beyond Appropriation: Goes beyond what Duchamp, Rauschenberg, or Warhol did in their appropriations.
- Critique: Complete appropriation to critique the core tenet of modernism—the idea of originality.
- Questioning Genius: Questions the artist as divinely inspired genius.
- Photographing a Photograph: Photographs an icon of photography illustrating Southern poverty during the Great Depression.
- Identical Image: Her image is almost indistinguishable from the actual photo, questioning our idea of originality.
- Deconstructing Reality: Deconstructs the idea of photographic truth and the depiction of reality.
- Recording Reality: While Evans recorded real life, she is just recording the recording.
Duane Hanson
- Museum Guard: Created hyperrealistic sculptures of working-class American citizens.
- Detail: Meticulous in detail, including fingernails, veins, and blemishes.
- Model: The head on the guard was modeled on his wife's uncle.
- Realism: Captures individual hairs and age spots.
- Context: Created to blend into the museum context, emphasizing ordinariness as opposed to classical sculpture's heroic nature.
Hanson's Old Couple on a Bench
- Hyperrealism: Another example of hyperrealistic sculpture.
- Interest: Focused on American every-people.
- Simulated Reality: The difficulty of distinguishing reality from simulated reality.
- Origin: A copy of which there is no original.
- Hyper Real: They have no origin in reality but look so realistic that they are hyperreal.
Patricia Piccinini
- Young Family: Creates creatures that are unsettling and strange, yet not threatening.
- Hybrid: Hybrid, wrinkly, half-human, half-pig creatures.
- Investigation: Investigates the potential rise of new and troubling developments in biotechnology and genetic manipulation.
- Potential: Concerns about creating human-animal hybrids to harvest organs.
- Empathy: Depicts them vulnerably, eliciting our empathy.
Commodity Art
- Dissolving Hierarchies: Within postmodernism, the hierarchies of high versus low art are dissolved.
- Rejection: Rejects the idea that one form of cultural activity is superior to another.
- Mixing: Complete mixing of high and low culture.
Amy Capilazo
- Art as Asset: According to Amy Capilazo (Christie's), new collectors see contemporary art as an asset to borrow against or trade on and defer capital gains taxes.
- Securities Market: Regards the art market as a branch of the securities market.
Reaganomics
- Economic Plan: During the 1980s with the Reagan administration's trickle-down economics.
- Tax Cuts: Increase in tax cuts for the wealthy.
- Deregulation: Decrease in regulations to enable unrestricted free market activity.
Defining Commodity Art
- Neo Pop: Also called neo-pop due to its resurgence of interest and qualities that define that movement.
- Objects and Images: Reflects objects and images from popular culture and consumer goods.
- Emphasis: Less emphasis on expressionism of individual artists.
- Blurring Boundaries: Blurring of high and low culture.
- Intangible Satisfactions: The term commodity references consumer goods and the capitalist system and intangible satisfactions relating to status or sentiment.
- Not Just Consumption: It's also about possession and status symbols.
- Simulation: Rather than referencing earlier styles, postmodern artists embraced the notion of simulation, with art simulating the world of commodities.
- Blurred Distinction: To the point of losing sight of where one ends and the other begins, so that there is a blurring of the distinction of what is a commodity versus what is art.
Jeff Koons
- Background: Son of a furniture dealer, designer, and decorator.
- Early Art: Created replicas of old master paintings in his father's shop.
- Influences: Drawing upon Duchamp's readymades and also pop art.
- Admiration: Admired Dali and surrealism.
- Stock Trading: Worked selling stocks and mutual funds.
Koons' New Shelton Wet/Dry Doubledecker
- Finance: Used his earnings from the first investors corporation to finance his art.
- Display: Presented brand-new vacuum cleaners in plexiglass illuminated by fluorescent lighting.
- Aesthetic: Resembled a cleaning supply store conceived by a minimalist sculptor.
- Venue: Placed in the window of the New Museum in SoHo, blending into merchandise displays of surrounding stores.
- Art and Commerce: Art and commerce that appeared virtually identical.
- Statement: Koons stated that vacuums are anthropomorphic breathing machines that explore issues of personality, selfhood, and the psychological state tied to immortality and compared them to the Virgin Mary.
Koons' Balloon Dog & Michael Jackson and Bubbles
- Kitsch Sculptures: Displayed in giant porcelain figures that allude to cheap collectible figurines.
- Michael Jackson and Bubbles: Presents Michael Jackson and his pet monkey almost like religious icons from the Renaissance.
- Comparison: Compares religious zeal with modern celebrity worship.
- Statement: Koons stated that he wanted to create him in a very godlike icon manner, but he always liked the radicality of Michael Jackson, that he would do absolutely anything that was necessary to communicate with the people.
Hank Willis Thomas
- Branded Head: Creates dialogue around the stereotypical images of African Americans that the media uses to exploit and make profit on in film, TV, and ads for consumer products.
- Personal Connection: Thomas' cousin and best friend was murdered during a robbery in Philadelphia because robbers wanted to take a gold chain worn by a friend.
- Broader Context: During the 1980s and 1990s, young Black men were often killed over Michael Jordan sneakers seen as status symbols.
- Connection to Slavery: Connects slavery branding to show ownership.
- Consumerism: Argues that contemporary culture emphasizes African Americans branding themselves with consumer goods.
Takashi Murakami and Otaku Culture
- Miss Ko2: Murakami's work is strongly critical of Western intervention.
- Background: Raised by parents who experienced the nuclear bombings in Japan and the heavy military sanctions after World War II.
- Cynicism: Communicates deep cynicism toward the West and the global art market.
- Intervention Effects: Considers Japan's contemporary obsession with cuteness, youthful innocence, and fetish to be a product of US interventions that began with the bomb.
- Revenge: Some assert that Murakami considers his thrusting of this into US culture to be a form of revenge.
- Blurring Distinctions: Blurs distinctions between high and low art.
- Otaku Culture: Obsession with manga, anime, and cuteness aesthetic derived from kawaii (cuteness).
- Characters: Anime-inspired characters with voluptuous breasts, razor-sharp teeth, and sickeningly cute smiling daisies.
Murakami's Miss Ko2
- First Large-Scale Sculpture: The first large-scale otaku-inspired sculpture he created.
- Meaning of Ko: Ko means child, young woman, or young geisha in Japanese and is associated with a restaurant server.
- Dress: Based on the uniforms from Anna Miller's, a popular hangout in Tokyo's otaku scene.
- Intensification: The paint intensifies the hypersexuality and artificiality of the sculpture.
- Interpretation: Represents the ideal Japanese woman as a doll or puppet.
Murakami's Tan Tan Bo
- Tan Tan Bo Puking aka Jiro Tan: Murakami's style draws inspiration from manga and anime, as well as the bold patterns of ukiyo-e Japanese woodblock prints from the Edo period.
- Superflat: Refers to his brightly colored animated paintings as superflat.
- Merging: Superflat merges Japanese tradition with contemporary art forms and flattens art and commerce to combine Japan's history with pop culture.
- Elimination: His work eliminates the distinction between fine art and popular culture.
- Exploration: Explores Japan's fascination with fantasy by creating a universe with colorful characters while alluding to the darker aspects of otaku culture.
- Juxtaposition: Juxtaposes kawaii (adorably cute) elements against the grotesque, as seen in the deranged cartoon vomiting across the composition.
Murakami's 727
- Triptych: In the center, Murakami's avatar named Mr. DOB.
- Features: Open mouth reveals razor-sharp teeth, and multiple eyes gaze maniacally.
- Inspiration: Japanese anime is known for cartoon characters with unusually large eyes, and he emphasizes that here.
- Creation: Mr. DOB was created by Murakami in 1993.
- Meaning: Derived from the Japanese slang term dobozite, which roughly translates to why.
- Interpretation: The maniacal smile of Mr. DOB can be understood as Murakami's laughing stance towards the art world itself and towards the West.
- Reference: 727 references the Boeing American plane that flew over his childhood home en route to military bases.
- US Presence: The title references the US presence in post-World War II Japan.
- Wave: The wave Mr. DOB is riding references the 19th-century Japanese woodblock artist Hokusai.
- Background: The abstract background references the Japanese folding screen.
- Allusion: The aesthetic and three panels allude to the folding screen.
- Goal: Murakami began the Mr. DOB series to create a great icon of the contemporary art world comparable to Mickey Mouse or Hello Kitty.
Murakami's I Love Superflat
- Commodification: The commodification of art.
- Commercial Designs: The designs have become extremely commercial.
- Louis Vuitton Feature: They were featured on Louis Vuitton bags.
- Reappropriation: Epitomizes the reappropriation of Western iconography.
- Commentary: A commentary and play upon and also leveraging the Western art market.
Damien Hirst
- For the Love of God: A strategy of creating appalling artwork centered on rotten corpses for sky-high prices.
- Memento Mori: A late 20th-century take on memento mori, reminders of death, found throughout European art history.
- Platinum Skull: A platinum skull studded with hundreds of diamonds.
- Initial Failure: Initially seemed like his plan to create this exorbitantly expensive piece would fail.
- Consortium Purchase: However, at the last minute, an anonymous consortium of investors purchased the piece.
- Hirst's Involvement: Hirst himself and gallerists were part of the consortium that represent him.
- Market Manipulation: They effectively purchased his own work to increase its speculative value.
- Questioning Prices: Raises questions about astronomically inflated prices of art on the contemporary art market.
- Market Impact: Are artists like Hirst and Koons commendable for manipulating markets in their favor, or are they exacerbating the situation and making it more difficult for other artists?
- Value Questions: Impacts how we look at art and its value.
Maurizio Cattelan
- Artist's Statement: \"I'm not trying to overthrow an institution or question a structure of power. I'm neither that ambitious nor that naive. I'm only trying to find a degree of freedom. I just think that you can create new margins for freedom in every context.\"
- Known For: Dark humor, satire, and for confronting and questioning the art market.
- Rebellious Identity: His seemingly rebellious artist identity has often led to a reversal of the traditional relationships between an artist and their representing gallery.
Cattelan's A Perfect Day
- Installation: A daylong installation where Cattelan adhered his gallerist, Massimo de Carlo, to his gallery wall in Milan with electrical tape.
- Submission: Di Carlo was suspended, unable to move, and at the complete mercy of Cattelan.
- Interpretation: Communicates Cattelan's personal viewpoint of feeling entrapped by the pressures of the gallery system and the art market.
- Power Subversion: He holds the director in his power rather than the situation being reversed.
- Meaning: Compared to Andy Warhol's 1967 pop art fruit.
- Symbol: A symbol of global trade, a double entendre, and a classical device for humor.
- Exhibition: First on display at Art Basel in Miami in 2019.
- Performance Art: Performance artist David Datuna ate the banana, calling the act Hungry Artist, showing the absurdity of a banana worth more than \$100,000.
- NFT Collaboration: Later teamed with Dole Sunshine Company to sell fruit-themed NFTs, raising awareness about food insecurity and malnutrition while fundraising for the Boys and Girls Club of America.
- Replaced Banana: The banana for Comedian was eaten again recently. Cattelan stated the art was in the idea and not the banana itself, which is regularly replaced during any exhibition.