1. Social Policy Intro
Social Policy Overview
Introduction
Dr. John McNamara presents insights into Social Policy.
Key Questions
What is Social Policy?
What is it designed to achieve?
Who makes Social Policy and what is the process?
What influences the process of making Social Policy?
Defining Social Policy
General Definition of Policy
Policy: A plan of action; signifies formal decisions made by government bodies.
Public policy is viewed as official decisions governing actions.
Reference: Heywood (2013)
Government Policy Elements
Intentions: Goals set by the government.
Actions: Implementation of policies.
Results: Outcomes arising from these actions.
These elements are interconnected through formalized bureaucratic processes.
Examples of Social Policy
Notable Policies
GI Bill (United States, 1944)
NHS (UK, 1948)
Children’s Allowance (Ireland, 1944)
Free Secondary Education (Ireland, 1967)
Evaluation Criteria
Reasoning: Justification for the policy.
Origin: Historical context.
Proposal: Initial plans laid out.
Actions: Steps taken to implement.
Results: Intended outcomes.
Unforeseen Results: Unexpected consequences.
Continued Effectiveness: Long-term appraisal.
Evolution: Changes over time.
Specifics of Social Policy
Government Responsibility
Responsibility of government acknowledged globally (Lavalette & Pratt, 1997).
Modifications in market forces' operations affect health, housing, education, and social services.
Studying Social Policy
Focus Areas
Analysis of social needs and scarcity in human organization.
Traditionally associated with social services or welfare systems outside market influences (Titmuss in Lavalette & Pratt, 1997).
Objectives of Social Policy
Aims
Address societal inequalities.
Compensate for market failures in correcting inequalities.
Ensure equal opportunity across society.
Enhance societal wellbeing and reduce disparities in health, housing, and education.
Contextual Analysis
Socio-economic Factors
Class distinctions affect morbidity and mortality, indicating substantial social and economic influences (Lesley Doyal).
Reference to a 1993 UK study highlighting higher sickness rates among elderly unskilled workers compared to professionals.
Health Factors
Housing Quality: Impacts societal health.
Access to Healthcare: Essential for wellbeing.
Knowledge and Lifestyle: Influence health outcomes.
Policy Responses: Social housing, public awareness initiatives, health education programs.
Social Protection
Purpose and Scope
Aims to tackle inequality and imbalance through social security and welfare.
Encompasses various societal needs: unemployment, health issues, old age, and insufficient income.
Europe witnessing growth in GDP spending on Social Protection from 10% in the 1950s to 19.5% in 2014 (Considine & Dukelow).
Functionality of Social Protection
Financial Support
Designed to cover financial needs amid challenging circumstances.
Encompasses community values like social justice and support for vulnerable populations.
Democracy & Rights Evolution
Electoral Developments
Historical shifts in voting rights and franchise in Britain and Ireland from 1780 to 1918.
Significant events include the Peterloo Massacre and various Reform Acts enhancing voting accessibility.
19th Century Developments
Social Transformations
Post-French Revolution socio-political changes leading to radical revolutions (1848).
Karl Marx’s influence through the Communist Manifesto (1848), emphasizing class struggle and rights.
Bismarck’s welfare state emergence in Germany during radicalization efforts.
Welfare State Origins
Key Figures
Otto von Bismarck: Established early welfare measures in Germany.
David Lloyd George: Introduced social reforms in Britain (1908-1915).
Historical Context
Focus on trade unions and labor movements enhancing worker rights in the late 19th century.
Attention to improving working and living conditions.
Historical Surveys on Poverty
Pioneering Studies
Charles Booth and Seebohm Rowntree conducted significant surveys revealing high poverty rates (25%-30% in urban areas).
Their work prompted informed public discussions regarding poverty.
Fabian Society
Advocacy for Change
Members included prominent figures; focus on tackling poverty incrementally through social policy.
Indirectly led to the establishment of the British Labour Party in 1900.
Expansion of Welfare Measures
Bismarck's Strategies
Social insurance measures introduced (illness, unemployment, accident, and old age).
Similar programs appeared in other countries like Sweden, Denmark, and New Zealand through the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
Liberal Reforms in Britain and Ireland (1906-1911)
Policy Changes
Comprehensive reforms based on poverty surveys led to the introduction of school meals, Old Age Pension Act, and Labour Exchanges.
The National Insurance Act in 1911 reinforced various worker protections.
Mid 20th Century Developments
Post-WWII Welfare State
Influential figures: FDR’s New Deal, John Maynard Keynes, William Beveridge.
Beveridge Report (1942) stresses societal issues surrounding want, disease, ignorance, squalor, and idleness; laid groundwork for modern welfare.
Myths & Perceptions of Welfare
Public Narratives
Discussion about the stigmatization of welfare recipients and the perceptions of welfare cheats.
Media portrayals shaping societal views on social welfare.
Media’s Influence on Social Protection
Media Narratives
Examination of how media narratives contribute to negative portrayals of social benefits and their recipients.
Social Policy Makers
Key Stakeholders
Various actors contribute to the creation of Social Policy, including government agencies, stakeholders, and the community.
Influencing Factors of Social Policy Process
Key Influences
Ideology: Shaping beliefs about social responsibility.
Pragmatism: Practical considerations in policy development.
Goals: Desired outcomes that guide the policy-making process.