1. Social Policy Intro

Social Policy Overview

Introduction

  • Dr. John McNamara presents insights into Social Policy.

Key Questions

  • What is Social Policy?

  • What is it designed to achieve?

  • Who makes Social Policy and what is the process?

  • What influences the process of making Social Policy?

Defining Social Policy

General Definition of Policy

  • Policy: A plan of action; signifies formal decisions made by government bodies.

  • Public policy is viewed as official decisions governing actions.

  • Reference: Heywood (2013)

Government Policy Elements

  • Intentions: Goals set by the government.

  • Actions: Implementation of policies.

  • Results: Outcomes arising from these actions.

  • These elements are interconnected through formalized bureaucratic processes.

Examples of Social Policy

Notable Policies

  • GI Bill (United States, 1944)

  • NHS (UK, 1948)

  • Children’s Allowance (Ireland, 1944)

  • Free Secondary Education (Ireland, 1967)

Evaluation Criteria

  • Reasoning: Justification for the policy.

  • Origin: Historical context.

  • Proposal: Initial plans laid out.

  • Actions: Steps taken to implement.

  • Results: Intended outcomes.

  • Unforeseen Results: Unexpected consequences.

  • Continued Effectiveness: Long-term appraisal.

  • Evolution: Changes over time.

Specifics of Social Policy

Government Responsibility

  • Responsibility of government acknowledged globally (Lavalette & Pratt, 1997).

  • Modifications in market forces' operations affect health, housing, education, and social services.

Studying Social Policy

Focus Areas

  • Analysis of social needs and scarcity in human organization.

  • Traditionally associated with social services or welfare systems outside market influences (Titmuss in Lavalette & Pratt, 1997).

Objectives of Social Policy

Aims

  • Address societal inequalities.

  • Compensate for market failures in correcting inequalities.

  • Ensure equal opportunity across society.

  • Enhance societal wellbeing and reduce disparities in health, housing, and education.

Contextual Analysis

Socio-economic Factors

  • Class distinctions affect morbidity and mortality, indicating substantial social and economic influences (Lesley Doyal).

  • Reference to a 1993 UK study highlighting higher sickness rates among elderly unskilled workers compared to professionals.

Health Factors

  • Housing Quality: Impacts societal health.

  • Access to Healthcare: Essential for wellbeing.

  • Knowledge and Lifestyle: Influence health outcomes.

  • Policy Responses: Social housing, public awareness initiatives, health education programs.

Social Protection

Purpose and Scope

  • Aims to tackle inequality and imbalance through social security and welfare.

  • Encompasses various societal needs: unemployment, health issues, old age, and insufficient income.

  • Europe witnessing growth in GDP spending on Social Protection from 10% in the 1950s to 19.5% in 2014 (Considine & Dukelow).

Functionality of Social Protection

Financial Support

  • Designed to cover financial needs amid challenging circumstances.

  • Encompasses community values like social justice and support for vulnerable populations.

Democracy & Rights Evolution

Electoral Developments

  • Historical shifts in voting rights and franchise in Britain and Ireland from 1780 to 1918.

  • Significant events include the Peterloo Massacre and various Reform Acts enhancing voting accessibility.

19th Century Developments

Social Transformations

  • Post-French Revolution socio-political changes leading to radical revolutions (1848).

  • Karl Marx’s influence through the Communist Manifesto (1848), emphasizing class struggle and rights.

  • Bismarck’s welfare state emergence in Germany during radicalization efforts.

Welfare State Origins

Key Figures

  • Otto von Bismarck: Established early welfare measures in Germany.

  • David Lloyd George: Introduced social reforms in Britain (1908-1915).

Historical Context

  • Focus on trade unions and labor movements enhancing worker rights in the late 19th century.

  • Attention to improving working and living conditions.

Historical Surveys on Poverty

Pioneering Studies

  • Charles Booth and Seebohm Rowntree conducted significant surveys revealing high poverty rates (25%-30% in urban areas).

  • Their work prompted informed public discussions regarding poverty.

Fabian Society

Advocacy for Change

  • Members included prominent figures; focus on tackling poverty incrementally through social policy.

  • Indirectly led to the establishment of the British Labour Party in 1900.

Expansion of Welfare Measures

Bismarck's Strategies

  • Social insurance measures introduced (illness, unemployment, accident, and old age).

  • Similar programs appeared in other countries like Sweden, Denmark, and New Zealand through the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Liberal Reforms in Britain and Ireland (1906-1911)

Policy Changes

  • Comprehensive reforms based on poverty surveys led to the introduction of school meals, Old Age Pension Act, and Labour Exchanges.

  • The National Insurance Act in 1911 reinforced various worker protections.

Mid 20th Century Developments

Post-WWII Welfare State

  • Influential figures: FDR’s New Deal, John Maynard Keynes, William Beveridge.

  • Beveridge Report (1942) stresses societal issues surrounding want, disease, ignorance, squalor, and idleness; laid groundwork for modern welfare.

Myths & Perceptions of Welfare

Public Narratives

  • Discussion about the stigmatization of welfare recipients and the perceptions of welfare cheats.

  • Media portrayals shaping societal views on social welfare.

Media’s Influence on Social Protection

Media Narratives

  • Examination of how media narratives contribute to negative portrayals of social benefits and their recipients.

Social Policy Makers

Key Stakeholders

  • Various actors contribute to the creation of Social Policy, including government agencies, stakeholders, and the community.

Influencing Factors of Social Policy Process

Key Influences

  • Ideology: Shaping beliefs about social responsibility.

  • Pragmatism: Practical considerations in policy development.

  • Goals: Desired outcomes that guide the policy-making process.