New Deal

Hoover's Economic Response

  • Imposition of Tariffs:

    • In 1930, Hoover imposed tariffs on imported agricultural goods.
    • Aim: To raise agricultural prices and protect American industries.
    • Outcome: Tariff did not successfully raise prices for agricultural goods due to already decreased American purchasing power; led to inflation for imported goods.
  • Established Organizations:

    • Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC):
    • Provided loans to failing businesses to stabilize the economy.
    • Federal Home Loan Bank System:
    • Aimed at providing relief to homeowners facing foreclosure.
  • Infrastructure Funding:

    • Earmarked $2 billion for infrastructure projects.
    • No direct relief for rising unemployment.

Franklin Delano Roosevelt and the New Deal

  • Introduction to FDR:

    • A Democrat who responded to the Great Depression with reforms known as the New Deal.
  • Two Phases of the New Deal:

    • First New Deal: Focused on economic planning and regulation rather than dismantling large corporations.
    • Rationale: Breaking up big businesses would lead to job losses during fragile economic times.
  • Key Components of the First New Deal:

    • National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA):

    • Established the National Recovery Administration (NRA).

    • Goals: Regulate production, working conditions, prices—a move away from unrestrained competition.

    • Controversy: Favoritism towards large companies in writing regulatory codes; minimal support for unions.

    • Emergency Banking Act:

    • Funded vulnerable banks and established the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) for deposit insurance.

    • Glass-Steagall Act:

    • Prevented banks from buying/selling stocks, protecting depositor assets.


Depression-Era Challenges

  • The Dust Bowl:

    • Environmental disaster led to severe agricultural decline exacerbating economic issues.
    • Caused by drought and mechanized farming techniques leading to soil erosion.
  • Government's Job Creation Efforts:

    • Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC):
    • Provided jobs in natural resource conservation.
    • Public Works Administration (PWA):
    • Contracted public works, enhancing infrastructure.
    • Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA):
    • Set production quotas to manage agricultural supply and stabilize prices.
    • Farmers incentivized not to use all land through subsidies.

Social & Labor Organizations

  • Rise of New Labor Movements:

    • Formation of the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO):
    • Umbrella organization of unions that advocated for workers' rights.
    • Engaged in collective bargaining with big companies.
  • Union Dynamics:

    • CIO differed from the older American Federation of Labor (AFL):
    • CIO accepted government intervention in labor issues, while AFL favored minimal government involvement.

The Second New Deal

  • Shift in Focus:

    • Transitioned from planning and regulation to redistribution of wealth.
  • Social Security Act:

    • Introduced unemployment insurance, pensions for the elderly, and aid to the disabled.
    • Funded through federal tax revenue and paychecks, creating a substantial government bureaucracy.
  • Consequences of the New Deal:

    • Redefinition of freedom from a focus on individual contracts to ensuring a base standard of living for all citizens.
    • Emergence of a significant leftist political movement influenced by economic equity concerns.

New Deal Limitations and Outcomes

  • Exclusions in Social Security:

    • Domestic workers and agricultural workers often excluded, leading to significant gaps in coverage, particularly affecting women and minorities.
    • Dependency on welfare programs created stigmas against marginalized communities.
  • Political Backlash:

    • Conservative Supreme Court deemed key elements of the New Deal, like the NRA, unconstitutional.
    • Roosevelt's response was an attempt at court packing to ensure favorable rulings for New Deal programs.
  • Final Note on the Great Depression:

    • Unemployment remained high (over 15%) until World War II spurred economic recovery through wartime production efforts.