Police and Human Rights
Introduction to Risk Society and Data Double
Concepts of Risk Society
The application of actuarial and database logics aimed at predicting human actions.
These models involve understanding actions as predictable and ultimately actionable.
Creation of Data Double
Definition: A data double is an electronic profile compiled from personal data fragments of an individual.
It holds increasing social significance as it is used for assessments and judgments in various contexts.
Examples: National security, local policing.
Human Rights Consideration
Discussion on whether data doubles possess human rights: Most respond negatively.
Surveillance and Digital Footprint
Surveillance Context
Individuals are increasingly surveyed online, with metadata captured from every online action (also known as digital footprint).
Engagement in sharing personal digital experiences regarding surveillance is discouraged.
Extraction of Metadata
Metadata is drawn from various online activities to create risk profiles aimed at preempting crime.
Application of Risk Profiles
Contemporary Examples
Reference to the U.S. government using social media profiles to identify potential risks associated with specific individuals, such as immigrants or those critical of authority.
Implications of Data Double
Social Sorting and Criminalization
Data doubles result in social sorting where marginalized individuals are monitored and subjected to preemptive policing.
CCTV Camera Usage
Defined by John Fiske as a technology often targeting racialized communities, reinforcing negative stereotypes about 'legitimate' versus 'illegitimate' users of space.
Crime Prevention Insights
Actuarial Logic vs. Precautionary Logic
Crime prevention strategies often influenced by public fear and anxiety rather than purely risk assessments.
Surveillance as a Social Sorting Mechanism
Racialized individuals are disproportionately scrutinized through technologies and policing methods that categorize them as higher risk.
Historical Context and Current Practices of Policing
Colonial Policing
Historical emergence from British policing models aimed at controlling Indigenous populations and enforcing social order in favor of colonial interests.
Modern Policing Strategies
Transition towards neoliberal approaches in policing, emphasizing order maintenance for capitalist interests over community safety and rights.
Human Rights Violations in Policing
Instances of Police Misconduct
Examples include the deaths of individuals such as Trayvon Martin and George Floyd, illustrating systemic racial bias in policing practices.
Highlighting the challenges faced by marginalized communities in their interactions with law enforcement.
Social Crime Prevention Alternatives
UN Guidelines on Crime Prevention
Advocating for crime prevention methods that focus on social development, addressing the root causes of crime rather than punitive measures.
Examples of Effective Strategies
Enhanced access to education, jobs, housing, and healthcare as preventative measures against crime.
Challenges to Traditional Policing Models
Policing as a Coercive Force
Resisting societal and community cooperation based on fear leads to abuses of power.
Call for Reforms
Campaign Zero's recommendations for reforming police practices include limiting police interventions and improving accountability.
The Case of the G20 Summit
Police Violence and Rights Violations
Events at the 2010 G20 Summit in Toronto illustrate the criminalization of dissent, with mass arrests and suppression of free speech.
Kettling Tactics Used
Kettling involved surrounding and detaining protesters unlawfully, often without just cause, violating their rights to free expression and association.
Moving Towards a Human Rights-Based Model of Crime Prevention
Alternative Approaches Advocated
Emphasis on reducing police budgets and reallocating funds to community services for long-term crime prevention.
Conclusion: The Need for systemic Change in Policing
Towards a More Just Society
Highlighting the necessity of viewing police reform through a human rights lens, addressing both the systemic issues of policing and societal inequalities.