Police and Human Rights

Introduction to Risk Society and Data Double

  • Concepts of Risk Society

    • The application of actuarial and database logics aimed at predicting human actions.

    • These models involve understanding actions as predictable and ultimately actionable.

  • Creation of Data Double

    • Definition: A data double is an electronic profile compiled from personal data fragments of an individual.

    • It holds increasing social significance as it is used for assessments and judgments in various contexts.

    • Examples: National security, local policing.

  • Human Rights Consideration

    • Discussion on whether data doubles possess human rights: Most respond negatively.

Surveillance and Digital Footprint

  • Surveillance Context

    • Individuals are increasingly surveyed online, with metadata captured from every online action (also known as digital footprint).

    • Engagement in sharing personal digital experiences regarding surveillance is discouraged.

  • Extraction of Metadata

    • Metadata is drawn from various online activities to create risk profiles aimed at preempting crime.

Application of Risk Profiles

  • Contemporary Examples

    • Reference to the U.S. government using social media profiles to identify potential risks associated with specific individuals, such as immigrants or those critical of authority.

Implications of Data Double

  • Social Sorting and Criminalization

    • Data doubles result in social sorting where marginalized individuals are monitored and subjected to preemptive policing.

    • CCTV Camera Usage

    • Defined by John Fiske as a technology often targeting racialized communities, reinforcing negative stereotypes about 'legitimate' versus 'illegitimate' users of space.

Crime Prevention Insights

  • Actuarial Logic vs. Precautionary Logic

    • Crime prevention strategies often influenced by public fear and anxiety rather than purely risk assessments.

  • Surveillance as a Social Sorting Mechanism

    • Racialized individuals are disproportionately scrutinized through technologies and policing methods that categorize them as higher risk.

Historical Context and Current Practices of Policing

  • Colonial Policing

    • Historical emergence from British policing models aimed at controlling Indigenous populations and enforcing social order in favor of colonial interests.

  • Modern Policing Strategies

    • Transition towards neoliberal approaches in policing, emphasizing order maintenance for capitalist interests over community safety and rights.

Human Rights Violations in Policing

  • Instances of Police Misconduct

    • Examples include the deaths of individuals such as Trayvon Martin and George Floyd, illustrating systemic racial bias in policing practices.

    • Highlighting the challenges faced by marginalized communities in their interactions with law enforcement.

Social Crime Prevention Alternatives

  • UN Guidelines on Crime Prevention

    • Advocating for crime prevention methods that focus on social development, addressing the root causes of crime rather than punitive measures.

  • Examples of Effective Strategies

    • Enhanced access to education, jobs, housing, and healthcare as preventative measures against crime.

Challenges to Traditional Policing Models

  • Policing as a Coercive Force

    • Resisting societal and community cooperation based on fear leads to abuses of power.

  • Call for Reforms

    • Campaign Zero's recommendations for reforming police practices include limiting police interventions and improving accountability.

The Case of the G20 Summit

  • Police Violence and Rights Violations

    • Events at the 2010 G20 Summit in Toronto illustrate the criminalization of dissent, with mass arrests and suppression of free speech.

  • Kettling Tactics Used

    • Kettling involved surrounding and detaining protesters unlawfully, often without just cause, violating their rights to free expression and association.

Moving Towards a Human Rights-Based Model of Crime Prevention

  • Alternative Approaches Advocated

    • Emphasis on reducing police budgets and reallocating funds to community services for long-term crime prevention.

Conclusion: The Need for systemic Change in Policing

  • Towards a More Just Society

    • Highlighting the necessity of viewing police reform through a human rights lens, addressing both the systemic issues of policing and societal inequalities.