march 12th red planet

Guidelines for Reflection Exercises

  • Spend at least 20 minutes on reflections.

  • Be patient with both yourself and the text.

  • Aim to address the text from multiple angles.

  • Increased patience and richness in responses can strengthen grades.

  • Draw as many applications as possible into reflections.

Upcoming Class Changes

  • Discussion of the upcoming Futuran episode from Star Trek.

  • Reflect on the evolution of the Star Trek franchise over time.

  • Further updates will follow regarding this viewing.

Notes on Heinlein’s Works

Key Points to Remember for the Final Exam

  1. Importance of Jim and the Other World

  2. Doc McRae’s philosophy

  3. Concept of the poverty of human understanding in the novel.

Jim and the Other World
  • Jim's interview with the Old Ones is significant.

  • The twist revealing Willis's character as female was initially rejected by publishers.

  • Discussion of gender transitions in Heinlein's work.

  • Perceptions of Jim's interactions with Willis are complex, portraying him as a bumbling servant who lacks dignity.

  • The significance of the roles of Willis and Jim, where Jim becomes less important than he initially perceived.

  • Exploration of anthropocentric views and how they affect Jim’s perception of dignity and respect.

Doc McRae’s Philosophy
  • Quote from Heinlein: “Man does not live by bread alone.”

  • Discussion of anti-materialistic philosophy:

    • Materialism is described as fundamentally implausible.

    • Importance of recognizing non-material aspects of existence.

  • Connection to the idea of Martians and the concept of discorporation in "Stranger in a Strange Land".

The Concepts of Martian Existence

  • Martians have a different understanding of existence, emphasized in clipped dialogue around ghosts.

  • The idea that the old ones are disconnected from material forms, representing a shift towards a more ethereal existence.

  • Reflection of McRae's thoughts against materialism ties into broader sci-fi themes represented in works like Star Wars (Yoda's sayings).

The Poverty of Human Understanding
  • Emphasizes ignorance and acceptance of that ignorance as a path to understanding.

  • McRae's statement on learning about Martians underscores a crucial theme about the limitations of human knowledge.

  • Acceptance of the unknown highlights problems with anthropocentral views in character interactions.

Discussion on Final Exam Preparation

  • Final exam structure similar to midterm, with an essay question included.

  • Importance of drawing on concrete examples from texts to support arguments.

    • Include specific data and elements from works like "2001: A Space Odyssey" and "Childhood's End".

  • Analysis of film elements and their textual counterparts is crucial for strong answers.

Exam Format & Topics to Prepare

Narrative Analysis
  • Evaluate the dialogues between "2001: A Space Odyssey" and "Childhood's End" on human evolution.

  • Study significant moments in the film where themes are illustrated via the monolith:

    • Appearances on the moon, outside Jupiter, and corresponding plot elements.

    • Discuss the overarching idea of humanity's insufficiency.

  • Inclusion of terminology like "theosis" or "apotheosis" to convey spiritual themes in narratives.

Reversal Tropes Approach
  • Analyze how narratives depict reversal tropes in character agency and technology.

  • Specific examples:

    • Inverted roles of spaceships in Douglas Adams' work.

    • Reversal of typical robot behavior and motivations.

    • Alien invasion tropes subverted.

Interpretation of Knowledge
  • Discussion of hubris in knowledge from Asimov's "Nightfall.

  • Examine the relationship between scientist and cultist views on knowledge and understanding.

  • The symmetry between scientific knowledge and cult beliefs underscores pitfalls in knowledge acquisition.

Grading Feedback for Midterm

  • General appreciation for engagement with text.

  • Midterm format to mirror final exam closely, focusing on the construction of a structured argument.

  • Importance of nuanced data gathering from texts to support responses.

  • Additional bonus point provided to all midterms as a goodwill gesture.

  • Adjust scores accordingly, as noted: add 1 point to final grade provided on the midterm.

Concluding Remarks

  • Emphasize the growth of understanding through articulating uncertainties.

  • Approach knowledge acquisition with openness to questions and complexities of human experience.