L4 Notes

Session Overview and Administrative Updates

  • The session begins with a greeting for Father's Day, acknowledging the fathers in the group.
  • Professor logistical update: The professor is traveling to San Francisco for a Tuesday morning meeting. The return flight is scheduled for Tuesday night at approximately 10:0010:00.
  • To avoid conflicts with other student classes, this session was rescheduled for Sunday evening.
  • The professor expresses appreciation for the students' writing and analysis throughout the course, noting that the time and thought put into submissions are evident.
  • Professional Outreach: The professor offers to share a personal email address for LinkedIn connections and provides a standing offer to serve as a reference for students applying to law school or other programs, as has been done for previous students.

Introduction to Contributory Negligence

  • Definition: Contributory negligence refers to the plaintiff's own unreasonable conduct that contributes to an accident.
  • Legal Requirements:
    • The plaintiff must have been negligent (acted unreasonably when there was a duty to act reasonably).
    • The plaintiff's actions must be the actual and proximate cause of the harm suffered.
  • Focus: The inquiry focuses on the plaintiff's failure to take reasonable steps to protect him or herself.
  • Historical context (Butterfield case): In merry old England, if a person rode a horse "violently" through the streets and hit a pole they failed to see, the old approach dictated that if a plaintiff was even 1%1\% liable, they recovered nothing. This is described as a draconian approach.
  • Modern Approach: Modern courts use a system of allocation where the jury determines the percentage of harm caused by each party (e.g., 70%70\% defendant and 30%30\% plaintiff). The plaintiff's award is reduced by their own percentage of contributory negligence.

Contributory Negligence: Problem 1 Analysis

  • Scenario: A driver (plaintiff) is distracted by a text message and looks down. Simultaneously, the defendant driver suddenly swerves into the plaintiff's lane, sideswiping the car. The plaintiff would not have had time for evasive maneuvers even if she had been paying attention.
  • Negligent Acts:
    • Defendant: Crossing into another lane and sideswiping a vehicle.
    • Plaintiff: Driving while distracted by a phone (not looking where they are going).
  • Summary Judgment Discussion: A court might determine as a matter of law that the plaintiff was not contributorily negligent because the plaintiff's negligence was not the actual or proximate cause of the harm. Even if she had her hands at "three and nine" and was paying full attention, the accident would have still occurred.
  • Hypotheticals on Swerving and Negligence:
    • Swerving to avoid a moose: Generally not considered negligent due to the danger presented by a moose to the driver and family.
    • Swerving to avoid a pigeon: Potentially negligent if it involves swerving into oncoming traffic to avoid a small animal with low impact risk.
    • Swerving to avoid a person: Not negligent, though if the person was intoxicated and wandered into the road, that bystander might share potential liability as an intervening cause.
    • Equipment failure: If a poorly manufactured tire blows out causing a swerve, the tire or car manufacturer may be liable.
  • Foreseeability and the "Want of a Nail" Proverb: Referencing the Benjamin Franklin proverb regarding a blacksmith missing a nail, leading to a lost horseshoe, a lost horse, a lost soldier, and eventually a lost kingdom. The legal focus remains on reasonable foreseeability; it is not reasonably foreseeable that a poorly shod horse should make the blacksmith liable for the loss of a war.

Assumption of the Risk

  • Definition: The plaintiff makes a knowing choice regarding a risk that later materializes and causes harm.
  • Elements of Proof:
    1. The plaintiff was aware of the risk.
    2. The plaintiff appreciated the magnitude of the risk.
    3. The plaintiff voluntarily encountered the risk.
  • Subjective vs. Objective: Unlike negligence which uses an "objective" reasonable person standard, assumption of risk is a "subjective" inquiry into what the specific plaintiff knew and felt.
  • Historical vs. Modern Rule: Historically, assuming any risk barred recovery. Now, damages are allocated based on the degree of risk assumed versus the defendant's negligence.
  • Supermarket Hypothetical: A supermarket waxes its floor and places a waist-high yellow sign saying "Caution" or "Wet Floor."
    • If the plaintiff sees the sign, appreciates the slip risk, but walks anyway to get bread, it is Assumption of Risk.
    • If the plaintiff is on her phone, fails to see the sign entirely, and slips, it is Contributory Negligence.

Strict Liability (No-Fault Liability)

  • Core Principle: Strict liability does not require proof of intentional misconduct or negligence. It is based on the defendant engaging in activities that create unique and significant risks for others, even if done carefully.
  • Blasting/Drilling: Most states categorize blasting as inherently dangerous because it can cause harm through vibrations or flying debris even when conducted with care. Liability depends on proving proximate cause.
  • Abnormally Dangerous Animals:
    • Owners are strictly liable for injuries caused by wild animals (lions, tigers, bears).
    • Pit Bull Case Study: Historically, some professors argued pit bulls had "no social utility" because they were bred for aggression and dogfighting. Modern views have shifted as they are now common domestic pets, though they once served as a prime example of potential strict liability due to inherent danger.
  • Case: Van Houghton versus Pritchard:
    • A neighborhood cat urinated in a neighbor's garage. The neighbor picked up the cat, was bitten, and required surgery costing 39,00039,000 in medical bills.
    • The Ruling: The plaintiff lost because they could not prove the cat was a "vicious type" or had known dangerous tendencies.
    • Defenses: Picking up a strange cat likely constitutes Assumption of Risk (subjective awareness that cats bite) or Contributory Negligence.

Limitations on Strict Liability and the Mink Case

  • Scope of Risk: A defendant's liability in strict liability is limited to the types of harm that make the activity dangerous in the first place.
  • Case: Foster versus Preston Mill (Washington, 1954):
    • Blasting vibrations (an ultra-hazardous activity) caused a mother mink in captivity to become so upset she ate her young.
    • The Ruling: The court denied recovery. It held that the "exceedingly nervous disposition" of the mink was the cause of the loss, not the inherent risks associated with blasting.
    • Policy Reason: While flying debris or structural damage is a foreseeable risk of blasting, a wild animal eating its young miles away is not a risk that makes legal blasting "ultra-hazardous."

Practical Legal Scenarios and Problem Solving

  • Problem 2: The Target Rescue Scenario: Paula and her niece Mindy are at Target. A light fixture falls, shattering glass. Paula steps on glass to rescue her panicking niece and injures her foot.
    • Involuntary Action: Some argue the rescue was an involuntary reflex or that she had a "duty to protect" the child.
    • Negligence Analysis: It is unlikely a jury would find an aunt negligent for rescuing a frightened four-year-old from broken glass, even if she could have theoretically waited for help.
  • Problem 3: The Dog on the Sidewalk: A dog (e.g., a golden retriever) lies on a sidewalk and an inattentive child on a bike collides with it.
    • Strict Liability: Fails because a golden retriever is not an inherently dangerous animal.
    • Negligence: Possible if the owner failed to keep the dog locked up, knowing it might sleep on a public path.
  • Problem 4: Bubba's Bees: A negligent driver (Adam) causes a bee truck to wreck. Charlotte is stung 200200 yards away.
    • Anaphylactic Shock: Under the "Thin Skull Rule," the defendant must take the plaintiff as they find them.
    • Strict Liability Discussion: Courts might debate if transporting bees is "ultra-hazardous." While bees have social utility, a swarm presents a significant risk.
  • Problem 5: Lytton's Restaurant Insecticide: Lytton's uses "Super X" insecticide which has a flowery smell but is toxic and requires a 66-hour ventilation period.
    • Facts: Sprayed at midnight, Meg enters the bathroom at 6:056:05 AM and has an allergic reaction.
    • Parties to Sue: Lytton's (for negligence in opening too soon or poor ventilation) and potentially the Manufacturer (if the 66-hour warning was inadequate).
    • Damages Consideration: If the damage is minor (one Benadryl treatment), an attorney might not take the case. If it results in a coma or wrongful death, the damages justify the litigation cost.

Questions & Discussion

  • Settlement Negotiations: Lawyers have a fiduciary duty to communicate all settlement offers to their clients. A client might decline a reasonable 50,00050,000 offer, insisting on 1,000,0001,000,000 at trial, even if the attorney advises against it.
  • Collecting Judgments: If a defendant (like a college kid) has no money, the plaintiff might seek wage garnishment or property liens. Commercial defendants (like Target) are preferred because they have deep pockets and insurance.
  • Malpractice and Specialization: The professor explains why many attorneys refuse to write wills—it is a specialized field (wills, trusts, estates, and probate). Performing such work without regular experience risks malpractice.
  • The LSAT: Discussion on the Law School Admission Test. The professor encourages aspiring lawyers not to be terrified of the test, as it is a hurdle that can be overcome with repeated attempts if necessary.