Nature of Science: Scientific Method, Experimental Design, and Technological Design
Fundamental Definitions and Key Terms of Science
National Academy of Sciences Definition of Science:
Science is a particular way of knowing about the world.
In science, explanations are strictly limited to those based on observations and experiments that can be substantiated by other scientists.
Explanations that cannot be based on empirical evidence are not part of science.
Fact:
An objective, verifiable observation.
Example: Water boils at ().
Principle:
A statement based on repeated experimental observation that describes an aspect of the world.
Example: Greenhouse effect.
Scientific Law:
A broad concept or principle that describes HOW nature behaves.
Describes patterns observed in nature.
Often accepted as facts.
Examples:
Newton's laws of motion
Boyle's gas laws
Law of Conservation of Mass
Scientific Theory:
An explanation of an observed phenomenon explaining WHY it occurs.
Organizes facts and research from scientists to construct a cohesive explanation.
NEVER becomes a fact or a law regardless of the amount of supporting evidence.
Example: Evolutionary theory.
The Investigative Sequence and Experimental Process
Foundations of Scientific Inquiry:
Science is fundamentally based on experimentation.
Scientific understanding is dynamic and constantly built upon as new findings emerge.
There is no single rigid path for designing an experiment, but the general investigative process tends to follow a defined sequence.
General Sequence of Investigation:
Ask a question
Conduct background research
Construct a hypothesis
Test your hypothesis in an experiment
Analyze data
Draw conclusions and communicate them
Observations, Inferences, and Quantitative Precision
Observations:
Questions in scientific investigations frequently arise directly from observations.
An observation is a description of something that can be detected using the five senses: sight, smell, touch, taste, or hearing.
Must be strictly objective; an observation is NOT an opinion.
Example: The ground is wet.
Inferences:
An inference is a guess or logical deduction about an object or outcome based on prior observations.
A single observation can lead to multiple reasonable inferences.
Examples based on the observation that the ground is wet:
It rained.
Someone was watering the plants.
Categories of Observations:
Qualitative Observation:
Describes qualities or physical characteristics without numerical measurements.
Examples:
Green liquid
Large hole
Sour taste
Sweet smell
Quantitative Observation:
Uses numbers and units to measure a quantifiable attribute.
Examples:
Considerations for Quantitative Data:
Precision:
Refers to how close repeated measurements are to each other.
Focuses on consistency and specificity of data points.
Accuracy:
Refers to how close a measurement is to the correct or accepted true value.
Focuses on correctness of data.
Measurement Standard:
Always record the most specific reading provided by the measurement instrument, then estimate one additional decimal place.
Four Combinations of Data Quality:
Precise and Accurate
Precise but not Accurate
Accurate but not Precise
Not Accurate or Precise
Background Research, Purpose, and Hypotheses
Conducting Background Research:
Investigating existing knowledge helps define the purpose and objective for an experiment.
Progression of scientific inquiry: Observations Questions Research (discovering what has already been established) Defining a Purpose.
Purpose / Objective: A clear, concise statement specifying the exact question being answered in the investigation.
Constructing a Hypothesis:
A testable prediction based on observations that describes a specific cause-and-effect relationship between variables.
A hypothesis is substantially more than a simple guess.
Standard Format for a Hypothesis: "If (IV) then (DV)"
IV = Independent Variable (Cause)
DV = Dependent Variable (Effect)
Scientific Variables and Experimental Design
Independent Variable (IV):
The factor that the experimenter deliberately changes or manipulates during the investigation.
Placed on the X-Axis of a data graph.
Must be the ONLY parameter that differs between experimental groups.
Example Scenario: An investigation testing if beverage choice prior to a race affects running speed.
Independent Variable: The type of drink consumed before the race.
Dependent Variable (DV):
The factor that changes in response to manipulations of the independent variable.
Placed on the Y-Axis of a data graph.
Represents the data collected and measured in the experiment.
Example Scenario: In the pre-race beverage running experiment.
Dependent Variable: How quickly you run (running time or speed).
Experimental Components:
Materials:
A bulleted list detailing every item required to perform the experiment.
Must specify exact quantities/amounts and brand names where relevant.
Procedures:
A numbered list outlining every step taken during the investigation.
Each step must begin with an action verb.
Must be clear and explicit enough for another person to replicate the experiment identically.
Experimental Group(s):
The sample groups subjected to the variable being tested.
Running Example: The groups of runners drinking different specific test beverages.
Control Group:
The baseline comparison group treated under normal conditions.
Running Example: The group of runners drinking standard water or receiving no drink prior to running.
Constants:
Aspects of the experiment that are kept identical across all trials and groups.
Ensures that all experimental conditions are uniform except for the independent variable.
Guarantees that any observed change in the dependent variable is solely caused by the independent variable.
Running Example Constants: Participant age, gender, breakfast consumed, training regimen, and running shoes.
Repeated Trials:
Conducting as many repeated trials as possible is essential to:
Ensure results are not due to chance or random error.
Eliminate experimental errors.
Ensure data is precise.
Data Analysis, Results, and Conclusions
Results Collection and Presentation:
Collect raw data in an organized structure during the investigation (e.g., data tables).
Present processed data in clear, accessible visual formats, such as graphs.

Data Analysis Guidelines:
Limit statements strictly to what the collected data explicitly demonstrates.
Identify and highlight prominent trends, patterns, or relationships in the data.
Discuss potential sources of error in the data.
Drawing Conclusions and Communication:
Make an explicit statement declaring whether the hypothesis was supported or rejected by the experimental data.
Crucial Rule: Scientific data NEVER "proves" or "disproves" a hypothesis; data can only support or fail to support (reject) a prediction.
Describe real-world applications or practical uses for the information learned from the investigation.
Science, Technology, and Engineering Design
Distinction Between Science and Technology:
Science:
Focuses on the advancement of knowledge.
Answers questions based on natural observations.
Technology:
Focuses on the advancement of society.
Solves problems based on human needs.
Definition: The application of scientific discoveries to meet human needs and goals through the development of products and processes.
Engineering:
Applies scientific and mathematical principles directly to solve practical problems.
Steps of the Technological Design Process:
Problem Identification:
Clearly define the specific problem or societal need.
Solution Design:
Brainstorm, research, sketch, and systematically narrow down to the optimal product or process design.
Must operate within strict constraints, including:
Cost effectiveness
Time effectiveness
Material selection (availability, durability, environmental sustainability, etc.)
A perfect design is never achievable; the trade-off requires that the overall benefits significantly outweigh the risks ().
Implementation:
Build and test a prototype or process, making continual iterative improvements.
Evaluation:
Determine if the problem was successfully solved and whether all project constraints were satisfied.