Nature of Science: Scientific Method, Experimental Design, and Technological Design

Fundamental Definitions and Key Terms of Science

  • National Academy of Sciences Definition of Science:

    • Science is a particular way of knowing about the world.

    • In science, explanations are strictly limited to those based on observations and experiments that can be substantiated by other scientists.

    • Explanations that cannot be based on empirical evidence are not part of science.

  • Fact:

    • An objective, verifiable observation.

    • Example: Water boils at 100 degrees Celsius100\,\text{degrees Celsius} (100 ∘C100\,^\circ\text{C}).

  • Principle:

    • A statement based on repeated experimental observation that describes an aspect of the world.

    • Example: Greenhouse effect.

  • Scientific Law:

    • A broad concept or principle that describes HOW nature behaves.

    • Describes patterns observed in nature.

    • Often accepted as facts.

    • Examples:

    • Newton's laws of motion

    • Boyle's gas laws

    • Law of Conservation of Mass

  • Scientific Theory:

    • An explanation of an observed phenomenon explaining WHY it occurs.

    • Organizes facts and research from scientists to construct a cohesive explanation.

    • NEVER becomes a fact or a law regardless of the amount of supporting evidence.

    • Example: Evolutionary theory.

The Investigative Sequence and Experimental Process

  • Foundations of Scientific Inquiry:

    • Science is fundamentally based on experimentation.

    • Scientific understanding is dynamic and constantly built upon as new findings emerge.

    • There is no single rigid path for designing an experiment, but the general investigative process tends to follow a defined sequence.

  • General Sequence of Investigation:

    1. Ask a question

    2. Conduct background research

    3. Construct a hypothesis

    4. Test your hypothesis in an experiment

    5. Analyze data

    6. Draw conclusions and communicate them

Observations, Inferences, and Quantitative Precision

  • Observations:

    • Questions in scientific investigations frequently arise directly from observations.

    • An observation is a description of something that can be detected using the five senses: sight, smell, touch, taste, or hearing.

    • Must be strictly objective; an observation is NOT an opinion.

    • Example: The ground is wet.

  • Inferences:

    • An inference is a guess or logical deduction about an object or outcome based on prior observations.

    • A single observation can lead to multiple reasonable inferences.

    • Examples based on the observation that the ground is wet:

    • It rained.

    • Someone was watering the plants.

  • Categories of Observations:

    • Qualitative Observation:

    • Describes qualities or physical characteristics without numerical measurements.

    • Examples:

      • Green liquid

      • Large hole

      • Sour taste

      • Sweet smell

    • Quantitative Observation:

    • Uses numbers and units to measure a quantifiable attribute.

    • Examples:

      • 4 feet long4\,\text{feet long}

      • 6 legs6\,\text{legs}

      • 7.2 grams7.2\,\text{grams}

      • 100 mL100\,\text{mL}

  • Considerations for Quantitative Data:

    • Precision:

    • Refers to how close repeated measurements are to each other.

    • Focuses on consistency and specificity of data points.

    • Accuracy:

    • Refers to how close a measurement is to the correct or accepted true value.

    • Focuses on correctness of data.

    • Measurement Standard:

    • Always record the most specific reading provided by the measurement instrument, then estimate one additional decimal place.

    • Four Combinations of Data Quality:

    • Precise and Accurate

    • Precise but not Accurate

    • Accurate but not Precise

    • Not Accurate or Precise

Background Research, Purpose, and Hypotheses

  • Conducting Background Research:

    • Investigating existing knowledge helps define the purpose and objective for an experiment.

    • Progression of scientific inquiry: Observations →\rightarrow Questions →\rightarrow Research (discovering what has already been established) →\rightarrow Defining a Purpose.

    • Purpose / Objective: A clear, concise statement specifying the exact question being answered in the investigation.

  • Constructing a Hypothesis:

    • A testable prediction based on observations that describes a specific cause-and-effect relationship between variables.

    • A hypothesis is substantially more than a simple guess.

    • Standard Format for a Hypothesis: "If (IV) then (DV)"

    • IV = Independent Variable (Cause)

    • DV = Dependent Variable (Effect)

Scientific Variables and Experimental Design

  • Independent Variable (IV):

    • The factor that the experimenter deliberately changes or manipulates during the investigation.

    • Placed on the X-Axis of a data graph.

    • Must be the ONLY parameter that differs between experimental groups.

    • Example Scenario: An investigation testing if beverage choice prior to a race affects running speed.

    • Independent Variable: The type of drink consumed before the race.

  • Dependent Variable (DV):

    • The factor that changes in response to manipulations of the independent variable.

    • Placed on the Y-Axis of a data graph.

    • Represents the data collected and measured in the experiment.

    • Example Scenario: In the pre-race beverage running experiment.

    • Dependent Variable: How quickly you run (running time or speed).

  • Experimental Components:

    • Materials:

    • A bulleted list detailing every item required to perform the experiment.

    • Must specify exact quantities/amounts and brand names where relevant.

    • Procedures:

    • A numbered list outlining every step taken during the investigation.

    • Each step must begin with an action verb.

    • Must be clear and explicit enough for another person to replicate the experiment identically.

    • Experimental Group(s):

    • The sample groups subjected to the variable being tested.

    • Running Example: The groups of runners drinking different specific test beverages.

    • Control Group:

    • The baseline comparison group treated under normal conditions.

    • Running Example: The group of runners drinking standard water or receiving no drink prior to running.

    • Constants:

    • Aspects of the experiment that are kept identical across all trials and groups.

    • Ensures that all experimental conditions are uniform except for the independent variable.

    • Guarantees that any observed change in the dependent variable is solely caused by the independent variable.

    • Running Example Constants: Participant age, gender, breakfast consumed, training regimen, and running shoes.

    • Repeated Trials:

    • Conducting as many repeated trials as possible is essential to:

      • Ensure results are not due to chance or random error.

      • Eliminate experimental errors.

      • Ensure data is precise.

Data Analysis, Results, and Conclusions

  • Results Collection and Presentation:

    • Collect raw data in an organized structure during the investigation (e.g., data tables).

    • Present processed data in clear, accessible visual formats, such as graphs.

Model of Enzyme Substrate Interactions Under Various Conditions
  • Data Analysis Guidelines:

    • Limit statements strictly to what the collected data explicitly demonstrates.

    • Identify and highlight prominent trends, patterns, or relationships in the data.

    • Discuss potential sources of error in the data.

  • Drawing Conclusions and Communication:

    • Make an explicit statement declaring whether the hypothesis was supported or rejected by the experimental data.

    • Crucial Rule: Scientific data NEVER "proves" or "disproves" a hypothesis; data can only support or fail to support (reject) a prediction.

    • Describe real-world applications or practical uses for the information learned from the investigation.

Science, Technology, and Engineering Design

  • Distinction Between Science and Technology:

    • Science:

    • Focuses on the advancement of knowledge.

    • Answers questions based on natural observations.

    • Technology:

    • Focuses on the advancement of society.

    • Solves problems based on human needs.

    • Definition: The application of scientific discoveries to meet human needs and goals through the development of products and processes.

    • Engineering:

    • Applies scientific and mathematical principles directly to solve practical problems.

  • Steps of the Technological Design Process:

    1. Problem Identification:

    • Clearly define the specific problem or societal need.

    1. Solution Design:

    • Brainstorm, research, sketch, and systematically narrow down to the optimal product or process design.

    • Must operate within strict constraints, including:

      • Cost effectiveness

      • Time effectiveness

      • Material selection (availability, durability, environmental sustainability, etc.)

    • A perfect design is never achievable; the trade-off requires that the overall benefits significantly outweigh the risks (benefits≫risks\text{benefits} \gg \text{risks}).

    1. Implementation:

    • Build and test a prototype or process, making continual iterative improvements.

    1. Evaluation:

    • Determine if the problem was successfully solved and whether all project constraints were satisfied.