ENGL117: Persuasive Writing 1
Lecture Overview
- Brief Admin: Administrative matters discussed before diving into content.
- Principles of Argument: Continuation from last week, focusing on strategies in argumentation.
- Analysis of Texts: Focus on Jamaica Kincaid's "Alien Soil" and Richard Shaw's "A Tale of Two Stories".
- SA2 Information: Presentation of options for the second assignment which involves comparison and analysis of the mentioned texts.
Important Submission Guidelines
- Submission Process:
- Two-step process: Draft submission and final submission.
- Essays must be fully submitted to be marked.
- No penalties if the submission process is properly followed.
- Turnitin Scores:
- Scores must indicate normal quoting behavior.
- Low similarity scores should raise questions, but submissions need to be validated.
- Scoring:
- 20% - normal quoting
- 30% - might be overquoting
- 40% - too high, reconsider submission.
- Communication: Open invitation for students to discuss extensions or concerns regarding submissions.
Argument Structure and Strategy
- Essay Focus: Each essay must include a comparative analysis of Kincaid and Shaw, focusing on which argument is more fair and effective.
- Critical Comparative Discussion:
- Analyze strengths and weaknesses of each author’s argument.
- Must reference Hall and/or the Bedford handbook as foundational texts for analysis.
Argument Components
- Thesis Statement: Clear and defined - position must be evident.
- Logical Flow and Structure:
- Aim for clarity and organization in the essay structure.
- Paragraphs can focus on specific strategies or compares both authors within the same section.
- Use of Evidence:
- Combine personal experience with theoretical frameworks.
- Avoid emotionalism that overshadows logical arguments.
Workshop and Reading Assignments
- Workshop Dynamics: Attendance is crucial for effective learning and discussion generation.
- Readings: Important to engage with assigned readings ahead of workshops to foster deeper discussion.
Concepts Around Persuasion
- Persuasion Strategies:
- Engagement with Audience: Recognizing who the audience is and tailoring arguments accordingly.
- Balance Logic and Emotion: Ensuring that arguments do not lean too heavily in one direction.
- Addressing Opposition: Acknowledging opposing arguments within one’s own writing enhances credibility.
- Flaws in Argumentation: Critical to identify logical fallacies in both personal writing and in the texts being analyzed.
Key Takeaways on Kincaid and Shaw
- Jamaica Kincaid: Explores the legacy of colonization and individual experience as a Caribbean woman, engaging the reader’s awareness toward historical injustices.
- Richard Shaw: Investigates privilege within colonial frameworks, challenging the established narratives through personal and theoretical insights.
- Similarities: Both write about historical narratives and the importance of remembering uncomfortable pasts.
- Differences:
- Kincaid approaches from a perspective of oppression due to colonial history.
- Shaw critiques his own privilege and the dominant colonial narratives.
Final Thoughts
- Complexity of Arguments: Understanding the nuances in each text for a well-rounded analysis.
- Engagement: Importance of having discussions on contentious issues for enhanced critical engagement in writing.
- Expectations for Essays: Carefully structure arguments, support claims with evidence, and maintain a consistent tone throughout the piece.