Aristotle Ethics

Aristotle Theories and Principle of Virtue Ethics

  • Overview of Previous Discussions

    • Recap of discussions on virtue ethics, particularly those pertaining to Aristotle's ideas.

    • Focus on the doctrine of the golden mean as a secondary tool rather than a central principle of morality.

The Good Life

  • Aristotle's Perspective

    • Discussion of external factors contributing to the good life, which include:

    • Physical Excellence: Ability to perform well physically.

    • Wealth: Financial security and its benefits.

    • Beauty: The advantages conferred by physical attractiveness.

    • Emphasis on the notion of luck regarding one's circumstances and their impact on moral development and achieving the good life.

    • Acknowledgment of varying advantages/disadvantages based on one's birth situation, social status, and personal qualities (e.g., intelligence).

Competing Philosophical Views

  • Stoicism vs. Aristotelian Ethics

    • Stoics argue that external factors are insignificant to moral character, emphasizing internal conditions and character traits as determinants of a good life.

    • Contrast with Aristotle: Emphasis on character is paramount while external conditions, in Aristotle's view, contribute to one's potential to lead a moral life.

Understanding Virtue and Vice

  • The Doctrine of the Golden Mean

    • Virtue is positioned between two vices: deficiency and excess.

    • Examples of Virtues and Corresponding Vices

    • Wisdom:

      • Vice of Deficiency: Naivety

      • Vice of Excess: Cunning (deceptiveness)

      • Illustration: A wise person will neither deceive others (cunning) for personal gain nor blindly trust others (naive) ignoring new circumstances.

      • Cunning is illustrated as behaving deceptively, akin to a fox that appears friendly but aims to manipulate for a meal.

      • Naiveté described as ignoring past experiences or evidence due to misplaced trust.

    • Relating personal character to actions:

    • Example of a family member requesting money despite recent troubling behaviors illustrating naivety in ignoring evidence.

Critiques of Aristotle's Virtue Ethics

  • Critiques on Virtue Ethics

    • Scholars note biases in Aristotle’s list of virtues, primarily favoring wealthy men and overlooking perspectives relevant to women or diverse demographics.

    • Discussion of alternative frameworks like Carol Gilligan’s Ethics of Care which introduces feminine virtues such as compassion into discourse.

The Purpose of the Doctrine of the Golden Mean

  • Clarifications on Use

    • Not a decision-making procedure but a deliberative framework for evaluating past actions in terms of virtue and moral learning.

Objections to Aristotelian Ethics

  1. Critique on Happiness and Morality

    • Critics argue that Aristotle equates morality with happiness or self-fulfillment, countering that morality often involves self-denial.

    • Response: True morality is about seeking fulfillment rather than abstaining from pleasure alone.

  2. Role of External and Internal Factors

    • Critics question how much external circumstances should impact moral standing and whether morality can be luck-dependent.

    • Response: While external factors complicate the moral landscape, internal character traits play a significant role in decision-making.

  3. Absence of a Central Ethical Principle

    • Critics challenge whether a lack of a rigorous, central principle makes virtue ethics a valid ethical theory.

    • Response: The Aristotelian theory posits that right action aligns with virtuous behavior, expounding on an action-guiding principle.

  4. Influence of External Situations over Character Traits

    • Situational ethicists claim behavior is dictated more by context than stable character traits.

    • Illustrative Experiments: Two studies on seminary students and situational outcomes demonstrate variability in charitable actions based on environmental pressures and mood.

Final Thoughts
  • Discussion on Virtue Ethics' Validity

    • Affirmations about whether situational factors or character traits hold sway over action, exploring the complexity of human behavior in moral contexts, revisiting Aristotle's teachings in light of contemporary criticisms.