Aristotle Ethics
Aristotle Theories and Principle of Virtue Ethics
Overview of Previous Discussions
Recap of discussions on virtue ethics, particularly those pertaining to Aristotle's ideas.
Focus on the doctrine of the golden mean as a secondary tool rather than a central principle of morality.
The Good Life
Aristotle's Perspective
Discussion of external factors contributing to the good life, which include:
Physical Excellence: Ability to perform well physically.
Wealth: Financial security and its benefits.
Beauty: The advantages conferred by physical attractiveness.
Emphasis on the notion of luck regarding one's circumstances and their impact on moral development and achieving the good life.
Acknowledgment of varying advantages/disadvantages based on one's birth situation, social status, and personal qualities (e.g., intelligence).
Competing Philosophical Views
Stoicism vs. Aristotelian Ethics
Stoics argue that external factors are insignificant to moral character, emphasizing internal conditions and character traits as determinants of a good life.
Contrast with Aristotle: Emphasis on character is paramount while external conditions, in Aristotle's view, contribute to one's potential to lead a moral life.
Understanding Virtue and Vice
The Doctrine of the Golden Mean
Virtue is positioned between two vices: deficiency and excess.
Examples of Virtues and Corresponding Vices
Wisdom:
Vice of Deficiency: Naivety
Vice of Excess: Cunning (deceptiveness)
Illustration: A wise person will neither deceive others (cunning) for personal gain nor blindly trust others (naive) ignoring new circumstances.
Cunning is illustrated as behaving deceptively, akin to a fox that appears friendly but aims to manipulate for a meal.
Naiveté described as ignoring past experiences or evidence due to misplaced trust.
Relating personal character to actions:
Example of a family member requesting money despite recent troubling behaviors illustrating naivety in ignoring evidence.
Critiques of Aristotle's Virtue Ethics
Critiques on Virtue Ethics
Scholars note biases in Aristotle’s list of virtues, primarily favoring wealthy men and overlooking perspectives relevant to women or diverse demographics.
Discussion of alternative frameworks like Carol Gilligan’s Ethics of Care which introduces feminine virtues such as compassion into discourse.
The Purpose of the Doctrine of the Golden Mean
Clarifications on Use
Not a decision-making procedure but a deliberative framework for evaluating past actions in terms of virtue and moral learning.
Objections to Aristotelian Ethics
Critique on Happiness and Morality
Critics argue that Aristotle equates morality with happiness or self-fulfillment, countering that morality often involves self-denial.
Response: True morality is about seeking fulfillment rather than abstaining from pleasure alone.
Role of External and Internal Factors
Critics question how much external circumstances should impact moral standing and whether morality can be luck-dependent.
Response: While external factors complicate the moral landscape, internal character traits play a significant role in decision-making.
Absence of a Central Ethical Principle
Critics challenge whether a lack of a rigorous, central principle makes virtue ethics a valid ethical theory.
Response: The Aristotelian theory posits that right action aligns with virtuous behavior, expounding on an action-guiding principle.
Influence of External Situations over Character Traits
Situational ethicists claim behavior is dictated more by context than stable character traits.
Illustrative Experiments: Two studies on seminary students and situational outcomes demonstrate variability in charitable actions based on environmental pressures and mood.
Final Thoughts
Discussion on Virtue Ethics' Validity
Affirmations about whether situational factors or character traits hold sway over action, exploring the complexity of human behavior in moral contexts, revisiting Aristotle's teachings in light of contemporary criticisms.