Anth 111 Study Notes
Anth 111 - Subsistence and Economics
Instructor: Denise Huynh
Date: January 29
Readings: Chapter 7 (Pages 173-187)
Pastoralism
Definition: A subsistence strategy based on domesticated animal herds and the use of their products, primarily milk and milk products, and occasionally meat. It constitutes 50% or more of the diet.
Geographical Distribution: Predominantly found in the Middle East, Africa, Europe, and Central Asia.
Trade Networks: Highly developed and extensive.
Division of Labour:
Families and clusters of families function as the basic units of production.
Men are primarily responsible for herding animals.
Women are involved in processing animal products.
Property Relations in Pastoralism
Most Important Property: Domesticated animals are the most vital form of property.
Other Property: Includes housing and domestic goods.
Inheritance: Property may be inherited, particularly through male lineage.
Use Rights: Rights to land and migratory routes are often established.
Sustainability: Pastoralism can be sustainable, provided there is adequate land.
Types of Pastoralism
Transhumance:
Involves seasonal movement of livestock to different pastures, often with men moving while women, children, and older men remain in permanent settlements.
Nomadism:
No permanent villages; the entire social unit moves with livestock to find new pastures.
Agriculture
Definition: Involves growing crops on permanent plots utilizing techniques such as plowing, irrigation, and fertilizer to create surplus.
Types of Agriculture:
Intensive Agriculture: Requires significant inputs of labor and resources.
Industrial Agriculture: Characterized by mechanization and mass food production.
Surplus Production: Allows some individuals to engage in non-subsistence activities, thereby promoting specialization.
Intensive Agriculture
Population Support: Can support many more people per unit of land compared to horticulturalism.
Labour Input: Numerous hours are devoted to land preparation, requiring a peasantry class.
Major Activities:
Includes plowing, planting, weeding, irrigation management, terracing, harvesting, processing, and storage.
Division of Labour in Intensive Agriculture
Family: The basic unit of labor, defined by gender and age.
Gender Roles: Women's daily work hours are approximately 25% more than those of men.
Property Rights in Intensive Agriculture
Rights: Property rights are clearly defined and protected.
Acquisition: Rights can be acquired or sold, and land inheritance often takes place through marriage.
Protection: Institutions exist to safeguard property rights.
Industrial Agriculture
Definition: Intensive farming practices that involve mechanization and large-scale food production.
Impact of Agribusiness: Increased food production but introduced complex challenges.
Labor and Resources: Requires more labor, advanced technology, and usage of non-renewable resources than any other economic system.
Effects on Other Economies: Displaces and undermines sustainable practices in foraging, horticulture, and pastoralism.
Intensification: People and the Environment
Sedentary Lifestyle: Intensive cultivators tend to remain in one location.
Specialization of Agriculture: Agricultural economies increasingly focus on one or two caloric staples, raising specific animals to support this focus, leading to monoculture.
Horticultural Diversity:
Horticultural plots typically maintain diverse botanical species in tropical forest settings.
Agricultural plots decrease ecological diversity due to deforestation and concentration on staple crops.
Risk Management in Agriculture
Stability of Harvest: Agriculturalists aim for stable and long-term production, yet reliance on single staple crops can lead to famine when crops fail.
Population Considerations: Large, stationary populations benefit from this model compared to smaller, mobile populations typical of foragers and horticulturalists who mitigate risk via ecological diversity.
Distribution of Goods and Services
Principles: All three distribution principles (reciprocity, redistribution, and market exchange) can coexist in the same society but may govern different transactions.
Reciprocity
Definition: A mode of distribution characterized by the exchange of goods and services of approximately equal value between parties.
Categories:
Generalized Reciprocity:
Characterized by exchanges where the value is not closely monitored, and the timing of repayment is flexible.
Most common among foragers and among close friends/family across cultures.
Balanced Reciprocity:
A more formalized and regularized exchange where the value is monitored, expecting reciprocal exchanges in the short term.
Less personal than generalized reciprocity.
Negative Reciprocity:
One party seeks to gain more than they give, often in impersonal or hostile contexts.
Kula Ring and Delayed Reciprocity
Example: The Kula Ring among the Trobriand Islands illustrates delayed reciprocity, as there is a significant lag time between giving and receiving.
Kula Ring Mechanics:
Men pass ceremonial shell armbands (mwali) and necklaces (soulava) between islands to forge lifelong relationships among high-ranking men.
Certain mwali and soulava hold greater prestige than others.
Emphasis on the cultural principle “to possess is to give” indicates a strong social bond formed through these exchanges.
Further References:
"Purpose of the Kula Expedition" video resources.
Related materials from "Argonauts of the Western Pacific" by Bronislaw Malinowski (1922).
Redistribution
Definition: A distribution method requiring centralized social organization where wealth is collected and reallocated in a different pattern.
Responsibility: Typically, a responsibility to redistribute goods and foods to ensure all members of the group are provided for.
Example: The Potlatch as a form of ceremonial redistribution.
Market Exchange
Definition: A mode of distribution where goods and services are bought and sold, with values determined by supply and demand.
Evolution: This system developed from more straightforward trade practices.
Market Characteristics: Marketplaces vary in size and permanence and do not always necessitate money, as barter exists directly through the exchange of commodities without standard currency.
Modes of Consumption
Definition: The culturally specific ways in which goods and services are consumed, highlighting the importance of both intake and output.
Types of Consumption:
Minimalism:
Involves few finite consumer demands with sufficient means to meet them.
Common among foragers and to a lesser extent among horticulturalists and pastoralists.
Associated with the concept of the Original Affluent Society.
Consumerism:
Characterized by infinite demands and inadequate means to satisfy them.
Drives colonialism, globalization, and other expansionist activities.
A prevalent feature of industrial economies.
Forms of Consumption
Personalized Consumption:
Products produced by consumers for their own use or by individuals they know personally; typically seen in foraging, horticulture, and pastoralism.
Depersonalized Consumption:
Consumers are distanced from producers, a common trait in industrial agriculture.
Notable exceptions exist where personal connections are retained.