Consequences of Victimization

Consequences of Victimization

Overview

  • Primary Victimization Consequences
    • Physical consequences
    • Psychological consequences
    • Economic costs
  • System Costs
    • Law enforcement, courts, and corrections
  • Exacerbating Factors to Victimization
    • Vicarious victimization
    • Reporting
    • Fear of crime

Physical Consequences

  • Injury can range from short-lived to permanent.
  • Characteristics of those who incur injury (NCVS, 2016):
    • 27% of assault victims
    • 35% of robbery victims
    • Incidents perpetrated by non-strangers were more likely to result in injury compared to those by strangers.
  • Uniform Crime Reports (UCR) - Murder and Nonnegligent Manslaughter:
    • Majority of victims are males (78%).
    • Whites and Blacks account for similar percentages of victims.
    • Most murder victims are murdered by an acquaintance.
    • Guns are the weapon of choice when a weapon is used.
    • The motive for the majority of known homicides is arguments.

Psychological Consequences

  • Responses to victimization are dependent on:
    • Biological makeup
    • Interactional style
    • Coping style and resources
    • Context in which the incident occurs
    • Context in which they operate after the incident

Mental Health Consequences and Costs

  • Three common affective responses:
    • Depression:
      • Changes in sleeping and eating habits
      • Feelings of guilt, worthlessness, and irritability
      • Change in activities and interests
    • Reductions in self-esteem and self-worth:
      • Alter the way in which one views oneself
      • Especially prominent in female victims
    • Anxiety:
      • Irrational and excessive fear
      • Accompanied by physical symptoms

Psychological Consequences - Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

  • Affects approximately 25% of victims versus 9% of the general public.
  • Men: War or witness to serious injury or death.
  • Women: Rape and sexual molestation.

Behavioral Reactions - Self-Blame and Learned Helplessness

  • Self-blame: Blaming oneself for victimization.
    • Characterological self-blame: One’s character (victimization is deserved).
    • Behavioral self-blame: Victim can do something to avoid a future victimization.
  • Learned helplessness:
    • Feel that responding to victimization is useless.

Economic Costs

  • Common economic costs:
    • Property losses
    • Cost of medical care
    • Time away from work, school, and home
    • Pain, suffering, quality of life reduction
    • Legal costs
  • Property loss due to victimization:
    • 94% of property crime victims experienced economic loss.
    • Arson = 15,50015,500 per incident.
    • Motor vehicle theft = 3,3003,300 per incident.
    • 16% of victims recover some or all of their property.
  • Medical care:
    • Transporting victims to the hospital
    • Doctor care
    • Prescription drugs
  • Economic costs by crime type:
    • Child abuse costs 6.26.2 billion annually.
    • Battered women costs 1.81.8 billion annually.
    • Assaults with injuries: 1,4701,470 per incident.
    • Drunk driving victims injured: 6,4006,400 per incident.
  • Gunshot victims:
    • Make up one third of all crime-related hospitalizations
    • Lifetime medical costs = 1.71.7 billion for all gunshot victims (1994)
  • Mental Health Care
    • 10–20% mental health costs crime-related
  • Productivity losses
    • At place of employment, housework, and school
  • Pain, Suffering, and Quality of Life Issues
    • Most difficult elements to “quantify”
    • Victims may change routines and lifestyle
    • How can we attribute a dollar value to this?

System Costs

  • The United States spends upward of 214214 annually on the criminal justice system.
  • The United States covers one-fourth of health insurance payouts to crime victims.
    • Gunshot victims cost taxpayers over 4.54.5 billion annually.
  • Insurance companies pay 4545 billion annually on crime-related claims.

Vicarious Victimization

  • Effects of victimization on those close to the victim
    • When loved ones of crime victims also suffer the consequences of victimization
      • For example, homicide survivors
    • May occur when someone is traumatized by watching coverage of violent acts through media
      • Realistic threat of death to all members
      • Extraordinary carnage
      • Strong community affiliation
    • Witnessing of event by community members
    • Symbolic significance of victims to community
    • Need for rescue workers
    • Significant media attention

Reporting

  • Reporting the crime to law enforcement and subsequent involvement in the criminal justice system are important.
  • Only about half of all crimes are reported.
  • Reports are most likely when:
    • The offender is armed
    • The offender is under the influence of drugs or alcohol
    • The offender is a stranger
    • The offender is a non-gang member
    • The victim suffers an injury
  • Common reasons crime victims choose to report:
    • Prevent future crime
    • Stop offender
    • Because it was a crime
    • Protect others
    • Recover property
  • Common reasons victims do NOT report:
    • Private matter
    • Reported to another official
    • Unsuccessful crime/item returned
    • Fear

Fear of Crime

  • Fear: Emotional response to a perceived threat.
    • Physiological response causing fight or flee reaction.
  • Fear of crime is different from the perceived risk of crime.
    • Fear of crime: Activates the body to alert them to danger.
    • Perceived risk: Perceived likelihood that a person will become a crime victim.
  • Fear of crime is difficult to measure.
    • Types of questions asked didn’t ask about fear specifically.
      • How safe do you feel at school?
    • Some groups are actually less likely to be victimized but report higher levels of fear.
  • Females and older persons are more fearful.
    • Females:
      • Fear of sexual assaults
      • “Shadow hypothesis”
    • Older individuals:
      • Likely to feel that they cannot fend off attackers or otherwise protect themselves.
  • Incivilities are tied to fear of crime.
    • Incivilities are low-level breaches of community standards that indicate erosion of conventionally accepted norms and values.
    • Incivilities can be:
      • Physical: Litter, trash, and untended property.
      • Social: Rowdy youth, loiterers, and people drinking.
  • Fear of crime as “good”
    • Can be good if it leads to protection
      • Avoidance behaviors (constrained behaviors)
        • Restrictions that people place on their behaviors
          • Staying at home
      • Defensive Behaviors
        • Guard themselves
          • Purchasing a gun