Chapter 3- Literature Reviews
PSYC 381 - Research Methods Notes
Chapter 3: Literature Reviews
Overview
- Literature reviews are an essential component of empirical study.
- They serve multiple functions, including:
- Providing historical background relevant to the current research topic.
- Acting as a condensed summary of existing literature.
- This involves evaluating the aggregate or totality of existing evidence.
- Comparing studies based on elements such as reliability, validity, and theoretical contribution.
- Acting as an introduction to a current study.
Functions of a Literature Review
- Organizes Literature:
- Selects studies focusing on the same research topic, question, or problem.
- Describes and Compares Findings:
- Compares studies based on methodological and theoretical considerations.
- Evaluates Conclusions:
- Identifies relations, contradictions, gaps, and inconsistencies within the literature.
- Suggests next steps to address the research problem.
Prioritization of Sources
- A strong literature review emphasizes:
- Scientific Literature:
- Should take primacy in the review.
- Consists of empirical studies that have been peer-reviewed.
- Mainly includes:
- Research Articles: Original studies presenting new findings.
- Review Articles: Summarizations of existing research on a topic.
- Popular Science Literature:
- Designed for a general audience, not scientifically rigorous.
- Science Journalism:
- Closely related to popular science; focuses on recent and newsworthy scientific developments.
- All Other Sources: Less relevant and generally not prioritized.
Source Types
- Primary Source:
- Firsthand information published in peer-reviewed journals.
- Secondary Source:
- Information discussing or referencing a primary source, used as a guide to locate primary sources.
- Citing differences exist between primary and secondary sources in APA format (see section 8.6 in the APA manual).
Types of Literature Reviews
Narrative Review:
- Most traditional and popular form of literature review.
- Involves qualitative appraisal of existing literature.
- Prone to bias due to lack of systematic methodology and quantitative analysis.
Systematic Review:
- Distinguished from narrative reviews by use of explicit, reproducible methodology.
- Features:
- Clearly defined search strategy.
- Predefined criteria for selecting studies.
- Aims to answer specific research questions.
- Makes explicit inclusion and exclusion criteria.
- Seeks to identify all published articles meeting eligibility criteria.
- Includes an assessment of validity of the results of all included studies.
Meta-analysis (Statistical Synthesis):
- A specific type of systematic review.
- Focuses on summarizing quantitative findings from empirical studies.
- Provides statistical tools for comparing data across studies using an index known as effect size.
- Effect size quantifies the relationship between two variables or the difference between two groups.
Limitations of Literature Reviews
- All literature reviews have inherent limitations:
- No perfect literature review exists.
- Selection bias can affect systematic reviews as well.
- Specific issues with meta-analysis include:
- Reductionism: Oversimplifying complex phenomena.
- Quality variations among studies affecting overall findings.
- Methodological comparison challenges.
- Ignoring context of studies.
- Publication bias, as not all studies get published.
Goals of Constructing Literature Reviews
- Aim to produce valid and reliable scientific knowledge while reducing the risk of bias.
- Steps in constructing the literature review:
- Topic selection.
- Research question development.
- Searching the literature.
- Outlining the review.
- Creating the review.
Topic Selection Criteria
- Select a topic that is interesting and relevant to the field of Psychology.
- Considerations include:
- Social Importance: Relevance to societal issues.
- Scientific Relevance: Contribution to the field.
- Feasibility Factors:
- Time constraints.
- Cost considerations.
- Permission from affiliated organizations.
- Availability of participants.
- Ethical issues involved in research.
- Measurement constraints.
- Political factors.
- Complexity of design.
Searching the Literature
- Use dedicated scholarly search engines.
- Seek peer-reviewed databases relevant to the research topic/question.
Search Method
- Create a tentative list of search terms.
- Narrow down your search scope.
- Use Boolean search logic:
- Combine keywords using AND, OR, NOT to refine searches.
- Utilize appropriate subject descriptors.
- Review search results critically.
- Locate relevant articles and save notes or articles during the process.
Outlining and Creating the Review
- Outlining should occur before, during, and after literature searching to maintain logical flow.
- Phases of creating the review:
- Introduction: Establishes context and importance of the topic.
- Body: Discusses and synthesizes existing literature.
- Conclusion: Summarizes findings and suggests future research directions.
- Regularly review and edit to enhance clarity and coherence of the review.