Chapter 3- Literature Reviews

PSYC 381 - Research Methods Notes

Chapter 3: Literature Reviews

Overview
  • Literature reviews are an essential component of empirical study.
  • They serve multiple functions, including:
    • Providing historical background relevant to the current research topic.
    • Acting as a condensed summary of existing literature.
    • This involves evaluating the aggregate or totality of existing evidence.
    • Comparing studies based on elements such as reliability, validity, and theoretical contribution.
    • Acting as an introduction to a current study.
Functions of a Literature Review
  1. Organizes Literature:
    • Selects studies focusing on the same research topic, question, or problem.
  2. Describes and Compares Findings:
    • Compares studies based on methodological and theoretical considerations.
  3. Evaluates Conclusions:
    • Identifies relations, contradictions, gaps, and inconsistencies within the literature.
    • Suggests next steps to address the research problem.
Prioritization of Sources
  • A strong literature review emphasizes:
    • Scientific Literature:
    • Should take primacy in the review.
    • Consists of empirical studies that have been peer-reviewed.
    • Mainly includes:
      • Research Articles: Original studies presenting new findings.
      • Review Articles: Summarizations of existing research on a topic.
    • Popular Science Literature:
    • Designed for a general audience, not scientifically rigorous.
    • Science Journalism:
    • Closely related to popular science; focuses on recent and newsworthy scientific developments.
    • All Other Sources: Less relevant and generally not prioritized.
Source Types
  • Primary Source:
    • Firsthand information published in peer-reviewed journals.
  • Secondary Source:
    • Information discussing or referencing a primary source, used as a guide to locate primary sources.
    • Citing differences exist between primary and secondary sources in APA format (see section 8.6 in the APA manual).
Types of Literature Reviews
  • Narrative Review:

    • Most traditional and popular form of literature review.
    • Involves qualitative appraisal of existing literature.
    • Prone to bias due to lack of systematic methodology and quantitative analysis.
  • Systematic Review:

    • Distinguished from narrative reviews by use of explicit, reproducible methodology.
    • Features:
    • Clearly defined search strategy.
    • Predefined criteria for selecting studies.
    • Aims to answer specific research questions.
    • Makes explicit inclusion and exclusion criteria.
    • Seeks to identify all published articles meeting eligibility criteria.
    • Includes an assessment of validity of the results of all included studies.
  • Meta-analysis (Statistical Synthesis):

    • A specific type of systematic review.
    • Focuses on summarizing quantitative findings from empirical studies.
    • Provides statistical tools for comparing data across studies using an index known as effect size.
    • Effect size quantifies the relationship between two variables or the difference between two groups.
Limitations of Literature Reviews
  • All literature reviews have inherent limitations:
    • No perfect literature review exists.
    • Selection bias can affect systematic reviews as well.
  • Specific issues with meta-analysis include:
    • Reductionism: Oversimplifying complex phenomena.
    • Quality variations among studies affecting overall findings.
    • Methodological comparison challenges.
    • Ignoring context of studies.
    • Publication bias, as not all studies get published.
Goals of Constructing Literature Reviews
  • Aim to produce valid and reliable scientific knowledge while reducing the risk of bias.
  • Steps in constructing the literature review:
    1. Topic selection.
    2. Research question development.
    3. Searching the literature.
    4. Outlining the review.
    5. Creating the review.
Topic Selection Criteria
  • Select a topic that is interesting and relevant to the field of Psychology.
  • Considerations include:
    • Social Importance: Relevance to societal issues.
    • Scientific Relevance: Contribution to the field.
    • Feasibility Factors:
    • Time constraints.
    • Cost considerations.
    • Permission from affiliated organizations.
    • Availability of participants.
    • Ethical issues involved in research.
    • Measurement constraints.
    • Political factors.
    • Complexity of design.
Searching the Literature
  • Use dedicated scholarly search engines.
  • Seek peer-reviewed databases relevant to the research topic/question.
Search Method
  1. Create a tentative list of search terms.
  2. Narrow down your search scope.
  3. Use Boolean search logic:
    • Combine keywords using AND, OR, NOT to refine searches.
  4. Utilize appropriate subject descriptors.
  5. Review search results critically.
  6. Locate relevant articles and save notes or articles during the process.
Outlining and Creating the Review
  • Outlining should occur before, during, and after literature searching to maintain logical flow.
  • Phases of creating the review:
    1. Introduction: Establishes context and importance of the topic.
    2. Body: Discusses and synthesizes existing literature.
    3. Conclusion: Summarizes findings and suggests future research directions.
  • Regularly review and edit to enhance clarity and coherence of the review.