Market Segmentation and Target Marketing Notes
Foundations of Market Segmentation and Target Marketing
Market segmentation and target marketing involve the strategic decision of choosing which customers to serve and, importantly, which customers to walk away from.
Segmentation is fundamentally a "bet": a firm chooses to give up some potential reach in the market to become significantly more relevant to the specific people they choose to keep as customers.
The relationship between relevance and cost involves a trade-off; as marketing strategies move toward individual customization, relevance increases, but the cost to serve those segments also rises.
Market Coverage Strategies: Differentiation vs. Undifferentiation
Undifferentiated Marketing (Mass Marketing):
Example: ALDI.
Core Strategy: Provides one offer and one promise, such as the lowest price on a limited range of products.
Operational Focus: Deliberately ignores shoppers who desire extensive choice. It competes primarily on cost rather than relevance to specific consumer niches.
Differentiated Marketing:
Example: Woolworths.
Core Strategy: Operates through multiple tiers including Metro stores, full supermarkets, online platforms, and the Everyday Rewards program.
Operational Focus: Creates distinct offers for various groups, such as time-poor shoppers, budget-conscious consumers, and premium shoppers. It competes on relevance but incurs the higher costs of managing operational complexity.
The Four Bases of Market Segmentation
Real-world segmentations rarely rely on a single base; they typically combine two or more to accurately describe a buyer. The four primary bases are:
Geographic Segmentation (Where they are):
Example: Bunnings. The product range shifts based on local climate and geography. For instance, stores in Cairns stock cyclone fixings, while stores near Jindabyne stock snow gear.
Demographic Segmentation (Who they are):
Example: Bonds. Ranges are built around specific life stages, including baby, kids, teen, and adult categories.
Psychographic Segmentation (What they believe):
Example: Aesop. This brand targets buyers who view design and restraint as a form of personal self-expression.
Behavioural Segmentation (What they do):
Example: Qantas Frequent Flyer. This program segments customers based on flight frequency and redemption patterns rather than age or demographic labels.
Deep Dive: Dimensions of Behavioural Segmentation
Usage Rate: Asks "How often do they buy?" In the Qantas Group, Platinum flyers represent a tiny share of total passenger volume but account for a large share of the airline's profit.
Occasion: Asks "Why are they buying now?" A consumer might buy the same seat for a business trip, a family holiday, or visiting relatives. While the physical product is the same, the underlying need differs based on the occasion.
Loyalty Status: Asks "Us, them, or both?" Companies use status tiers to create switching costs, making it feel expensive for a customer to move to a competitor (e.g., Qantas vs. Virgin).
Benefit Sought: Asks "What are they really buying?" Qantas sells reliability and lounge access, whereas Jetstar sells the lowest possible fare.
The Primacy of Needs Over Demographics
Demographics describe a segment, but needs are what actually create one. Even when consumers share the same age, postcode, and income, their needs can drive them into entirely different segments:
Value-Driven Segments (e.g., Who Gives A Crap): These consumers buy based on values. They are willing to pay more for toilet paper because of profits go toward building toilets. For this group, the product is a moral vote.
Time-Driven Segments (e.g., Koala): These consumers buy to get their time back. They demand mattresses delivered and set up on the same day with no showroom visits or haggling. The product represents convenience.
Price-Driven Segments (e.g., Chemist Warehouse): These consumers buy the lowest price. Cluttered aisles are intentional as they signal value and discounts. The product is the discount itself.
The Five Tests for a Usable Market Segment
To determine if a segment like "the tradie" is actionable for a brand like Bunnings, it must pass five specific tests:
Measurable: Can the size of the segment be determined? For Bunnings, this is done using ABS (Australian Bureau of Statistics) licensed-trade data and PowerPass sign-up figures to establish a hard number.
Substantial: Is the segment large or profitable enough to be worth pursuing? Tradies are substantial because they buy weekly rather than twice a year and have a higher spend per visit.
Differentiable: Does the segment behave differently than others? Tradies prioritize stock depth and a fast exit from the store, whereas DIY shoppers typically require more advice.
Accessible: Can the segment be reached? Bunnings reaches tradies at in-store, through trade-specific radio ads, and via PowerPass email communication.
Actionable: Can the firm actually serve the segment? Bunnings provides a dedicated trade desk, bulk pricing, and early opening hours to meet specific trade requirements.
Target Marketing Strategies
Once segments are identified as options, targeting is the definitive decision of which to pursue. There are four primary strategies:
Undifferentiated (Mass) Marketing: One offer for the entire market. Example: Vegemite uses the same jar and message for everyone. This is inexpensive to run but impossible to defend if a competitor targets a specific niche.
Differentiated Marketing: Separate offers for several segments. Example: Coles offers "Coles Finest," "Own Brand," and value tiers side-by-side. This provides broad reach but introduces expensive operational complexity.
Concentrated (Niche) Marketing: Focusing all effort on one specific segment. Example: Aesop serves a design-led buyer and ignores the rest of the market. This builds deep loyalty but creates high exposure if that specific buyer segment disappears or moves on.
Micromarketing: Offers built around the individual. Example: HelloFresh Australia assembles boxes and offers per household. This is a powerful strategy but is only viable with high-quality data.
Evaluating Segment Attractiveness
Before selecting a target, a segment should be scored on three criteria:
Size and Growth: The segment must be big enough to matter and growing fast enough to be worth the investment. However, the largest segments often attract the most competition. For example, as plant-based milk grew, every major dairy brand entered the space.
Structural Attractiveness: This involves assessing the competition. Who else is in the space? How hard do they fight? Are there substitutes? Are there price wars? In the meal kit market, HelloFresh and Marley Spoon already compete intensely on discounts.
Company Objectives and Fit: Does the firm have the skills and brand equity to win in this segment? While Bunnings can serve tradies, a boutique hardware store likely cannot. An attractive segment the firm cannot serve effectively is simply an opportunity for a competitor.
Case Study: Boost Juice Targeting
Segment Scoring:
Detox and Cleanse Buyers: Attractive, but high sugar counts in products kill the brand's credibility with this group.
Post-Workout Gym Crowd: High value and high repeat purchase rates. This is the chosen TARGET.
Price-led Meal Replacement: Thin margins, no brand loyalty, and does not fit the Boost brand image.
Weekend Family Treat: Loyal and easy to serve, but growth potential is limited.
The Formal Target Definition: Regular gym-goers aged – located in metro fitness and transport precincts who desire a fast, high-protein recovery drink they can trust.
The Marketing Mix (4Ps) adjusted for the Gym-Goer Target:
Product: Focus on protein-led blends with sugar content clearly stated up front.
Place: Locations situated near gyms and transit stations; utilizing app pre-orders to allow customers to "beat the queue."
Price: Positioned at a premium compared to the average juice bar, including rewards to encourage repeat visits.
Promotion: Utilizing gym partnerships and fitness creators rather than mass-market television advertising.
Common Pitfalls in Segmentation and Targeting
Over-segmentation: Slicing the market into so many small pieces that no individual slice can generate enough revenue to pay for the effort of serving it.
Falling for the Demographic Trap: Treating labels like "Women 25–34" as a segment. This is a description, not a segment, and it provides no insight into what those individuals actually want.
Targeting the Segment You Like: Marketers often mistakenly pick the buyer who looks like them rather than the buyer who actually spends the most money.
Choosing What You Cannot Serve: Targeting a segment that you cannot effectively reach or supply creates an opportunity for a competitor to step in.