Week 8π
Psychology 745
Psychopathology
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder
- Instructor: Martin McElhiney, Ph.D.
Overview of Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)
- Source: Castonguay, Chapter 5
- Characteristics:
- OCD is characterized by two main symptoms:
- Obsessions:
- Defined as unwanted thoughts, ideas, images, or impulses.
- These thoughts are experienced as repugnant, threatening, obscene, blasphemous, nonsensical, or a combination of these.
- Three Distinguishing Characteristics of Obsessions:
- Unwanted/Uncontrollable:
- They intrude into consciousness, often triggered by external cues.
- Incongruence:
- Content is incongruent with the individual's belief system, not typical of thoughts one would expect to have.
- Resistance:
- Accompanied by feelings that a fix is necessary; requires dealing with, neutralizing, or avoiding the obsession.
- The motivation to resist is driven by fear of disastrous consequences if not acted upon.
Common Obsessions
Table 5.1 - Categories and Examples
Categories
- Contamination:
- Concerns about contracting AIDS from touching bathroom surfaces.
- Fear of cancer from lawn fertilizer.
- Anxiety about germs spreading and making others sick.
- Fear of illness from touching unwashed laundry.
- Responsibility for Harm:
- Thoughts of having accidentally harmed someone while driving.
- Doubts about whether doors are locked or appliances are turned off.
- Symmetry/Order:
- Urge for environmental balance between two sides.
- Belief that a parent's death hinges on the order of book arrangement.
- Sexual Thoughts:
- Impulses toward inappropriate actions such as kissing one's boss.
- Sexual thoughts about minors or family members.
- Violence/Aggression:
- Impulses to harm vulnerable individuals (children/elderly).
- Religious Scruples:
- Blasphemous thoughts like portraying Jesus inappropriately.
- Fears about the adequacy of one's faith.
Compulsions
Definition and Common Rituals
- Compulsions:
- Defined as motivated and intentional behaviors performed in response to obsessions, aimed at reducing distress.
- Recognized as the most noticeable aspect of OCD that leads to significant functional impairment.
- Distinction from Other Disorders:
- Unlike behaviors in addictive disorders (e.g., sexual addiction, trichotillomania) that produce pleasure, compulsive behaviors are primarily anxiety-driven.
- Common Compulsive Rituals Examples:
- Washing/Cleaning:
- Handwashing for extensive periods (e.g., 15 minutes).
- Ritualistic cleaning of the shower and handling items like mail or groceries to prevent contamination.
- Checking:
- Repeatedly checking locks, windows, and appliances to ensure safety.
- Reassurance Seeking:
- Asking the same question of others multiple times for reassurance.
- Ordering/Arranging:
- Organizing items in a specific order until it feels right.
- Counting:
- Engaging in counting behaviors during routine tasks.
- Repeating Behaviors:
- Habits such as stepping through doorways or flicking light switches in patterns.
Differentiating OCD from Similar Disorders
Understand Related Conditions
- Illness Anxiety Disorder (IAD):
- Defined as a preoccupation with fears of having serious diseases like cancer, similar to obsessional fears in OCD.
- Repetitive reassurance-seeking can resemble compulsive checking in OCD.
- Body Dysmorphic Disorder (BDD):
- An OCD-related disorder according to DSM-5.
- Characterized by extreme concerns over perceived physical flaws.
- Generalized Anxiety Disorder (GAD):
- Characterized by chronic worries about real-life issues like finances and relationships, differing from OCD's content focus.
- Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCPD):
- Defined by rigid perfectionism and need for order; differs from OCD by not involving distressing obsessions and compulsions.
- Schizophrenia and Delusional Disorders:
- Involve bizarre thoughts but lack the resistance characteristic of OCD.
Understanding the Role of Obsessions and Compulsions
Functional Relationship
- Connection Between Obsessions and Compulsions:
- The compulsion serves as a means of mitigating the distress caused by obsessions.
- Patterns of Co-Occurrence:
- Responsibility obsessions correlate with checking rituals.
- Symmetry obsessions are linked to ordering and counting rituals.
- Contamination thoughts trigger washing and cleaning rituals.
- Religious, sexual, and violent obsessions often result in mental rituals and reassurance-seeking behaviors.
- Assessment Needs:
- Understanding the content and triggers of obsessional thoughts, as well as the anticipated negative consequences, is crucial.
- Information on compulsive rituals and avoidance strategies must be meticulously gathered, including the individual's rationale for these rituals.
- Insight into the senselessness of symptoms can impact diagnosis accuracy.
Course and Associated Features
Chronic Nature of OCD
- Generally chronic with low rates of spontaneous remission.
- Symptoms may fluctuate, exacerbated by life stress.
- 40-Year Follow-Up Study: (Skoog & Skoog, 1999) among 144 Swedish individuals with OCD:
- 120 (83%) showed some improvement.
- 58 (40% of total) no longer met OCD criteria (though some retained symptoms).
- 24 of the 58 reported complete recovery (17% of total).
- 48% of total had OCD for over 30 years.
- Correlates of worse outcomes included early onset, presence of both obsessions and compulsions, and low initial social functioning.
- Conclusion: Most individuals improve over decades, but many continue to experience clinical or subclinical symptoms.
Impacts of OCD
Functional and Relational Impairments
- Associated with impaired social and role functioning.
- Effects on romantic and family relationships, academic performance, and employment.
- Comorbid psychological disorders are common.
- Patients with severe OCD do not differ significantly in rates of alcohol abuse, suicide, or marriage compared to the general population.
- Family Impact:
- Relatives often experience restrictions on household access and involvement in compulsive rituals, affecting overall quality of life.
Epidemiology of OCD
Prevalence and Onset
- Worldwide prevalence: 2-3% of adults.
- Higher occurrence in females than males.
- Typical onset before age 25; rare after age 50.
- Mean age of onset is younger in males (~21 years) compared to females (22-24 years).
- Onset often lacks clear precipitant, but stress or trauma may contribute for some individuals.
- Notably higher symptom rates found among childbearing women.
- Environmental and sociological factors strongly influence the content of obsessional thoughts and rituals (e.g., AIDS-related fears since 1980s).
Statistical Data on OCD Prevalence
Percent of U.S. Adults Reporting OCD (2001-2003)
- Overall: 1.8%
- Female: 1.2%
- Male: 0.5%
- Age Breakdown:
- 18-29: 1.5%
- 30-44: 1.4%
- 45-59: 1.1%
- 60+: 0.5%
Severity of OCD
Past Year Severity Among U.S. Adults (2001-2003)
- Severe: 50.6%
- Moderate: 34.8%
- Mild: 14.6%
Comorbidity in OCD
Associated Psychological Conditions
- Increased risk for other forms of psychopathology, especially depressive disorders.
- Lifetime prevalence of major depressive disorder (MDD) in OCD patients: 12.4% to 60.3% (mean = 29%).
- Generally, OCD predates MDD, indicating that depression typically follows distress from OCD.
- OCD may co-occur with additional anxiety disorders, notably social phobia, panic disorder, and generalized anxiety disorder (GAD).
- Personality disorder comorbidity estimates vary between 8.7% to 87.5%, with anxious personality disorders being more common.
Etiology of OCD
Biological Models
- Serotonin Hypothesis:
- Suggests OCD results from serotonin neurotransmitter abnormalities.
- SSRIs (e.g., fluoxetine) are more effective than other medications, but direct studies do not conclusively align with serotonin levels and OCD.
- Structural Models:
- Propose neuroanatomical abnormalities in the orbitofrontal-subcortical circuits, linking initiation behaviors with subconscious awareness.
- Neuroimaging studies show increased activity in the orbital gyrus and head of the caudate nucleus in OCD patients, but findings are mixed.
Limitations of Biological Models
- Symptoms are not always aligned with proposed biological mechanisms.
- No clarity on how neurotransmitter or neuroanatomical abnormalities give rise to specific OCD symptoms.
- Current serotonin and neuroimaging studies are correlational, lacking definitive causal links.
Psychological Models
Learning Theory
- Behavioral models establish a two-stage conditioning theory:
- Classical Conditioning (Stage 1):
- Neutral stimuli pair with aversive stimuli, leading to conditioned fear responses.
- Operant Conditioning (Stage 2):
- Avoidance behaviors and compulsive rituals develop due to negative reinforcement from anxiety reduction.
- Limitations:
- Many individuals with OCD do not cite classical conditioning experiences as origins for their obsessions.
Psychological Models - Cognitive-Behavioral Approach
- Proposes that emotional distress, such as anxiety, emerges not from stimuli itself but from personal appraisals of those stimuli.
- Obsessional fears develop through misappraisals of the significance and threat of intrusive thoughts.
- Mental Intrusions:
- Normal experiences that become clinical obsessions when deemed overly significant by the individual.
Cognitive-Behavioral Models: Belief Framework
- Comprehensive models include six specific beliefs and appraisals that contribute to the development of OCD symptoms.
Assessment of OCD
Key Measures
- Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale-II Self Report (Y-BOCS-I-SR)
- Obsessive-Compulsive Inventory (OCI)
Yale-Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale-II Self Report (Y-BOCS-II-SR)
Instructions and Implementation
Designed to evaluate distressing thoughts and actions related to OCD symptoms over a 30-day period.
Part A Instructions:
- Participants indicate if specific intrusive thoughts were experienced (Y/N).
Common Examples of Obsessions:
- Violence:
- Images of violent events without apparent reason.
- Concern with right/wrong: Adds undue moral complexity to simple thoughts.
- Concerns with cleanliness:
- Worries about germs and contaminants affecting health.
- Violence:
Part C Instructions:
- Document behaviors to lessen or neutralize intrusive thoughts, with a focus on engaged time (ranging from none to constantly).
- Control over urges and resulting distress from prevention need is noted.
Obsessive-Compulsive Inventory (OCI)
Assessment Overview
- Composed of 42 items across 7 subscales: Washing, Checking, Doubting, Ordering, Obsessing, Hoarding, and Mental Neutralizing.
- Rating scale ranges from 0 (not at all) to 4 (extremely).
- Analytical focus on mean scores for subscales as indications of OC symptom severity.
Summary of Key Points
- OCD involves complex interactions between obsessions and compulsions leading to functional impairment.
- Distinction from other anxiety and personality disorders is critical for accurate diagnosis and treatment selection.
- Both biological and psychological models apply but face limitations and require comprehensive understanding for effective treatment and management.