Comprehensive Study Notes on the Surplus Lines Act and Excess & Surplus Markets

Overview of the Surplus Lines Act and General Statute 58-21

  • State Surplus Lines Framework:

    • Every state maintains a dedicated Surplus Lines Act to regulate insurance placed with non-admitted carriers.
    • In North Carolina, General Statute Chapter 5858 covers all insurance law (including admitted and non-admitted markets).
    • Chapter 58−2158-21 specifically contains the North Carolina Surplus Lines Act.

  • Statutory Background and Origins:

    • General Statute Chapter 5858 contains 105105 chapters in total, though only approximately 5050 chapters actively contain statutory content.
    • Hanover Insured (an excess and surplus lines broker) conducted annual continuing education (CE) seminars for 120120 to 150150 loyal agents/brokerage personnel.
    • Industry surveys conducted at these seminars revealed that despite operating in the market, nearly zero surplus lines licensees, brokerage firms, or agents had ever read or studied the Surplus Lines Act directly.

  • Key Statutory Provisions of General Statute 58-21:

    • G.S. 58−21−158-21-1 (Short Title):
      • Establishes that the article shall be officially known and cited as the "Surplus Lines Act".
    • G.S. 58−21−258-21-2 (Relationship to Other Insurance Laws):
      • Explicitly isolates surplus lines insurance from general admitted insurance statutory regulations.
      • Unless surplus lines insurance, surplus lines licensees, non-admitted domestic surplus lines insurers, or non-admitted insurers are specifically referred to in a particular section of Chapter 5858, no other articles or sections of Chapter 5858 apply to them.
      • Legal Significance: Prevents attorneys or litigants from suing surplus lines carriers under standard admitted market regulatory rules, preserving market distinction and preventing operational havoc.

Federal Reform, NAIC Integration, and Purpose of Regulation

  • G.S. 58−21−458-21-4 (Non-Admitted and Reinsurance Reform Act - NRRA):

    • Passed as Section 55 (Subtitle B) of the federal Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010.
    • Regulates the sale of insurance in states where the insurer is not authorized/admitted to write business.
    • Statutorily authorizes the North Carolina Commissioner of Insurance to utilize the National Insurance Producer Database of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).
    • Surplus lines carriers report premium volume data, operational data, and financial stability metrics to the NAIC database.
    • The Commissioner accesses this database to continuously evaluate the financial integrity of non-admitted carriers and determine whether to permit their continued operation within the state.

  • G.S. 58−21−558-21-5 (Purpose of the Act and Necessity for Regulation):

    • Protection: To protect persons in North Carolina seeking insurance coverage.
    • Exportation Access: To permit surplus lines insurance to be placed with reputable and financially sound non-admitted insurers and "exported" out of the state pursuant to statutory rules.
      • Definition of Export: Transporting or placing a risk away from a duly licensed/admitted state insurance company to a non-admitted insurer.
    • Orderly Access & Market Innovation: To establish an orderly system of regulatory access that encourages admitted insurers to introduce new and innovative coverages once sufficient loss data is established by surplus lines pioneers.
    • Revenue Protection: To protect and collect the tax revenues owed to the state.

Statutory Definitions and Licensing Requirements

  • G.S. 58−21−1058-21-10 (Verbatim Statutory Definitions):

    • Admitted Insurer: An insurer admitted (licensed) to do business in North Carolina.
    • Eligible Surplus Lines Insurer: A non-admitted insurer with which a surplus lines licensee may place surplus lines insurance.
    • Export: To place surplus lines insurance with a non-admitted carrier.
    • Producing Broker: An agent or broker licensed under Article 3333 of Chapter 5858 who deals directly with the party seeking insurance and who may also be a surplus lines licensee.
    • Surplus Lines Insurance: Any insurance in North Carolina of a risk resident, located, or to be performed in the state permitted to be placed through a surplus lines licensee with a non-admitted insurer eligible to accept such insurance.
    • Surplus Lines Licensee: A person licensed under G.S. 58−21−6558-21-65 to place insurance on risks resident, located, or to be performed in the state with non-admitted insurers eligible to accept such insurance.
    • Home State: Defined as North Carolina if the insured's principal place of business is located in North Carolina.
      • Multistate Exposure Application: If a Georgia-headquartered contractor conducts temporary operations at a location in North Carolina, North Carolina state surplus lines regulations apply to the North Carolina location/exposure during the performance of work.

  • Licensing Rules and Continuing Education Context:

    • To discuss insurance directly with an insured, an individual must possess a valid agent's or broker's license (which are legally identical under state law).
    • Continuing Education (CE) Requirements: Standard licensure requires 2424 CE credit hours every 22 years, including a mandatory flood insurance course every 33 years.
    • Flood Insurance CE Dispute: An instructor who banked over 600600 credit hours and co-produced/starred in an online flood insurance video with Stewart Powell was informed by the Department of Insurance (DOI) that teaching/producing did not fulfill the mandatory flood course requirement unless he personally watched his own video. Refusing to watch his own video, he allowed his agent license to lapse since active licensure was no longer required for teaching.
    • Dual Licensure Rationale: Agents may maintain both a standard producer license and a surplus lines license simultaneously to bypass intermediary wholesalers when directly placing specialized risks (e.g., high-rise building construction towers).

Placement Standards, Eligibility, and White List Regulations

  • G.S. 58−21−1558-21-15 (Placement of Surplus Lines Insurance):

    • Surplus lines insurance cannot be procured unless the full amount or specific kind of insurance cannot be obtained from admitted insurers operating in North Carolina.
    • Diligent Search Requirement: Requires a due diligence search among admitted insurers actually writing the particular class of insurance in the state before exporting the risk.
    • Regulatory Shift: State law previously required three written declinations from admitted insurers. North Carolina eliminated the three-declination rule and placed the legal responsibility directly on the licensee to ensure and certify due diligence.

  • G.S. 58−21−2058-21-20 (Eligible Surplus Lines Insurer Criteria):

    • Must demonstrate good reputation and financial integrity.
    • Capital & Surplus Threshold: Must maintain a minimum of $15,000,000\$15,000,000 in capital and surplus.
    • Must supply the Insurance Commissioner with its latest certified financial statement.
    • Must be officially placed on the North Carolina White List.

  • The White List and Regulatory Compliance:

    • Definition: A monthly published list by the North Carolina Surplus Lines Association (ncsla.gov) detailing every permitted non-admitted insurer allowed to write risks located in North Carolina.
    • Severe Personal Liability Penalty: If an agent or surplus lines licensee places a risk with a non-permitted, non-admitted insurer not on the White List, the agent/licensee becomes personally liable (not corporately liable) for all claims incurred under that policy.

  • Case Study: Arizona Medical Malpractice Fraud Scheme:

    • Context: Medical malpractice is a specialized market with only about 55 active writing carriers. Occurred approximately 1515 years ago.
    • Scheme Details: An Arizona-based entity hired a former marketing representative from an established medical malpractice carrier. The representative divided North Carolina into Eastern and Western territories split at Raleigh.
    • Execution: An Eastern NC agent flew to Arizona, signed a licensee representation contract, and wrote medical malpractice policies for approximately 2222 doctors.
    • Discovery: The agent submitted mandatory quarterly tax reports for five consecutive quarters. On the fifth quarter, the DOI flagged that the carrier NAIC number and company name could not be matched to any permitted carrier.
    • Outcome: Investigation revealed the carrier was an unpermitted sham entity operating out of a post office box without capital backing. The Insurance Commissioner held a license revocation hearing. Following character testimony, the agent received a $15,000\$15,000 civil penalty and 22 years of probation while preserving his license.
    • Agency System Protocol: Best-practice agencies run automated monthly computer audit reports cross-referencing all active non-admitted carrier files against the newly published White List before bound coverage is issued.

Domestic Insurers, Withdrawal, Reports, and Support Organizations

  • G.S. 58−21−2158-21-21 (Non-Admitted Domestic Surplus Lines Insurers):

    • General Rule: Insurance companies domiciled in North Carolina must be admitted.
    • Statutory Exception: A domestic insurer possessing a minimum capital and surplus of at least $15,000,000\$15,000,000 may, pursuant to a board of directors resolution and written approval from the Commissioner, be designated as a non-admitted domestic surplus lines insurer operating exclusively in the surplus lines market.

  • G.S. 58−21−3058-21-30 (Withdrawal of Eligibility):

    • The Commissioner may revoke eligibility/permission if a surplus lines carrier:
      1. Is no longer financially sound (monitored via NAIC database).
      2. Has willfully violated state laws.
      3. Fails to make reasonably prompt payments of just claims and losses.

  • G.S. 58−21−3558-21-35 (Duty to File and Maintain Reports):

    • Within 3030 days after placing a risk (or via quarterly filings), the licensee must submit a report detailing: insured name, insurer name, policy period, policy number, premium amount, premium tax, and a signed affidavit acknowledging full compliance with G.S. 58−21−1558-21-15 due diligence rules.

  • G.S. 58−21−4058-21-40 (Surplus Lines Regulatory Support Organizations):

    • Statutorily created the North Carolina Surplus Lines Association (NCSLA) around 19901990.
    • Mandate: Every surplus lines licensee in North Carolina is required by law to maintain active membership in the association.
    • Functions: Educate the public and industry on proper market usage, disseminate White List updates, communicate regulatory/policy changes requested by the Commissioner, host an annual spring meeting (typically in April), and manage market oversight duties delegated under G.S. 58−21−5058-21-50.

Policy Requirements, Broker Duties, Tax, and License Maintenance

  • G.S. 58−21−4558-21-45 & G.S. 58−21−5058-21-50 (Evidence of Insurance & Notice Requirements):

    • Upon placing coverage, the broker/licensee must deliver evidence of insurance (binder or policy) to the insured immediately (formal policies typically require 3030 to 6060 days for delivery).
    • Mandatory Non-Admitted Notice Wording: Every policy binder and evidence of insurance must display the licensee's name and include the exact statutory disclaimer:
      • "The insurance company with which this coverage has been placed is not licensed by the State of North Carolina and is not subject to its supervision. In the event of insolvency of the insurance company losses under this policy will not be paid by any state insurance guarantee or solvency fund."

  • G.S. 58−21−5558-21-55 (Validity of Surplus Lines Contracts):

    • Declares surplus lines contracts fully valid and legally enforceable across all parties, blocking non-admitted carriers or litigants from denying claims under non-licensure defenses.

  • G.S. 58−21−6058-21-60 (Effect of Premium Payment to Licensee):

    • Payment made by an insured to the producing broker or surplus lines licensee is legally recognized as payment to the insurance company.
    • Once money is paid to the licensee, the insurer cannot cancel the policy for non-payment of premium even if the licensee fails to transmit funds.
    • Operational Reality: Brokers require full premium and tax payment upfront prior to issuing binders, unless large volume brokers negotiate formal 3030-day agency billing terms.

  • G.S. 58−21−6558-21-65 & G.S. 58−21−7058-21-70 (Licensing Terms and Intermediary Rules):

    • License term runs annually from September 11 to August 3131 with a $50\$50 annual renewal fee.
    • Licensees may accept business from any licensed agent/broker, must countersign non-resident licensee policies, and assume full tax remittal duties.

  • G.S. 58−21−7558-21-75 (Record Retention Requirements):

    • Licensees must maintain complete policy records in North Carolina for at least 33 years.
    • Modern Interpretation: Under regulatory agreements between the NCSLA and DOI, maintaining 24/7/36524/7/365 direct electronic access to non-resident carrier digital databases satisfies the in-state physical record requirement for North Carolina exposures.

  • G.S. 58−21−8058-21-80 & G.S. 58−21−9058-21-90 (Quarterly Reports and Premium Tax Rate):

    • Licensees submit quarterly reports detailing gross written premiums, return premiums, and tax obligations.
    • Surplus Lines Tax Rate: Fixed at exactly 5BAKPERCENT5BAK_PERCENT (55 percent) of gross written premium.
    • Unlike admitted carriers billed on earned premium by the DOI, surplus lines tax is fully due upfront upon policy issuance (subject to tax returns on policy cancellations).

  • G.S. 58−21−9558-21-95 (Eight Grounds for License Discipline):

    • The Commissioner may suspend, revoke, or non-renew a license after a hearing for:
      1. Removal of the licensee's office from North Carolina.
      2. Removal of accounting records from the state during the 33-year retention window.
      3. Closing the surplus lines office for more than 3030 consecutive business days without Commissioner authorization.
      4. Failure to file required quarterly reports on time.
      5. Failure to transmit required 55 percent surplus lines premium tax.
      6. Failure to maintain the mandatory $5,000\$5,000 surety bond (which guarantees premium tax transmission to the state).
      7. Violation of any provision of Article 2121.
      8. Any cause for which a standard producer license could be denied, revoked, or suspended under standard insurance laws.

  • G.S. 58−21−10058-21-100 & G.S. 58−21−10558-21-105 (Legal Actions and Criminal Penalties):

    • Carriers must maintain a designated agent for service of process filed with the Commissioner.
    • Aiding or representing an unauthorized non-admitted insurer in violation of state law is punishable as a Class 1 Misdemeanor, alongside civil penalties and mandatory restitution.

Core Principles of Excess and Surplus (E&S) Markets

  • Freedom from Rate and Form Filing:

    • The Sole Primary Rationale: Freedom from rate and form filing is the fundamental reason excess and surplus lines carriers exist.
    • Admitted carriers must file policy forms and rates with state departments of insurance, restricting custom policy terms and rapid pricing adjustments.

  • State Rate and Form Regulatory Systems:

    • Prior Approval (2727 States): Form and rate filings must be formally submitted and approved before use (North Carolina is a prior approval state). Obtaining full policy form approval typically requires 1818 to 2424 months, and up to 22 to 33 years for major rating organization (ISO) forms.
    • Filing and Use (1717 States): Forms/rates are filed and used immediately, but remain subject to state review and forced withdrawal upon disapproval.
    • Open Filing (66 States): Insurers implement forms/rates freely without upfront filing; state regulators intervene only upon consumer complaints.

  • Industry Perspectives on E&S Freedom:

    • Philip McCrory (CEO of RSUI Insurance Company): Stated in an A.M. Best executive seminar that any legislative attempt to restrict freedom of rate and form filing represents the single greatest existential threat to the surplus lines market.

  • Underwriting and Risk Management Case Examples:

    • Hendersondale Agricultural Case Study: A chemical plant bed gassing firm operating 350350 trucks across 1717 to 1818 states used lethal soil treatment gas causing death within 3030 seconds of exposure. Admitted carriers refused the liability. E&S carriers underwrote the exposure by customizing policy forms to mandate semi-annual motor vehicle record (MVR) checks and strict Department of Transportation (DOT) filings.
    • Moses Paving Example: E&S carriers endorsement structures utilize fully earned premium terms to prevent short-term job contractors from purchasing annual coverage, completing a 11-week job, and immediately canceling for full pro-rata premium refunds.
    • Construction Audit Hazard Example: An agency audit of an $80,000\$80,000 surplus lines general liability policy issued to a major construction company revealed a Designated Premises Endorsement restricting GL coverage exclusively to the primary administrative office site. Consequently, the firm's 1515 active commercial job sites were completely uninsured until audited and negotiated out by broker intervention.

  • Upcoming Announcements:

    • Class cookout scheduled for September 22.