Academic Notes: Tributary Arguments and Schematization (Lecture 6)

Lecture Quiz 6: Review and Analysis

  • Quiz Structure and Requirements:

    • Header Requirements: Write "Lecture Quiz Six" and your name on a blank sheet of paper.

    • Format: Identify two specific answers corresponding to Question 1 and Question 2.

    • Argument Passage provided: "They are serving ice cream, so you will have a good time. You should go."

  • Question 1: Providing the Link Between Arguments:

    • The objective is to identify how the two distinct arguments in the passage connect.

    • The proper way to identify a link is to determine which conclusion (CC) serves as support (SS) for the next argument.

    • In the provided example, the link is established as: C1→S2C_1 \rightarrow S_2.

    • This notation indicates that these two different claims are substantively the same claim, and the "tributary link" travels from the conclusion of the first argument to the support of the second.

  • Question 2: Identifying the Main Argument:

    • In the example, Argument 2 is the main argument.

    • Identification Criterion: A tributary argument (Argument 1) feeds into another. The main argument is defined by a conclusion that stands on its own and does not act as support for any subsequent claim in the passage.

The Core Process of Schematization

  • Step 1: Read for Understanding:

    • Read the entire passage to grasp the general subject matter.

    • Psychological Tip: To improve reading comprehension, specifically for tests like the SAT, "convince yourself that you are interested" in the material. Pretending to be interested makes the structure easier to identify.

  • Step 2: Identify Reasoning Flags:

    • Look for "flags" denoting links or connector words between clauses/substances.

    • Look for "indirectness" flags (words like "surely," "must," "probably," "likely") which often indicate a conclusion is being drawn.

  • Step 3: Identify Conclusions and Support:

    • Establish the primary claims (Conclusions).

    • Identify the evidence or reasons provided for those claims (Support).

  • Step 4: Determine Tributary Links:

    • Identify if a conclusion in one argument acts as a premise/support in another.

Practical Exercise 1: Jerry's Night Out

  • The Findings:

    • Conclusion 1 (C1C_1): He must have been quite drunk last night (Flag: "must have been").

    • Support 1 (S1S_1): Jerry was getting a drink every few minutes.

    • Support 2 (S2S_2): He took his clothes off on the dance floor.

    • Conclusion 2 (C2C_2): He is hung over today (Flag: "probably").

    • Support 3 (S3S_3): He was drunk last night (C1C_1).

    • Support 4 (S4S_4): Jerry said he felt nauseous this morning.

  • Structural Analysis of the Word "So":

    • The word "so" acts as a reasoning connector.

    • In this context, it indicates that what precedes it (he was drunk) is the reason/support for what follows (he is hung over).

  • The Link:

    • Link: C1→S3C_1 \rightarrow S_3

    • The main argument is that Jerry is hung over today, because the first argument regarding his drunkenness feeds into the second.

Practical Exercise 2: River Flooding and Runoff Surges

  • The Conclusions:

    • Conclusion 1 (C1C_1): The river will flood tomorrow (Flag: "probably," "likely").

    • Conclusion 2 (C2C_2): A large runoff surge is just north of us (Flag: "And that means").

  • The Support Systems:

    • Support for C2C_2:

      • Gauge readings show water levels are rising rapidly upstream.

      • Heavy snow melt is moving down from the mountains.

    • Support for C1C_1:

      • Surges upstream usually reach the area within 24 hours.

      • Identified runoff surge is north of us (C2C_2).

  • The Link:

    • Link: C2→SLinkC_2 \rightarrow S_{Link}

    • The order of arguments in a schematization does not matter as long as the tributary link is clearly stated.

Practical Exercise 3: Flight Connections (Double Tributaries)

  • The Three Conclusions:

    • Conclusion 1 (C1C_1): Flight 1 will not arrive on time (Flag: "surely").

    • Conclusion 2 (C2C_2): Flight 2 (to Beijing) will leave on time (Flag: "I suspect").

    • Conclusion 3 (C3C_3): Kim will miss her connection (Flag: "It seems clear").

  • Support and Links:

    • Support for C1C_1: Poor visibility and heavy crosswinds (S1S_1, S2S_2).

    • Support for C2C_2: The plane for Flight 2 is big enough to handle crosswinds (S3S_3).

    • Support for C3C_3: A tight connection between flights (S4S_4); the fact that Flight 1 is late (C1→S5C_1 \rightarrow S_5); the fact that Flight 2 is leaving on time (C2→S6C_2 \rightarrow S_6).

  • Tributary Structure:

    • Link 1: C1→S5C_1 \rightarrow S_5

    • Link 2: C2→S6C_2 \rightarrow S_6

    • Main Argument: Argument 3 (Kim will miss her connection).

Implicit and Tricky Conclusions

  • Theory of Implicit Conclusions:

    • Because humans are naturally competent at reasoning through communication, they often leave conclusions unstated when they are perceived as obvious.

    • In schematization, the analyst must make these implicit claims explicit even if they are only suggested by rhetorical questions or tone.

  • Case Study: Lowering the Drinking Age:

    • Passage: "Are you really thinking of voting in favor of lowering the drinking age? The brain is not fully mature until your early 20s. Alcohol can affect brain development. I don't think teens should be drinking."

    • Implicit Main Conclusion (C2C_2): You should not vote in favor of lowering the drinking age.

    • Tributary Conclusion (C1C_1): Teens should not be drinking (Flag: "I don't think," representing a normative claim).

    • Support for C1C_1: Brain maturity thresholds and alcohol's effect on development.

    • Link: C1→Sfor C2C_1 \rightarrow S_{\text{for } C_2}

Evaluative Practice: Letter to the Editor (Art Center)

  • Conclusion: The Art Center should donate remaining/empty seats to senior citizens and high school drama teachers.

  • Evidence Provided:

    • Evidence 1 (S1S_1): It is a "crying shame" the house is half-empty.

    • Evidence 2 (S2S_2): Performers would rather play to a full house.

    • Evidence 3 (S3S_3): Senior citizens are on restricted fixed incomes and "deserve a break."

    • Evidence 4 (S4S_4): High school students can't afford tickets but would benefit and eventually "benefit us all."

  • Interpretive Debate on S1S_1 vs. S2S_2:

    • Some may argue S1S_1 (empty house is a shame) and S2S_2 (performers want a full house) are restatements.

    • Professor's Stance: They are likely separate. S2S_2 is from the perspective of the performer, whereas S1S_1 implies a broader waste of space and production budget from the perspective of the venue or society.

Future Outlook and Assignment Details

  • Upcoming Topic (Next Week): What motivates arguments? We will explore "Implicit Questions." Every argument is essentially answering a question, even if it is not explicitly stated.

  • Homework Assignments:

    • Practice material will include: The French Air Traffic Investigation and the 5G iPhone burning case study.

    • The goal is to refine the skill of seeing argument structure before moving into argument motivation.