Choosing Reinforcers and Preference Assessments Notes

Fundamentals of Functional Consequences and Reinforcement

  • Functional Consequences in Behavior Change:

    • Successful behavior modification requires the systematically structured application of functional consequences.
    • Reinforcement procedures are explicitly utilized whenever the primary goal is to increase and strengthen a specific behavior.
  • Definition of Reinforcement:

    • Reinforcement is a functional process in which a specific behavior is immediately followed by a consequence, resulting in an increased probability of that behavior occurring again under similar conditions in the future.
    • Behavior that experiences functional reinforcement demonstrates a higher future frequency of occurrence.
  • The Three-Term Contingency Framework:

    • Antecedent: An environmental event, stimulus, or condition that occurs immediately prior to the emission of the target behavior.
    • Behavior: The observable and measurable response emitted by the learner.
    • Consequence: The environmental change, event, or stimulus that immediately follows the performance of the target behavior.
    • Functional Criterion: A consequence is classified as a reinforcer if and only if the future frequency of the target behavior increases following the consequence delivery.
  • Determinants of Procedural Success:

    • The efficacy of any reinforcement procedure depends directly on the effectiveness and potency of the specific reinforcer selected.
    • Systematic preference identification is necessary to isolate strong, effective reinforcers.
  • Categories of Potential Reinforcers:

    • Edibles and food items.
    • Toys and tangible objects.
    • Activities and recreational tasks.
    • Social interactions.
    • Verbal and non-verbal praise.

Reinforcer Delivery and Individualization Principles

  • Potency Allocation Rule:

    • When implementing reinforcement protocols, the most potent and high-value reinforcers must be systematically reserved for target responses that are performed with the highest level of independence and require the minimum amount of prompting or assistance.
  • Individualization of Reinforcers:

    • Reinforcer value is entirely idiosyncratic; an item, stimulus, or activity that is highly preferred or desirable for one learner does not automatically possess reinforcing value for another learner.
    • Identifying individualized reinforcers requires combining informal and formal preference assessment methods.
  • Reinforcer Variation and Motivation:

    • Reinforcers must be systematically varied across sessions and time to maintain high learner motivation and prevent satiation.
    • Learners must be routinely exposed to novel items and activities to expand their prospective reinforcer pool.
  • Pairing Unconditioned and Conditioned Reinforcers:

    • If a learner responds exclusively to edible reinforcers (primary reinforcers), practitioners must consistently pair food delivery with social praise (secondary/conditioned stimulus).
    • Systematic pairing must continue until social praise independently acquires reinforcing properties and functions as a standalone reinforcer.

Informal Methods for Preference Identification

  • Overview of Informal Identification:

    • Informal methods allow practitioners to identify candidate reinforcers without standard structured presentation arrays.
    • The five primary informal methods are: Asking, Watching, Sampling, Offering Choices, and Try and See.
  • Method 11: Asking

    • Direct Learner Inquiry:
      • Involves directly interviewing or asking the learner what items, activities, or conditions they like or desire.
      • The learner's explicit verbal or gestural responses inform the selection of candidate reinforcers.
    • Key Considerations:
      • Learner desires and preferences are dynamic and shift across time; continuous check-ins and re-questioning regarding needs and likes are mandatory.
      • Preferences may be highly situation-specific or context-dependent (e.g., a learner may like swinging, but strictly on a specific type or model of swing).
      • Practitioners must gather exhaustive collateral details regarding all physical and environmental parameters of preferred reinforcers.
    • Indirect Informant Interviews:
      • When working with non-communicative learners who cannot express preferences verbally or symbolically, practitioners must interview key collateral stakeholders who know the individual intimately.
      • Informants include family members, primary caregivers, behavioral therapists, and classroom teachers.
  • Method 22: Watching (Direct Observation)

    • Practitioners observe the learner during unstructured playtime and leisure periods to document which items or activities the learner independently selects and interacts with.
    • Observing leisure periods shared with primary caregivers helps identify preferred tangibles, preferred high-probability activities, and restricted or narrowed patterns of interest.
  • Method 33: Reinforcer Sampling

    • Objective: Designed to expand a learner's restricted interest repertoire and establish new functional reinforcers.
    • Procedure: Expose the learner to brief samples of novel potential reinforcers that the student has not previously experienced or interacted with, followed by active encouragement to engage with the novel stimuli.
    • Application Examples:
      • Exposing learners to novel board games or recreational activities during leisure time that they have never previously played.
      • Addressing restricted interests: If a learner demonstrates a narrow interest in trains (e.g., exclusively playing with one specific toy train while ignoring all other toys), the practitioner sets out various distinct toy trains alongside non-train toys. The practitioner directly models active, play interaction with the diverse toys and trains, explicitly inviting and encouraging the learner to sample them.
  • Method 44: Offering Choices

    • Menu Presentation:
      • Provide the learner with a structured list or menu displaying a limited selection of available items.
      • Formats include pictorial menus (picture form) or written text lists.
    • Contingent Delivery Mechanics:
      • The learner selects a preferred item from the menu.
      • The practitioner delivers the chosen item immediately following both the selection AND the learner's completion of a targeted desirable behavior.
  • Method 55: Try and See

    • Procedure: Initiated when a learner exhibits an implicit or explicit indication of wanting to engage with a novel item or activity. Practitioners introduce the novel stimulus into the environment and attempt to deploy it directly as a contingent consequence.
    • Functional Determination:
      • If the target behavior recurs or increases in future trials, the stimulus functions validly as a reinforcer.
      • If the target behavior fails to recur or increase, the stimulus does not function as a reinforcer, regardless of initial demonstrated interest.

Standardized Formal Preference Assessments

  • Definition and Core Mechanics:

    • Formal preference assessments are standardized, empirical procedures used to determine an individual's specific preference hierarchy.
    • Methodology involves systematically presenting an array of items in a structured format while collecting quantitative data on:
      • Selection frequency (how often an item is chosen).
      • Engagement frequency and duration (how long and how frequently an item is actively manipulated or interacted with).
    • Data analysis establishes a validated hierarchy of potential reinforcers.
  • Universal Prerequisite:

    • Prior to initiating any formal preference assessment format, practitioners must pre-select and assemble the specific group of target items to be evaluated.
  • Formal Assessment Formats Covered:

    • Single Stimulus Preference Assessment.
    • Paired Stimulus Preference Assessment.
    • Multiple Stimulus Preference Assessment.

Single Stimulus Preference Assessment

  • Administration Protocol:

    • Target items are presented individually, one item at a time (singly), to the learner.
    • Sequential Operational Steps:
      1. Present a single stimulus directly in front of the learner.
      2. Observe and record whether the learner approaches the item (e.g., reaching, leaning, touching).
      3. Observe and record whether the learner actively engages with the item.
      4. Record qualitative notes on how the learner interacts with the item.
      5. Measure and record the exact duration of time the learner remains engaged with the item.
      6. Repeat steps 11 through 55 sequentially for every item in the identified assessment pool.
  • Target Learner Profile and Clinical Indications:

    • Learners who cannot visually scan a field, array, or multi-item presentation.
    • Learners who fail to differentiate between preferred items when presented concurrently in pairs or groups.
    • Learners who cannot make clear choices (or any choices at all) between competing items.
    • Learners who do not possess an established, broad pool of reinforcers.
  • Datasheet Structure and Data Mechanics:

    • Header Fields: Learner Name, Assessor Name, Date, and the list of selected target items.
    • Choice Tracking: Presentation order logged sequentially, labeled as aa, bb, cc, dd, and ee under the choice column.
    • Recorded Variables:
      • Approach vs. Non-approach.
      • Engagement vs. Non-engagement.
      • Total duration of engagement.
      • Occurrences of problem behavior during stimulus presentation.
    • Output Analysis: Items are quantitatively ranked at the bottom of the sheet from highest preferred to lowest preferred based on aggregated approach, engagement, and duration metrics.

Paired Stimulus Preference Assessment

  • Administration Protocol:

    • Items are presented using a forced-choice pairwise layout (testing two items simultaneously per trial) to directly compare relative preference between items.
    • Compares all items directly to generate a complete comparative hierarchy from most preferred to least preferred.
    • Sequential Operational Steps:
      1. Gather the target pool of items and assign a unique numeric identifier to each item.
      2. Present exactly two items simultaneously in front of the learner.
      3. Allow the learner to select one item and engage directly with it.
      4. Immediately remove the unchosen remaining item from the learner's reach and field of view.
      5. Present the next scheduled pair of items.
      6. Repeat the pairwise presentation process systematically until every single item in the pool has been paired against every other item (all possible pairwise combinations evaluated).
      7. Calculate the percentage of total trials in which each specific item was chosen when offered.
      8. Rank items based on choice percentages to establish a definitive preference hierarchy (most chosen items represent the highest preferred reinforcers).
  • Datasheet Structure and Data Mechanics:

    • Header Fields: Learner Name, Assessor Name, Date, and Target Items tested.
    • Pairwise Data Matrix: Contains individual data boxes displaying all item combination pairs.
    • Scoring Mechanics: The assessor circles the specific item selected by the learner in each paired box.
    • Output Analysis: Total choices per item are tallied at the bottom of the datasheet, converted to selection percentages, and ranked sequentially from highest preferred to lowest preferred.

Multiple Stimulus Preference Assessment

  • Administration Protocol:

    • Presents more than two items simultaneously (a multi-item array) arranged in a straight horizontal line in front of the learner.
    • Systematically compares item selections to construct a complete preference hierarchy.
    • Sequential Operational Steps:
      1. Gather target items and place them simultaneously in a straight horizontal line directly in front of the learner, maintaining equal distance (equidistant) between all items.
      2. Assign a precise spatial position number to each location in the line array.
      3. Instruct or prompt the learner to select an item from the array.
      4. Allow the learner to engage with the chosen item and log which item was selected.
      5. Rearrange the remaining unchosen items in the array according to a standardized rotation rule: move the item located on the extreme right of the line so that it becomes the first item on the extreme left of the line.
      6. Reassign array location starting numbers to reflect the newly shifted spatial layout.
      7. Repeat the selection, logging, and right-to-left rotation steps until only one item remains unselected in the array.
  • Target Learner Profile and Clinical Indications:

    • Requires the learner to possess visual scanning skills and the functional capacity to choose among multiple competing stimuli.
    • Extremely efficient protocol for rapidly ranking items into an empirical preference hierarchy.
  • Datasheet Structure and Data Mechanics:

    • Header Fields: Learner Name, Assessor Name, Date, and Target Items tested.
    • Location Tracking Grid: Items are tracked across specific spatial array positions across successive trials.
    • Scoring Mechanics: The selected item is circled on the graph corresponding to its specific location placement during that trial.
    • Output Analysis: Total selections for each item are summed following assessment completion, allowing items to be rank-ordered from highest preferred to lowest preferred.